Abstract
Schools serve as social institutions that convey values in the context of socialization and enculturation. Teachers are pivotal in this transmission process via their value-related educational goals (VrEGs), which outline how they would like to see their pupils in terms of values. What factors influence these VrEGs? We suggest that those vary on an individual level, but also correspond to the prevailing value orientations of the society. In our study we followed two main goals to test this thesis. Firstly, we examine the differences in VrEGs between teachers of two European countries: Switzerland (CH) and United Kingdom (UK). Secondly, we investigated the similarity of the teachers' VrEGs with prevailing national value orientations from the specific countries. One hundred and fifty primary school teachers (108 CH, 42 UK) were asked about their VrEGs using an adapted version of Schwartz's Portrait Values Questionnaire (PVQ-21). Data from the Human Value Scale (HVS) of the European Social Survey (ESS) was used for country-specific value orientations. Analyses of the value structures and the differences in value priorities showed that for the individuals from the two countries as well as for the teachers' VrEGs from the two countries, significant differences exist in several value types. Teachers' VrEGs in each country showed a high correlation with the corresponding national value profile. We discuss our results in light of cross-national differences in value education in schools.
Introduction
Primary schools are fundamental socialization agents, tasked not only with academic instruction but also with the transmission of societal values. This process, termed "enculturation," is largely mediated by teachers through their Value-related Educational Goals (VrEGs)—the specific values they hope to foster in their students. This study investigates whether these goals are idiosyncratic to individual teachers or if they systematically reflect the broader cultural value orientations of the nations in which they teach. By comparing teachers in Switzerland (CH) and the United Kingdom (UK), the research explores the extent to which national culture acts as a template for classroom values.
Theoretical Framework: Schwartz’s Value Theory
The study utilizes Schwartz’s Theory of Basic Values, which posits ten universal motivational types of values. These values are organized in a circular structure (a "circumplex") based on their compatibility or conflict. For instance, values of Self-Enhancement (like Power and Achievement) typically conflict with Self-Transcendence (like Universalism and Benevolence), while Openness to Change (Self-Direction, Stimulation) stands in opposition to Conservation (Security, Conformity, Tradition).
Methodology
The researchers analyzed data from two primary sources:
- National Profiles: Representative samples from the European Social Survey (ESS) Round 10 for Switzerland ($N=1,523$) and the UK ($N=1,149$).
- Teacher Sample: 150 primary school teachers (108 Swiss, 42 UK) who completed an adapted Portrait Values Questionnaire (PVQ-21), rating their "ideal pupil."
Statistical methods included Multidimensional Scaling (MDS) to verify the value structure, Unfolding Analysis to compare individual value hierarchies across countries, and Q-correlation to assess the alignment between individual teachers and national averages.
Key Results: The Cultural Mirror Effect
The study found a striking alignment between teachers' educational goals and their respective national value profiles. Swiss teachers’ goals correlated strongly with the Swiss national profile ($r=0.67$), and UK teachers showed a similar alignment with the UK profile ($r=0.60$).
Conservation vs. Openness to Change
A significant divide emerged between the two countries. UK teachers and the general UK population prioritized Conservation values, specifically Conformity and Security. In contrast, Swiss teachers and the Swiss population placed greater emphasis on Openness to Change, prioritizing Self-direction and Hedonism.
Discriminant Analysis
Using unfolding analysis, the researchers were able to statistically separate the two groups of teachers based on their value priorities. A discriminant line effectively partitioned the sample, demonstrating that national origin is a robust predictor of a teacher's VrEGs.
Discussion and Conclusion
The findings suggest that teachers act as "mirrors" of their society, internalizing and then projecting national value priorities into their pedagogical goals. While some values like Universalism appear to be common ground across both Western European contexts, the specific emphasis on individual autonomy (Switzerland) versus social order and security (UK) highlights how cultural context shapes the "ideal pupil."
These results have implications for understanding how national curricula are enacted. Even with similar educational standards, the underlying value-laden goals of teachers may lead to different classroom climates and socialization outcomes. Future research should consider the impact of specific national policies—such as the "Fundamental British Values" mandate in the UK—and whether these cultural alignments hold in non-Western educational systems.
Summary updated