Abstract
Collective identification is vital for adolescents, fostering well-being and connection, but scant attention has been given to drivers of national identification and their contextual variations in youth. To address this, two longitudinal studies examined how values, as guiding goals defining what individuals consider important in their lives, relate to the trajectory of national identification in majority and minority youth. Study 1 (N = 568; M<sub>age</sub> = 16.24, SD = 0.71) and Study 2 (N = 678; M<sub>age</sub> = 13.78, SD = 0.73) focused on majority youth (Jewish-Israelis), while Study 2 also included minority (Arab citizens of Israel). The findings highlight values as important motivators of national identification over time. Conservation values, emphasizing the preservation of the status quo and a preference for stability, were prominent motivators for the majority of adolescents. In contrast, power values, which center around climbing the social ladder and accumulating wealth, held greater significance among their minority counterparts; however, both sets of values correlated with increased national identification. The discussion touches on motivations underlying national identification, their contextual diversity, and implications for future studies.
Introduction
Adolescence is a critical window for identity formation, yet the specific drivers that lead a young person to feel connected to their national group remain under-explored. Most existing research provides only cross-sectional "snapshots" and primarily focuses on adult populations. This research, published in the Journal of Youth and Adolescence, investigates the longitudinal relationship between personal values and national identification, exploring whether internal values shape identity or vice versa, and how these dynamics differ between majority and minority groups.
Theoretical Framework: Schwartz’s Basic Values
The study utilizes Schwartz’s Basic Values Theory, which organizes human values into a circular structure based on their motivational goals. These values are grouped into four higher-order dimensions:
- Conservation: Emphasizing tradition, conformity, and security.
- Openness to Change: Focusing on self-direction and stimulation.
- Self-Enhancement: Centered on power and achievement.
- Self-Transcendence: Prioritizing universalism and benevolence.
Methodology
The researchers conducted two independent longitudinal studies in Israel:
- Study 1: Followed 568 Jewish-Israeli (majority) 10th and 11th graders over one year.
- Study 2: Followed 678 Jewish and Arab-Israeli (minority) 8th graders over two years.
To determine the direction of influence, the team employed cross-lagged panel path analyses. This statistical approach allowed the researchers to test if values at Time 1 predicted national identification at Time 2, while controlling for initial identification levels. Values were measured using the Portrait Values Questionnaire (PVQ), and national identification was assessed via the Centrality-to-Identity scale.
Key Findings
The results suggest that personal values act as the "root" of social identity, consistently predicting future identification more strongly than identity predicted future values. However, the specific values driving this identification varied significantly by social context:
The Majority’s Anchor: Conservation
For Jewish-Israeli youth, national identity serves as a mechanism to fulfill needs for stability and safety. Those who prioritized Conservation values (tradition and the status quo) showed a significant increase in national identification over time ($\beta = 0.14$ in Study 1; $\beta = 0.20$ in Study 2).
The Minority’s Ladder: Power
In contrast, Conservation values did not predict national identity for Arab-Israeli youth. Instead, Power values—the desire for social status and resources—were the primary driver ($\beta = 0.14$). For these minority youth, identifying with the state may represent a pragmatic strategy for social mobility and success within the dominant society.
Barriers to Identification: Universalism and Openness
- Universalism: Among the majority group, youth valuing equality and social justice showed a decrease in future national identification over time ($\beta = -0.18$), suggesting that a "world-citizen" outlook may conflict with national boundaries.
- Openness to Change: Across both groups, youth prioritizing independence and stimulation tended to show lower national identification, likely because strong group ties can be perceived as a threat to personal autonomy.
Conclusion and Implications
The study demonstrates that while values are universal motivators, their application to national identity is highly contextual. For the majority, the nation is a source of stability; for the minority, it can be a tool for advancement. These findings suggest that educational or social programs aimed at fostering national unity must account for these diverse motivational profiles. Over-emphasizing national identification might inadvertently alienate students who hold strong Universalism or Openness values, potentially deepening social rifts.
Summary updated