Abstract
Effective communication during a pandemic, such as the COVID-19 crisis, can save lives. Social and physical distancing measures are the lead strategy in combating the spread of the virus. This study surveyed 705 adults in Switzerland to examine if their support and practice of social distancing depended on the type of spokesperson (government official vs. internationally recognized celebrity), the spokesperson's likeability, and the respondent's age. Results indicated that the government official was more effective in eliciting responses supportive of social distancing, particularly among older respondents. Furthermore, compliance was positively associated with concern for the situation, concern for others, and the belief that others were also complying. These findings suggest that different segments of the population may require tailored communication strategies and specific spokespersons to maximize public health compliance.
Introduction
At the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, social and physical distancing became the primary tools for saving lives. However, the effectiveness of these measures depends entirely on public cooperation. During the critical window of March 2020, governments worldwide scrambled to find the best way to communicate these rules, often alternating between formal addresses by heads of state and awareness campaigns featuring celebrities.
This study sought to determine if the "spokesperson effect" influences behavior. Does a message carry more weight when it comes from a high-ranking official or a universally liked celebrity? Furthermore, the researchers investigated how demographic factors (like age) and psychological factors (like empathy and risk perception) interact with these messages to determine who complies.
Methods
The researchers conducted a randomized online survey of 705 adults in Switzerland between March 22 and 27, 2020—a period just days after the Swiss government declared an "extraordinary situation." Participants were randomly assigned to one of two groups receiving identical information about social distancing but from different sources:
- Official Source: Simonetta Sommaruga (then-President of the Swiss Confederation).
- Celebrity Source: Tom Hanks (who had recently publicized his own COVID-19 diagnosis).
The study measured support for distancing, current compliance, and future intent to comply. The sample included 447 Facebook users and 258 university students. To ensure representativeness, Weighted Least Squares (WLS) regressions were used to adjust for the sample's skew toward female and highly educated participants.
Key Insights and Results
The Authority Effect
Contrary to the hypothesis that a "liked" celebrity would be more persuasive due to personal connection, the government official was more effective. In times of high uncertainty, people tend to look toward formal leadership for authoritative guidance. The government official had a statistically significant effect on the current practice of social distancing ($d = 0.17, p = 0.025$) compared to the celebrity.
Age and the Compliance-Risk Paradox
Older respondents (37–80 years) showed significantly higher compliance than younger respondents (17–36 years). Interestingly, the government official’s influence was nearly twice as strong in the older group ($d = 0.20$) compared to the younger group ($d = 0.11$). Surprisingly, the older group reported lower risk perception regarding the virus's spread, suggesting their compliance was driven by civic duty rather than personal fear.
Psychosocial Drivers of Compliance
Compliance was strongly associated with "pro-sociality"—the concern for the well-being of others. Additionally, the belief that others in the community were practicing distancing (social norms) was a major predictor of individual behavior.
As shown in the correlation matrix, current practice of social distancing (Current.Practice.SD) is positively correlated with age, concern for the situation, and the perception of others' practices. Conversely, it was negatively correlated with household size and self-reported mobility.
Discussion and Limitations
The study highlights that a "one-size-fits-all" communication strategy is likely insufficient. While officials are effective for reaching older citizens, different messengers—perhaps scientists or medical doctors—may be required to engage younger groups who show lower compliance.
Limitations include self-reporting bias, where participants may over-report compliance due to social desirability. Additionally, the study was limited to one specific cultural context (Switzerland) and a limited variety of spokespersons. Future work should investigate the effectiveness of "micro-influencers" or medical experts across different cultural and political landscapes.
Summary updated