Zero-Shot Constrained Motion Planning Transformers Using Learned Sampling Dictionaries

Jacob J. Johnson, Ahmed H. Qureshi, Michael C. Yip

TL;DR

This paper introduces CVQ-MPT, a novel zero-shot motion planning framework that significantly improves efficiency and accuracy for robots performing tasks with constraints. By leveraging a pre-trained transformer model and a gradient-based optimization technique, CVQ-MPT learns to sample more effectively near constraint manifolds, reducing planning time and path length without requiring task-specific training data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Robots operating in real-world environments often need to perform tasks that involve more than just reaching a goal configuration; they must also adhere to specific constraints. These constraints can range from maintaining a robot's end-effector orientation to avoiding collisions with dynamic objects or ensuring a container isn't spilled. Traditional motion planning methods, especially sampling-based planners (like RRT), struggle with these constraints. They often reject a large number of sampled points that fall outside the "constraint manifold" (the set of valid configurations satisfying the constraints), leading to inefficient planning and long computation times, particularly in high-dimensional spaces. While some learning-based approaches exist, they typically require extensive task-specific data for training, limiting their generalizability. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a method that can efficiently solve constrained motion planning problems in a "zero-shot" manner, meaning it requires no new training data for new tasks.

Methods

The core of the proposed method, CVQ-MPT (Constraint Vector Quantized-Motion Planning Transformer), builds upon a pre-trained VQ-MPT model. This model, originally designed for unconstrained motion planning, learns a "dictionary" of latent representations that can generate distributions of possible robot configurations. CVQ-MPT adapts this for constrained planning in two key ways:

  1. Zero-Shot Adaptation: Instead of retraining the VQ-MPT model for each new constraint, CVQ-MPT uses the pre-trained model directly. It then employs a gradient-based optimization technique to refine the predicted distributions from the VQ-MPT model. This optimization aims to shift these distributions closer to the constraint manifold.
  2. Gradient-Based Distribution Update: The paper formulates a loss function based on how well sampled points from the predicted distributions satisfy the constraint function ($G(q) = F(q)^T F(q)$). By minimizing an upper bound of this loss using Markov's inequality, the latent variables that generate these distributions are updated. This process effectively "pulls" the sampling regions towards the constraint manifold, making subsequent sampling more efficient.
  3. Projection and Planning: After generating samples from the updated distributions, a standard projection operator (Algorithm 1) is used to ensure sampled points strictly lie on the constraint manifold. A bidirectional sampling-based planner (Algorithm 3) then uses these refined samples to construct a collision-free, constraint-satisfying trajectory.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention new datasets for training. Instead, it leverages pre-trained VQ-MPT and MPNet models from prior work [6] which were trained on simulated data for unconstrained shortest trajectories. The evaluation is performed on simulated environments and a physical Franka Panda robot using real-world sensor data (point clouds).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Leveraging Pre-trained Models for Constraints: The most significant insight is that a powerful pre-trained model for unconstrained planning can be effectively adapted for constrained planning without task-specific fine-tuning. This "zero-shot" capability is a major step towards more generalizable robotic planning.
  • Optimizing Latent Distributions for Constraints: Instead of just projecting samples after they are generated, optimizing the latent representations that generate the samples is a more efficient approach. This proactively guides the sampling process towards the desired manifold.
  • Improved Sampling Efficiency: By making sampling regions closer to the constraint manifold, the number of samples that need to be projected or rejected is drastically reduced, leading to faster planning.
  • Generalization to Real-World Data: The success of CVQ-MPT on a physical robot using real sensor data demonstrates its robustness and ability to generalize beyond simulated environments.

Key Results

  • Planning Time Reduction: CVQ-MPT achieved approximately a 2x improvement in planning times compared to previous methods on the "Place Task." For a multi-sequence task, it reduced total planning time by 45%.
  • Shorter Trajectories: The generated trajectories were 35%-40% shorter compared to previous SMPs, leading to improved task execution times.
  • High Accuracy: CVQ-MPT achieved high accuracy (e.g., 98.42% for the Place Task) in solving planning problems, comparable to or better than traditional and other learning-based methods.
  • Physical Robot Performance: The method demonstrated comparable performance on a physical robot to simulated environments, showcasing its real-world applicability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Constraint Function Definition: The current work focuses on constraint functions defined on joint configurations, not on complex robot kinematics or dynamics.
  • Probabilistic Completeness: While the paper argues for probabilistic completeness based on the underlying SMP and projection operator, the optimization of latent variables might introduce nuances not fully explored.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring the application of CVQ-MPT to more complex task and motion planning problems, implying potential extensions to dynamic constraints or more intricate multi-robot scenarios. They also highlight the potential for this approach to be broadly useful for transferring learned neural planners to various robotic-environment interaction scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

Constrained robot motion planning is a ubiquitous need for robots interacting with everyday environments, but it is a notoriously difficult problem to solve. Many sampled points in a sample-based planner need to be rejected as they fall outside the constraint manifold, or require significant iterative effort to correct. Given this, few solutions exist that present a constraint-satisfying trajectory for robots, in reasonable time and of low path cost. In this work, we present a transformer-based model for motion planning with task space constraints for manipulation systems. Vector Quantized-Motion Planning Transformer (VQ-MPT) is a recent learning-based model that reduces the search space for unconstrained planning for sampling-based motion planners. We propose to adapt a pre-trained VQ-MPT model to reduce the search space for constraint planning without retraining or finetuning the model. We also propose to update the neural network output to move sampling regions closer to the constraint manifold. Our experiments show how VQ-MPT improves planning times and accuracy compared to traditional planners in simulated and real-world environments. Unlike previous learning methods, which require task-related data, our method uses pre-trained neural network models and requires no additional data for training and finetuning the model making this a \textit{one-shot} process. We also tested our method on a physical Franka Panda robot with real-world sensor data, demonstrating the generalizability of our algorithm. We anticipate this approach to be an accessible and broadly useful for transferring learned neural planners to various robotic-environment interaction scenarios.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{johnson2024zero,
  author = {Jacob J. Johnson and Ahmed H. Qureshi and Michael C. Yip},
  title = {{Zero-Shot Constrained Motion Planning Transformers Using Learned Sampling Dictionaries}},
  booktitle = {IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1109/icra57147.2024.10611398},
}
Figure