Is there a hidden chiral density-wave in the iron-based superconductors?

Rafael M. Fernandes, Steven A. Kivelson, Erez Berg

Abstract

Superconductivity in most iron pnictides and iron chalcogenides is found near an instability towards an orthorhombic stripe magnetic state. A remarkable property of the latter is that its melting into the tetragonal paramagnetic phase happens generally in two stages, resulting in a nematic paramagnetic phase that breaks the point-group symmetry. Recent experiments in hole-doped iron arsenides, however, revealed a magnetically ordered ground state that preserves tetragonal symmetry, which is likely either a checkerboard charge-and-spin density wave (CSDW) or a spin-vortex crystal (SVC). Here we show that either of these phases can also melt in two stages, resulting in an intermediate phase with vestigial order, namely: a charge density-wave (CDW) for a CSDW ground state, and a remarkable spin-vorticity density-wave (SVDW) for a SVC ground state. While the CDW has an Ising-like order parameter, the SVDW has a vector chiral order parameter that breaks inversion without breaking time-reversal symmetry, giving rise to Goldstone modes. We propose experimentally detectable signatures of these phases, and point out that their fluctuations can lead to an enhancement of the superconducting transition temperature.

Introduction

In the study of high-temperature superconductors, magnetism and superconductivity are often viewed as competing yet inextricably linked phenomena. In the majority of iron-based superconductors, a "stripe" magnetic state is the primary competitor. This state typically undergoes a two-stage melting process as temperature increases, leading to an intermediate "nematic" phase—a state where electronic degrees of freedom choose a preferred direction (breaking rotational symmetry) before full magnetic order is lost.

However, recent experimental evidence in hole-doped iron pnictides—such as $Ba(Fe_{1-x}Mn_x)_2As_2$, $(Ba_{1-x}Na_x)Fe_2As_2$, and $(Ba_{1-x}K_x)Fe_2As_2$—has uncovered magnetic ground states that, unlike the stripe state, preserve the tetragonal symmetry of the crystal lattice. This discovery raises a fundamental question: do these tetragonal magnetic states also possess their own intermediate "vestigial" phases? This paper explores the theoretical existence, properties, and physical consequences of such phases.

Theoretical Framework: Vestigial Order and Symmetry Breaking

To address this, the authors employ a Landau-Ginzburg-Wilson effective action framework centered on two magnetic order parameters, $\mathbf{M}_1$ and $\mathbf{M}_2$, associated with the nesting vectors $\mathbf{Q}_1 = (\pi, 0)$ and $\mathbf{Q}_2 = (0, \pi)$. Using a Hubbard-Stratonovich transformation, they identify composite order parameters that represent the "half-melted" intermediate states.

Vestigial phases and symmetry breaking on the O(3) sphere.

When the ground state is a Spin-Vortex Crystal (SVC), characterized by $\mathbf{M}_1 \perp \mathbf{M}_2$, the resulting vestigial phase is a Spin-Vorticity Density Wave (SVDW). This phase is defined by a vector chiral order parameter $\langle \mathbf{M}_1 \times \mathbf{M}_2 \rangle \neq 0$. Unlike the Ising-like nematic phase, the SVDW breaks inversion symmetry while preserving time-reversal symmetry. Furthermore, because it breaks a continuous $O(3)$ symmetry down to $O(2)$, the SVDW phase supports collective low-energy excitations known as Goldstone modes.

Results and Experimental Signatures

The analysis confirms that both the checkerboard charge-and-spin density wave (CSDW) and the SVC can melt in two stages, yielding a Charge Density-Wave (CDW) and an SVDW, respectively. The conditions for these "split transitions" depend on the ratio of interaction coefficients ($u/w$) and the strength of interlayer coupling ($J_z$).

Summary of magnetic and vestigial states.

A key finding is that the fluctuations of these hidden phases are inherently "attractive" for electron pairing. This suggests that the presence of CDW or SVDW fluctuations can actively enhance the superconducting transition temperature ($T_c$) without altering the symmetry of the superconducting state itself.

For experimental verification, the authors propose Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) as a primary tool. In the SVDW phase, an external magnetic field is expected to induce circulating orbital currents, which would generate small, detectable magnetic fields at the pnictogen (e.g., Arsenic) sites.

Conclusion

This research identifies a new class of chiral vestigial phases in iron-based superconductors. The SVDW, in particular, represents a novel state of matter with unique symmetry-breaking properties and excitations. While current saddle-point approximations suggest these transitions may be first-order, future numerical simulations and experimental searches using NMR and neutron scattering are required to fully map the phase space and confirm the role of these hidden phases in boosting superconductivity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Superconductivity in most iron pnictides and iron chalcogenides is found near an instability towards an orthorhombic stripe magnetic state. A remarkable property of the latter is that its melting into the tetragonal paramagnetic phase happens generally in two stages, resulting in a nematic paramagnetic phase that breaks the point-group symmetry. Recent experiments in hole-doped iron arsenides, however, revealed a magnetically ordered ground state that preserves tetragonal symmetry, which is likely either a checkerboard charge-and-spin density wave (CSDW) or a spin-vortex crystal (SVC). Here we show that either of these phases can also melt in two stages, resulting in an intermediate phase with vestigial order, namely: a charge density-wave (CDW) for a CSDW ground state, and a remarkable spin-vorticity density-wave (SVDW) for a SVC ground state. While the CDW has an Ising-like order parameter, the SVDW has a vector chiral order parameter that breaks inversion without breaking time-reversal symmetry, giving rise to Goldstone modes. We propose experimentally detectable signatures of these phases, and point out that their fluctuations can lead to an enhancement of the superconducting transition temperature.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fernandes2016is,
  author = {Rafael M. Fernandes and Steven A. Kivelson and Erez Berg},
  title = {{Is there a hidden chiral density-wave in the iron-based superconductors?}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.93.014511},
}
Figure