Volume of representations and mapping degree

Pierre Derbez, Yi Liu, Hongbin Sun, Shicheng Wang

Authors: Pierre Derbez, Yi Liu, Hongbin Sun, and Shicheng Wang

Abstract

Given a connected real Lie group $G$ and a contractible homogeneous proper $G$-space $X$ furnished with a $G$-invariant volume form, a real-valued volume can be assigned to any representation $\rho: \pi_1(M) \to G$ for any oriented closed smooth manifold $M$ of the same dimension as $X$. Suppose that $G$ contains a closed and cocompact semisimple subgroup; it is shown in this paper that the set of volumes is finite for any given $M$. From a perspective of model geometries, examples are investigated and applications with mapping degrees are discussed.

Introduction

In the study of geometric topology, a fundamental question involves the existence and nature of maps between manifolds. Specifically, mathematicians often seek to determine the "degree" of a map—a topological integer that describes how many times one manifold wraps around another. A central problem in this field is identifying which manifolds satisfy Property D, meaning the set of mapping degrees between them is finite.

To address this, Mikhail Gromov introduced the concept of simplicial volume, which provides a lower bound on mapping degrees. However, simplicial volume is not a universal solution; it vanishes for many important classes of manifolds, such as Seifert manifolds, leaving a gap in our ability to constrain mapping degrees. This paper bridges that gap by generalizing the concept of "representation volume," providing a robust framework for understanding these invariants across a wide class of Lie groups.

The Framework of Representation Volume

The authors consider a connected real Lie group $G$ and a contractible homogeneous $G$-space $X$. By equipping $X$ with a $G$-invariant volume form, one can assign a real-valued volume to any representation $\rho: \pi_1(M) \to G$, where $M$ is an oriented closed smooth manifold of the same dimension as $X$.

This volume is defined using a developing map. For a representation $\rho$, there exists a $\rho$-equivariant map from the universal cover of $M$ to the space $X$. The volume of the representation is essentially the integral of the pulled-back volume form over the manifold $M$.

Key Result: Finiteness via Rigidity

The primary contribution of this research is Theorem 1.1, which states that if $G$ contains a closed, cocompact, connected semisimple subgroup, the set of all possible volumes for representations of $\pi_1(M)$ into $G$ is finite for any given $M$.

This finiteness is a consequence of volume rigidity. The authors demonstrate that the volume function is "locally constant" on the representation variety. Using Lie algebra cohomology and a specific vanishing lemma (Lemma 7.4), they prove that small deformations of a representation do not change its associated volume. Since the space of representations (the representation variety) consists of only finitely many components, a locally constant function can only take a finite number of values.

To overcome technical difficulties in deforming these representations, the authors utilize central extensions. By passing from the group $G$ to a full central extension $G_{\mathbb{R}}$, they create a more manageable environment to analyze the representation variety and ensure the rigidity of the volume.

Applications to Mapping Degrees

The study of representation volume has direct implications for the study of mapping degrees. The paper establishes that representation volume is an invariant of the manifold's homotopy type. This means the volume remains unchanged even if the manifold is deformed, provided the underlying homotopy type is preserved.

By strengthening the link between geometric structures and Property D, the authors show that if a manifold is locally modeled on a geometry $(X, G)$ where $G$ is semisimple, it must satisfy Property D. This unifies several classical results—such as those involving hyperbolic geometry and $PSL(2, \mathbb{C})$—into a single, broader framework that is applicable to higher dimensions.

Discussion and Future Directions

While the paper provides a comprehensive framework for dimensions 2, 3, and 5, it highlights several remaining challenges:

  • Dimension 4: This dimension remains a "black box." The authors note that many factors regarding model geometries and Property D in four dimensions are still unknown.
  • Irrational Geometries: In dimension 5, there exist "non-symmetric" spaces where the semisimple subgroup is not closed (referred to as irrational cases). It remains unclear whether these cases admit compact models or if their representation volumes simply vanish.
  • The Scope of $G$: A lingering question is identifying the largest possible class of Lie groups $G$ that define non-trivial representation volumes and whether simply-connected manifolds can ever possess Property D.

By establishing the finiteness and rigidity of representation volumes, this work provides topologists with a powerful new tool to distinguish between manifolds and understand the constraints on the maps that connect them.

Summary updated

Abstract

Given a connected real Lie group and a contractible homogeneous proper $G$--space $X$ furnished with a $G$--invariant volume form, a real valued volume can be assigned to any representation $ρ\colon π_1(M)\to G$ for any oriented closed smooth manifold $M$ of the same dimension as $X$. Suppose that $G$ contains a closed and cocompact semisimple subgroup, it is shown in this paper that the set of volumes is finite for any given $M$. From a perspective of model geometries, examples are investigated and applications with mapping degrees are discussed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{derbez2019volume,
  author = {Pierre Derbez and Yi Liu and Hongbin Sun and Shicheng Wang},
  title = {{Volume of representations and mapping degree}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1016/j.aim.2019.05.015},
}
Figure