Zipf's Law for All the Natural Cities in the United States: A Geospatial Perspective

Bin Jiang, Tao Jia

Abstract: This paper provides a new geospatial perspective on whether or not Zipf's law holds for all cities or for the largest cities in the United States using a massive dataset and its computing. A major problem around this issue is how to define cities or city boundaries. Most of the investigations of Zipf's law rely on the demarcations of cities imposed by census data, e.g., metropolitan areas and census-designated places. These demarcations or definitions (of cities) are criticized for being subjective or even arbitrary. Alternative solutions to defining cities are suggested, but they still rely on census data for their definitions. In this paper we demarcate urban agglomerations by clustering street nodes (including intersections and ends), forming what we call natural cities. Based on the demarcation, we found that Zipf's law holds remarkably well for all the natural cities (over 2-4 million in total) across the United States. There is little sensitivity for the holding with respect to the clustering resolution used for demarcating the natural cities. This is a big contrast to urban areas, as defined in the census data, which do not hold stable for Zipf's law.

Introduction

For decades, urban geographers and economists have debated Zipf’s Law: the observation that the second-largest city in a country is half the size of the largest, the third is one-third the size, and so on. Mathematically, this is a power law distribution with an exponent near 1.0. However, a persistent challenge in this field is the definition of a city. Most studies rely on administrative boundaries, such as Metropolitan Statistical Areas, which are often subjective or politically motivated. These "top-down" definitions frequently result in Zipf’s Law appearing to hold only for the largest cities while failing for smaller settlements. This paper argues that by using arbitrary boundaries, our understanding of urban scaling is fundamentally flawed.

Redefining Urban Boundaries: The "Natural City"

To address the limitations of administrative data, this study proposes a "bottom-up" approach to defining cities, termed Natural Cities. This method assumes that human activity is primarily constrained by physical infrastructure. By extracting over 24 million street nodes (intersections and dead-ends) from OpenStreetMap (OSM) data, the researchers used these nodes as a proxy for human settlement.

Visualizing natural cities through clustered street nodes.

Using a City Clustering Algorithm (CCA), street nodes were grouped based on a specified "clustering resolution" or radius. If nodes fall within this radius, they are considered part of the same natural city. This approach identified between 2 and 4 million natural cities across the US, ranging from isolated dwellings to the massive New York City megalopolis. This method effectively ignores legal boundaries to focus on the organic physical network of human habitation.

Universal Scaling and Statistical Rigor

The study tested four different clustering radii (400m, 500m, 600m, and 700m) to ensure the results were not dependent on a specific distance setting. Unlike census-defined urban areas, which showed unstable exponents and failed statistical tests for a true power law, natural cities followed Zipf’s Law across the entire distribution.

Power law distribution of natural cities across multiple clustering resolutions.

Statistical analysis using Maximum Likelihood Estimation (MLE) and Kolmogorov-Smirnov (KS) tests confirmed that the power law exponent ($\alpha$) for natural cities was consistently around 2.0, which corresponds to a Zipf exponent of 1.0. The high $p$-values (often 0.8 to 0.9) indicate an exceptional fit to the model, suggesting that the underlying structure of human settlement is "scale-free" and self-organizing at every level of the hierarchy.

Conclusion

By shifting from administrative to geospatial definitions, this research demonstrates that Zipf’s Law is a universal property of human settlement in the United States. The "natural city" concept reveals a striking 90/10 imbalance—where 90% of settlements are small and 10% are large—characteristic of self-organized systems. While the law holds for the country as a whole, state-level variations suggest that local geography and economic evolution still play a role in shaping the specific heterogeneity of city sizes. This study highlights the power of data-intensive geospatial computing in uncovering fundamental laws of urban geography.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper provides a new geospatial perspective on whether or not Zipf's law holds for all cities or for the largest cities in the United States using a massive dataset and its computing. A major problem around this issue is how to define cities or city boundaries. Most of the investigations of Zipf's law rely on the demarcations of cities imposed by census data, e.g., metropolitan areas and census-designated places. These demarcations or definitions (of cities) are criticized for being subjective or even arbitrary. Alternative solutions to defining cities are suggested, but they still rely on census data for their definitions. In this paper we demarcate urban agglomerations by clustering street nodes (including intersections and ends), forming what we call natural cities. Based on the demarcation, we found that Zipf's law holds remarkably well for all the natural cities (over 2-4 million in total) across the United States. There is little sensitivity for the holding with respect to the clustering resolution used for demarcating the natural cities. This is a big contrast to urban areas, as defined in the census data, which do not hold stable for Zipf's law. Keywords: Natural cities, power law, data-intensive geospatial computing, scaling of geographic space
BibTeX
@article{jiang2011zipf,
  author = {Bin Jiang and Tao Jia},
  title = {{Zipf's Law for All the Natural Cities in the United States: A Geospatial Perspective}},
  journal = {International Journal of Geographical Information Systems},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1080/13658816.2010.510801},
}
Figure