Unveiling the double-peak structure of quantum oscillations in the specific heat

Zhuo Yang, Benoît Fauqué, Toshihiro Nomura, Takashi Shitaokoshi, Sunghoon Kim, Debanjan Chowdhury, Z. Pribulová, J. Kačmarčı́k, Alexandre Pourret, G. Knebel, Dai Aoki, T. Klein, D. K. Maude, C. Marcenat, Yoshimitsu Kohama

Abstract

Quantum oscillation phenomenon is an essential tool to understand the electronic structure of quantum matter. Here we report a systematic study of quantum oscillations in the electronic specific heat $C_{el}$ in natural graphite. We show that the crossing of a single spin Landau level and the Fermi energy give rise to a double-peak structure, in striking contrast to the single peak expected from Lifshitz-Kosevich theory. Intriguingly, the double-peak structure is predicted by the kernel term for $C_{el}/T$ in the free electron theory. The $C_{el}/T$ represents a spectroscopic tuning fork of width 4.8 $k_B T$ which can be tuned at will to resonance. Using a coincidence method, the double-peak structure can be used to accurately determine the Lande $g$-factor of quantum materials. More generally, the tuning fork can be used to reveal any peak in fermionic density of states tuned by magnetic field, such as Lifshitz transition in heavy-fermion compounds.

Introduction

Quantum oscillations are the "gold standard" for mapping Fermi surfaces in metals and semi-metals. For decades, the Lifshitz-Kosevich (LK) theory has been the primary framework for interpreting these oscillations. However, as experiments reach the "quantum limit"—where only a few Landau levels (LLs) are occupied—the LK theory often fails to capture the full complexity of the electronic response. This study addresses a significant discrepancy in the electronic specific heat ($C_{el}$), where experimental data on high-quality graphite reveals a double-peak structure where standard theory predicts only one.

Experimental Observation of the Double-Peak Structure

Using high-precision AC specific heat measurements on natural graphite flakes at ultra-low temperatures (down to 90 mK), researchers observed a distinct phenomenon. While standard transport measurements like magnetoresistance ($\Delta R_{xx}$) and the magnetocaloric effect ($1/T$) show single peaks as Landau levels cross the Fermi energy, the specific heat ($C_{el}/T$) exhibits two peaks for each crossing.

Comparison of quantum oscillations in 1/T, magnetoresistance, and specific heat, showing the unique double-peak structure in $C_{el}/T$ (panel c) and the corresponding Landau level diagram (panel d).

As seen in Figure 1, this double-peak structure is most prominent for low-index Landau levels ($N < 3$). The splitting between these peaks is not a result of spin-splitting or multiple sub-bands but is intrinsic to the specific heat measurement itself, scaling linearly with temperature.

The Spectroscopic Tuning Fork: Theoretical Origin

The origin of this structure lies in the fundamental thermodynamics of fermions. The electronic specific heat is calculated by convolving the Density of States (DOS) with a kernel function: $-x^2 dF(x)/dx$, where $F$ is the Fermi-Dirac distribution and $x = (E - E_F)/k_B T$.

Theoretical origin of the double-peak structure. (a) The kernel function $-x^2 dF(x)/dx$ at various temperatures. (c) Convolution of a sharp DOS peak with the kernel, illustrating how the double-peak structure emerges as the LL moves through the Fermi level.

In Figure 3, the kernel function is shown to have two maxima at $x \approx \pm 2.4$. When a Landau level is sharp (i.e., its broadening $\Gamma$ is smaller than $k_B T$), it acts as a probe that scans across this kernel. The specific heat "rings" twice—once as the LL passes through each maximum of the kernel. This creates a "spectroscopic tuning fork" with a fixed energy width of $4.8 k_B T$.

Applications and Universality

This discovery provides a high-precision diagnostic tool. By using a "coincidence method"—observing when the double peaks from different spin states merge—researchers can accurately determine the Landé $g$-factor without needing to identify specific Landau indices. For graphite, this yielded a $g$-factor of approximately 2.42 to 2.49, consistent with established values but obtained with fewer theoretical assumptions.

Furthermore, this effect is universal. The same logic explains previously mysterious data in heavy-fermion superconductors like $UCoGe$ near Lifshitz transitions. Any system where a sharp DOS peak is tuned by a magnetic field should exhibit this characteristic double-peak signature in its specific heat.

Limitations

The visibility of the double-peak structure depends heavily on sample quality; the Landau level broadening must be smaller than the thermal energy. In "dirty" samples, scattering smears these features into a single broad peak. Additionally, the asymmetric nature of 3D Landau levels can shift peak positions, requiring sophisticated fitting using models like the Slonczewski-Weiss-McClure (SWM) tight-binding Hamiltonian for the highest precision.

Summary updated

Abstract

Quantum oscillation phenomenon is an essential tool to understand the electronic structure of quantum matter. Here we report a systematic study of quantum oscillations in the electronic specific heat C<sub>el</sub> in natural graphite. We show that the crossing of a single spin Landau level and the Fermi energy give rise to a double-peak structure, in striking contrast to the single peak expected from Lifshitz-Kosevich theory. Intriguingly, the double-peak structure is predicted by the kernel term for C<sub>el</sub>/T in the free electron theory. The C<sub>el</sub>/T represents a spectroscopic tuning fork of width 4.8k<sub>B</sub>T which can be tuned at will to resonance. Using a coincidence method, the double-peak structure can be used to accurately determine the Landé g-factors of quantum materials. More generally, the tuning fork can be used to reveal any peak in fermionic density of states tuned by magnetic field, such as Lifshitz transition in heavy-fermion compounds.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2023unveiling,
  author = {Zhuo Yang and Benoît Fauqué and Toshihiro Nomura and Takashi Shitaokoshi and Sunghoon Kim and Debanjan Chowdhury and Z. Pribulová and J. Kačmarčı́k and Alexandre Pourret and G. Knebel and Dai Aoki and T. Klein and D. K. Maude and C. Marcenat and Yoshimitsu Kohama},
  title = {{Unveiling the double-peak structure of quantum oscillations in the specific heat}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-023-42730-4},
}
Figure