Maps between circle bundles: Fiber-preserving, Finiteness and Realization of mapping degree sets

Christoforos Neofytidis, Hongbin Sun, Ye Tian, Shicheng Wang, Zhongzi WangarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

In the field of topology, understanding the possible "winding numbers" or mapping degrees between manifolds is a fundamental challenge. A recent study has made a significant breakthrough in this area, specifically addressing the mapping degree set—denoted as $D(M, N)$—which consists of all integers $d$ such that there exists a continuous map $f: M \to N$ with degree $d$.

This research provides a complete solution to the "realization problem" for dimensions $n=4$ and $n=5$, which were previously the only remaining gaps for dimensions $n > 2$. By analyzing the behavior of maps between circle bundles, the authors demonstrate that any finite set of integers containing zero can be realized as a mapping degree set.

The Core Questions: Finiteness and Realization

Two major questions have historically driven research into mapping degree sets:

  1. Finiteness: Under what topological conditions is the set $D(M, N)$ finite?
  2. Realization: Given a finite set of integers $A$ (where $0 \in A$), can we construct manifolds $M$ and $N$ such that $D(M, N) = A$?

While these questions were largely settled for 3-dimensional manifolds and for manifolds of dimension $n \ge 6$, the intermediate dimensions $n=4$ and $n=5$ remained open. Furthermore, while the behavior of maps between circle bundles (structures where a circle is "glued" to every point of a base manifold) was well-understood in 3D, it remained mysterious in higher dimensions.

Fiber-Preserving Maps and the SCF Condition

The authors' approach hinges on identifying when a map between circle bundles $E_1$ and $E_2$ can be simplified. They introduce a group-theoretic condition called Strongly Center-Free (SCF). If the fundamental group of the base manifold $M_2$ is SCF (meaning every finite-index subgroup has a trivial center), then any non-zero degree map between the total spaces $E_1 \to E_2$ is homotopic to a fiber-preserving map.

This is a powerful reduction. It allows the authors to translate a complex high-dimensional problem about the total bundle spaces into a more manageable problem involving the base manifolds $M_1, M_2$ and their respective Euler classes ($e_1, e_2$). The Euler class is a cohomological invariant that measures how "twisted" the circle bundle is over its base.

The Mapping Degree Formula

The research establishes a concrete formula for the mapping degree of fiber-preserving maps. The degree of such a map is shown to be the product of the degree of the map between the base manifolds ($f: M_1 \to M_2$) and the degree of the map between the circular fibers ($k$).

Specifically, the mapping degree set is given by: $$\{0\} \cup \{k \cdot \text{deg}(f) \mid k \neq 0, f: M_1 \to M_2, \text{deg}(f) \neq 0, \text{ and } f^\#(e_2) = ke_1\}$$

Here, the Euler class acts as a "gatekeeper." A map between base manifolds can only be lifted to a bundle map if it pulls back the Euler class of the target bundle to a specific multiple of the Euler class of the source bundle. This relationship allows for precise control over the resulting set of degrees.

Key Results and Applications

1. Finiteness (Theorem 1.4)

The authors prove that $D(E_1, E_2)$ is finite if the base manifold $M_2$ is hyperbolic and the Euler class $e_2$ is not a torsion element. This extends known 3D results to all dimensions $\ge 3$.

2. Realization (Theorem C)

This is the headline result of the paper. The authors prove that for every finite set $A \subset \mathbb{Z}$ (with $0 \in A$) and every dimension $n > 2$, there exist closed oriented $n$-manifolds $M$ and $N$ such that $D(M, N) = A$.

To achieve this, the authors constructed "rigid" base manifolds—manifolds that only admit self-maps of degree 0 or 1. By combining these rigid building blocks with arithmetic combinatorics, they were able to "trap" the possible degrees of the total bundle space to exactly match the desired set $A$. This effectively completes the realization problem for all dimensions except $n=1$ and $n=2$, where the geometry is significantly more constrained.

Conclusion and Future Directions

By bridging the dimension gap for $n=4$ and $n=5$, this work provides a unified understanding of mapping degrees in higher-dimensional topology. While the existence of the necessary hyperbolic manifolds is proven, the authors note that further work could streamline these constructions by proving the existence of hyperbolic manifolds with specific properties (such as positive second Betti numbers and odd-order isometry groups) across all dimensions $n \ge 3$. Currently, the results stand as a definitive answer to the realization of finite sets in the study of manifold mappings.

Summary updated

Abstract

Let $E_i$ be an oriented circle bundle over a closed oriented aspherical $n$-manifold $M_i$ with Euler class $e_i\in H^2(M_i;\mathbb{Z})$, $i=1,2$. We prove the following: (i) If every finite-index subgroup of $π_1(M_2)$ has trivial center, then any non-zero degree map from $E_1$ to $E_2$ is homotopic to a fiber-preserving map. (ii) The mapping degree set of fiber-preserving maps from $E_1$ to $E_2$ is given by $$\{0\} \cup\{k\cdot \mathrm{deg}(f) \ | \, k\ne 0, \ f\colon M_1\to M_2 \, \text{with} \, \mathrm{deg}(f)\ne 0 \ \text{such that}\, f^\#(e_2)=ke_1\},$$ where $f^\# \colon H^2(M_2;\mathbb{Z})\to H^2(M_1;\mathbb{Z})$ is the induced homomorphism. As applications of (i) and (ii), we obtain the following results with respect to the finiteness and the realization problems for mapping degree sets: ($\mathcal F$) The mapping degree set $D(E_1, E_2)$ is finite if $M_2$ is hyperbolic and $e_2$ is not torsion. ($\mathcal R$) For any finite set $A$ of integers containing $0$ and each $n>2$, $A$ is the mapping degree set $D(M,N)$ for some closed oriented $n$-manifolds $M$ and $N$. Items (i) and ($\mathcal F$) extend in all dimensions $\geq 3$ the previously known $3$-dimensional case (i.e., for maps between circle bundles over hyperbolic surfaces). Item ($\mathcal R$) gives a complete answer to the realization problem for finite sets (containing $0$) in any dimension, establishing in particular the previously unknown cases in dimensions $n= 4, 5$.
BibTeX
@misc{neofytidis2025maps,
  author = {Christoforos Neofytidis and Hongbin Sun and Ye Tian and Shicheng Wang and Zhongzi Wang},
  title = {{Maps between circle bundles: Fiber-preserving, Finiteness and Realization of mapping degree sets}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2505.16285},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.16285},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure