Who is listening? Spokesperson Effect on Communicating Social and Physical Distancing Measures During the COVID-19 Pandemic

Ahmad Abu‐Akel, Andreas Spitz, Robert West

Abstract

Effective communication during the COVID-19 pandemic can save lives. At the present time, social and physical distancing measures are the lead strategy in combatting the spread of COVID-19. In this pilot, survey-based study, we obtained responses from 705 adults in Switzerland about their support and practice of social distancing measures to examine if these responses are: (1) influenced by whether these measures are supported by an internationally recognized celebrity or a government official, (2) dependent on whether the spokesperson is liked, and (3) age-dependent. We also considered several attitudinal and demographic variables that may influence the degree to which people support and comply with social distancing measures. We found that the government official was more effective, particularly in response to current compliance with social distancing measures, and was substantially stronger among older respondents despite having lower risk perception. Being liked seems to boost this effect. In addition, respondents’ greater support and compliance was positively associated with (1) higher concern for the current situation, (2) higher concern for the well-being of others, (3) greater belief that others are practicing social distancing, (4) feeling greater constraint in freedom of movement, and negatively with (5) city size, and (6) household size. Since different parts of the population appear to have different perceptions of risk and crisis, our preliminary results suggest that different spokespersons may be needed for the younger and the older populations, and for rural and urban populations. The development of evidence-based knowledge is required to further identify who would be the most effective spokesperson, and in particular to groups with low risk perception and low compliance.

Introduction

Public health officials face a daunting challenge: how do you convince millions of people to radically alter their behavior overnight? While celebrity endorsements are a staple of marketing and political campaigning, their efficacy during a "real-time" global crisis is understudied. This study sought to determine if the source of a message—a celebrity (Tom Hanks) versus a government official (Simonetta Sommaruga, then-President of the Swiss Confederation)—significantly alters public support and compliance with social distancing measures.

Methods

The researchers conducted a pilot, survey-based study using two identical online surveys distributed to 705 adults in Switzerland between March 22–27, 2020. The only difference between the two surveys was the attributed spokesperson:

  • Condition A: Social distancing measures supported by Tom Hanks.
  • Condition B: Measures supported by Simonetta Sommaruga.

The sample included 447 Facebook users (mean age ~42) and 258 university students (mean age ~21). Multivariate regressions were used to analyze the impact of the spokesperson on three outcome measures: support for social distancing, current practice, and future intentions. The team controlled for variables including religiosity, city size, household size, and perceived risk.

Results

The Spokesperson Effect

Contrary to the initial prediction that a liked celebrity would be more influential, the government official was more effective at encouraging current compliance. The government official had a small but statistically significant effect on the reporting of current practice of social distancing ($F(1, 688) = 5.07, p = 0.025, \text{Cohen’s } d = 0.17$). This suggests a "rally 'round the flag" effect where citizens look to formal leadership for guidance during existential threats.

Spokesperson effect on social distancing scores for government officials vs. celebrity actors.

Age and Compliance

The study revealed an "Age-Compliance Paradox." Older respondents showed significantly higher support and compliance than younger respondents, despite having a lower perception of personal risk. The spokesperson effect was nearly twice as robust in the older group ($d = 0.20$) compared to the younger group ($d = 0.11$). This suggests that for older populations, compliance is driven more by civic duty or concern for others than by personal fear.

Age differences in social distancing and attitudinal measures, with corresponding effect sizes (Cohen's d).

Attitudinal and Demographic Drivers

  • Altruism: One of the strongest predictors of compliance was "concern for the well-being of others," highlighting that prosocial messaging may be more effective than fear-based messaging.
  • Physical Constraints: Compliance was negatively associated with city size and household size, indicating that urban density and crowded living conditions make distancing pragmatically difficult.
  • Likability: While the official was more effective overall, being "liked" by the respondent trended toward higher endorsement of measures across both spokesperson types.

Discussion

The findings indicate that in a high-stakes communication environment, the public prioritizes official gravitas over celebrity influence. However, the challenge is persuasion rather than information, as 98.3% of respondents were already aware of the measures.

Limitations include the reliance on self-reported data, which is subject to social desirability bias, and a narrow comparison between only two spokespersons. Future work will expand this analysis to include data from six different countries to determine if these effects hold across different cultural and political landscapes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Effective communication during the COVID-19 pandemic can save lives. At the present time, social and physical distancing measures are the lead strategy in combatting the spread of COVID-19. In this pilot, survey-based study, we obtained responses from 705 adults in Switzerland about their support and practice of social distancing measures to examine if these responses are: (1) influenced by whether these measures are supported by an internationally recognized celebrity or a government official, (2) dependent on whether the spokesperson is liked, and (3) age-dependent. We also considered several attitudinal and demographic variables that may influence the degree to which people support and comply with social distancing measures. We found that the government official was more effective, particularly in response to current compliance with social distancing measures, and was substantially stronger among older respondents despite having lower risk perception. Being liked seems to boost this effect. In addition, respondents’ greater support and compliance was positively associated with (1) higher concern for the current situation, (2) higher concern for the well-being of others, (3) greater belief that others are practicing social distancing, (4) feeling greater constraint in freedom of movement, and negatively with (5) city size, and (6) household size. Since different parts of the population appear to have different perceptions of risk and crisis, our preliminary results suggest that different spokespersons may be needed for the younger and the older populations, and for rural and urban populations. The development of evidence-based knowledge is required to further identify who would be the most effective spokesperson, and in particular to groups with low risk perception and low compliance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{abuakel2021who,
  author = {Ahmad Abu‐Akel and Andreas Spitz and Robert West},
  title = {{Who is listening? Spokesperson Effect on Communicating Social and Physical Distancing Measures During the COVID-19 Pandemic}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2020.564434},
}
Figure