The values of schools: an analysis of vision statements

Ella Daniel, Sharon Arieli, Liat AkermanEuropean 2024 · DOI

Introduction

School vision statements are more than mere administrative requirements; they are central organizational artifacts that articulate an aspired future state. These documents highlight a school's ideals, purpose, and unique identity, serving to direct behavior and foster commitment among stakeholders. While extensive research has explored the personal values of educators and students, there remains a significant gap in understanding the organizational values of schools as institutions. This study addresses this gap by analyzing how schools in Israel prioritize different motivational goals within their vision statements.

Theoretical Framework: Schwartz’s Values Theory

To map the value landscape of these institutions, the researchers utilized Schwartz’s (1992) theory of universal human values. This framework identifies ten basic value types organized in a circular structure (circumplex) based on their motivational conflicts and congruencies.

Schwartz’s circumplex model of human values, illustrating the relationships between the ten basic value types.

The values are grouped into four higher-order dimensions:

  1. Openness to Change: Self-direction and stimulation.
  2. Conservation: Security, conformity, and tradition.
  3. Self-Enhancement: Power and achievement.
  4. Self-Transcendence: Universalism and benevolence.

Methodology

The study employed a mixed-methods approach to analyze a stratified sample of 99 Hebrew-speaking public elementary schools in Israel (69 public/secular and 30 public-religious). The researchers used the "Madad Tipuach" index to account for the socioeconomic status (SES) of each school's community.

The analysis proceeded in two stages:

  1. Qualitative Content Analysis: Vision statements were decomposed into "utterances"—discrete meaning units. For example, a statement emphasizing "independent learning" and "mutual respect" would be coded as two separate units representing Self-Direction and Benevolence, respectively.
  2. Quantitative Indexing: To allow for comparison across statements of varying lengths, the researchers calculated "value indices" by dividing the frequency of specific value utterances by the total number of utterances in the document.

Key Findings

The Hierarchy of Values

The analysis revealed a consistent hierarchy across the sample. Self-Direction (independence, creativity) and Benevolence (care for others, kindness) emerged as the most prevalent values. This suggests a universal educational mission focused on both cognitive autonomy and social support. Conversely, Power and Hedonism were the least salient, reflecting a systemic de-emphasis on self-interest and immediate gratification in formal educational settings.

Rank Value Type Mean Prevalence
1 Self-direction 0.23
2 Benevolence 0.19
3 Security 0.17
4 Universalism 0.11
... ... ...
10 Hedonism 0.01

The Impact of Social Context

While some values were universal, others were highly dependent on the school's religious affiliation and socioeconomic context:

  • The Universalism-Tradition Divide: Public (secular) schools placed significantly higher emphasis on Universalism (social justice, tolerance, environmentalism) compared to public-religious schools. In contrast, Tradition (religious devotion, national customs) was the second most prominent value in religious schools but was nearly absent in secular ones.
  • Socioeconomic Influence: A significant correlation ($r = -0.20$) was found between SES and Universalism. Schools serving higher SES communities were more likely to include values like social justice and environmental sustainability in their visions.

Value Instantiation

The study highlights the concept of "instantiation"—the specific way an abstract value is translated into concrete goals. For instance, while both secular and religious schools valued Self-Direction, secular schools "instantiated" this as critical thinking and self-fulfillment, whereas religious schools framed it as the independent study of religious texts to achieve religious devotion.

Discussion and Conclusion

The findings suggest that school vision statements are sensitive to the broader social and cultural contexts in which they operate. The dominance of Self-Direction and Benevolence points to a shared "educational core," while the divergence in Universalism and Tradition reflects the deep ideological divisions within the Israeli educational system.

A notable finding is the near-total absence of Hedonism. While pleasure and joy are central to youth culture, schools explicitly exclude these from their formal "aspired state," potentially creating a disconnect between the institutional culture and the lived experience of students.

Limitations: The study is limited to the Israeli context and focuses on "espoused values" (what is said) rather than "enacted values" (what is done). Future research should investigate the degree to which these vision statements actually influence classroom practice and student outcomes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract School vision statements articulate an aspired future state for the school, highlighting its ideals, purpose, and unique aspects to direct behavior and promote motivation and commitment among stakeholders. This paper investigates vision statements of schools as artifacts expressing the values emphasized by schools, drawing on organizational literature that shows the role of central organizational artifacts in conveying the values important to the organization. Using a comprehensive sample of elementary schools across all districts in Israel ( N = 99), we built on Schwartz’s values theory to identify values and analyze expressed values. We employed a mixed methods approach, combining qualitative and quantitative methods to analyze these values. First, we analyzed the content of vision statements to investigate how values were manifested. Then, we investigated the values hierarchy reflected in the vision statements, and compared sectors to identify the impact of the broader social context. Our analysis revealed variation in values expression: as expected, self-direction and benevolence emerged as the most prevalent values in school vision statements; power and hedonism were less salient. Comparison of vision statements from public and public-religious schools, as well as across schools with varying socioeconomic status (SES), revealed differences in universalism values. Public schools and those with higher SES placed greater importance on universalism values compared to public-religious schools. Additionally, tradition values were less prominent in public schools but were the second most significant values in public-religious schools. We discuss the results within the framework of values theory and educational policy.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{daniel2024values,
  author = {Ella Daniel and Sharon Arieli and Liat Akerman},
  title = {{The values of schools: an analysis of vision statements}},
  booktitle = {European},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/s10212-024-00886-7},
}
Figure