Weyl nodal ring states and Landau quantization with very large magnetoresistance in square-net magnet EuGa$_4$

Shiming Lei, Kevin Allen, Jianwei Huang, Jaime M. Moya, Tsz Chun Wu, Brian Casas, Yichen Zhang, Ji Seop Oh, Makoto Hashimoto, Dong-Hui Lu, Jonathan D. Denlinger, Chris Jozwiak, Aaron Bostwick, Eli Rotenberg, Luis Balicas, R. J. Birgeneau, Matthew S. Foster, Ming Yi, Yan Sun, E. Morosan

TL;DR

Researchers have identified the square-net compound $\text{EuGa}_4$ as a rare magnetic Weyl nodal ring semimetal. It exhibits a colossal, non-saturating transverse magnetoresistance exceeding 200,000% at 14 Tesla—orders of magnitude higher than most known magnetic topological materials—driven by unique topological band crossings that naturally suppress the Hall effect.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Topological semimetals (TSMs) are materials where electronic bands cross in ways that create "protected" states, leading to exotic properties like high carrier mobility and unusual responses to magnetic fields. Magnetic TSMs are particularly exciting because their topological properties can be tuned by manipulating their spin configuration (e.g., with an external field).

Among these, Weyl nodal-line (NL) semimetals—where bands cross along a line rather than at isolated points—are theoretically the most tunable. However, they are difficult to study because there are very few material candidates where these line nodes are close enough to the Fermi level to dominate the material's behavior. The authors sought to identify a new magnetic Weyl NL candidate and understand the origin of its extreme transport properties.

Methods

The team used a multi-pronged approach to characterize $\text{EuGa}_4$:

  • Crystal Growth: Single crystals were grown using a gallium self-flux technique.
  • ARPES (Angle-Resolved Photoemission Spectroscopy): This allowed the researchers to directly image the electronic band structure and confirm the existence of nodal-line states in the paramagnetic phase.
  • Quantum Oscillations (Shubnikov–de Haas effect): By measuring oscillations in resistivity at high magnetic fields and low temperatures, they mapped the Fermi surface geometry and determined carrier mobility and effective mass.
  • Magnetotransport: They measured magnetoresistance (MR) in extreme conditions, including high-field facilities up to 40 Tesla.
  • Theory: Density Functional Theory (DFT) was used to model the bands, and a kinetic theory model was developed to explain why the MR doesn't saturate.

Datasets

As an experimental physics paper, it does not use standard machine learning datasets. Instead, it generates original experimental data:

  • Spectroscopic Data: ARPES intensity maps across various photon energies and temperatures.
  • Transport Data: Resistivity and Hall effect measurements as a function of temperature and magnetic field.
  • Comparative Benchmark: The authors compiled a table (Table S1) comparing the MR of $\text{EuGa}_4$ against other famous TSMs like $\text{Na}_3\text{Bi}$, $\text{TaAs}$, and $\text{WTe}_2$.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Square-Net Advantage: The "square-net" arrangement of atoms is a fertile ground for topological states. In $\text{EuGa}_4$, the combination of this lattice, spin-orbit coupling, and mirror symmetry protection allows for the formation of stable Weyl nodal rings.
  • Symmetry-Driven Topology: The Weyl nodal rings are only "guaranteed" when the material is in a spin-polarized state (where all spins align with the external field). In the zero-field antiferromagnetic state, these specific topological features are absent.
  • A New Mechanism for Non-Saturating MR: Usually, for magnetoresistance to keep growing indefinitely with the field (non-saturation), a material needs a perfect balance of electrons and holes (compensation). $\text{EuGa}_4$ isn't perfectly compensated. Instead, the authors show that in a Weyl nodal ring system, the Fermi velocity reverses sign across the ring. This causes the Hall conductivity to vanish, which mathematically prevents the MR from saturating.
  • High Quantum Mobility: The material exhibits exceptionally high quantum mobility (up to $1630 \text{ cm}^2/\text{Vs}$), which is an order of magnitude higher than other magnetic Weyl semimetals like $\text{Co}_3\text{Sn}_2\text{S}_2$.

Key Results

  • Colossal Magnetoresistance: At 2 K and 14 T, the MR exceeds 200,000%. At 0.4 K and 40 T, it reaches nearly 500,000%.
  • No Saturation: Unlike many metals where MR levels off at high fields, $\text{EuGa}_4$ shows a power-law increase ($\sim H^{1.8}$) up to the highest tested fields (40 T).
  • Landau Quantization: The researchers observed clear spin-splitting in the quantum oscillations, providing a direct look at how the magnetic field quantizes the electronic orbits of the Weyl NR states.
  • Phase Transition: The material transitions from an A-type antiferromagnet to a spin-polarized state at a critical field of $\sim 7.4$ T, which is exactly where the "upturn" in MR begins.

Limitations and Future Work

  • ARPES Resolution: The current ARPES measurements couldn't resolve the subtle changes in the band structure exactly at the antiferromagnetic transition temperature ($T_N = 16.3$ K). The authors suggest future high-resolution laser-ARPES is needed.
  • The $\gamma$ Pockets: While the large $\alpha$ and $\beta$ pockets are well-understood, the contribution of the smaller $\gamma$ pockets to the transport properties requires more specialized theoretical treatment (the $\mu \to 0$ limit).
  • Spintronic Applications: While the MR is massive, it occurs at very low temperatures and high fields. Future research will likely focus on finding similar square-net magnets that exhibit these effects closer to room temperature and at lower fields.

Summary updated

Abstract

Magnetic topological semimetals (TSMs) allow for an effective control of the topological electronic states by tuning the spin configuration, and therefore are promising materials for next-generation electronic and spintronic applications. Of magnetic TSMs, Weyl nodal-line (NL) semimetals likely have the most tunability, and yet they are the least experimentally studied so far due to the scarcity of material candidates. Here, using a combination of angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy and quantum oscillation measurements, together with density functional theory calculations, we identify the square-net compound EuGa4 as a new magnetic Weyl nodal ring (NR) semimetal, in which the line nodes form closed rings in the vicinity of the Fermi level. Remarkably, the Weyl NR states show distinct Landau quantization with clear spin splitting upon application of a magnetic field. At 2 K in a field of 14 T, the transverse magnetoresistance of EuGa4 exceeds 200,000%, which is more than two orders of magnitude larger than that of other known magnetic TSMs. High field magnetoresistance measurements indicate no saturation up to 40 T. Our theoretical model indicates that the nonsaturating MR naturally arises as a consequence of the Weyl NR state. Our work thus point to the realization of Weyl NR states in square-net magnetic materials, and opens new avenues for the design of magnetic TSMs with very large magnetoresistance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lei2023weyl,
  author = {Shiming Lei and Kevin Allen and Jianwei Huang and Jaime M. Moya and Tsz Chun Wu and Brian Casas and Yichen Zhang and Ji Seop Oh and Makoto Hashimoto and Dong-Hui Lu and Jonathan D. Denlinger and Chris Jozwiak and Aaron Bostwick and Eli Rotenberg and Luis Balicas and R. J. Birgeneau and Matthew S. Foster and Ming Yi and Yan Sun and E. Morosan},
  title = {{Weyl nodal ring states and Landau quantization with very large magnetoresistance in square-net magnet EuGa$\_4$}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-023-40767-z},
}
Figure