Abstract
The mixed-valence compound YbB<sub>12</sub> displays paradoxical quantum oscillations in electrical resistivity and magnetic torque in a regime with a well-developed insulating charge gap and in the absence of an electronic Fermi surface. However, signatures of such unusual fermionic quasiparticles in other bulk thermodynamic observables have been missing. Here we report the observation of a series of sharp double-peak features in the specific heat as a function of the magnetic field. The measured Hall resistivity evolves smoothly across the field values at which the characteristic anomalies appear in the thermodynamic response and rules out the possibility of conventional electrons as their origin. Our observations of thermodynamic anomalies in a bulk three-dimensional electrical insulator provide the evidence for the presence of emergent dispersing fermionic excitations within the insulating bulk, which sets the stage for further investigation of electron fractionalization in other correlated mixed-valence compounds.
Introduction
A fundamental tenet of condensed matter physics is the distinction between metals and insulators based on the presence or absence of a Fermi surface. Metals possess a boundary in momentum space that allows for low-energy excitations, leading to phenomena like quantum oscillations. Insulators, characterized by an energy gap, should theoretically lack these features. However, recent observations in "Kondo insulators" like SmB<sub>6</sub> and YbB<sub>12</sub> have challenged this paradigm, revealing quantum oscillations despite a robust insulating state.
This discovery sparked a significant debate: are these oscillations a result of metallic surface states, impurities, or a more exotic bulk phenomenon? The hypothesis of "neutral fermions"—quasiparticles that behave like electrons but carry no charge—has been proposed to explain how an insulator could host a Fermi surface. To validate this, researchers sought bulk thermodynamic evidence that would prove these excitations are intrinsic to the entire volume of the material, rather than just its surface.
Experimental Methodology
The research team utilized high-quality single crystals of Ytterbium dodecaboride (YbB<sub>12</sub>), a material where strong electron correlations generate a narrow energy gap. To probe the bulk properties, they employed several high-precision techniques in high magnetic fields:
- Specific Heat ($C$): Measured using an AC method in static magnetic fields up to 35 Tesla.
- Magnetocaloric Effect (MCE): Used to measure temperature changes during magnetic field sweeps up to 60 Tesla in pulsed magnets.
- Transport Measurements: Simultaneous monitoring of magnetoresistance ($\rho_{xx}$) and Hall resistivity ($\rho_{xy}$) to correlate thermodynamic signals with charge transport.
Results: Bulk Thermodynamic Anomalies
The primary discovery of this study is a series of sharp "double-peak" features in the specific heat ($C/T$) as a function of the magnetic field. These anomalies occur at four distinct field values, labeled $B_{c1}$ through $B_{c4}$ (approximately 11, 16, 19.6, and 30 T).
Crucially, while the specific heat shows these massive anomalies, the Hall resistivity ($\rho_{xy}$) remains entirely smooth across the same field ranges. This decoupling is a "smoking gun" for neutral excitations; if the peaks were caused by conventional charged electrons, they would inevitably appear in the Hall signal. Furthermore, angular dependence measurements confirmed that these signals follow the cubic symmetry of the crystal lattice, ruling out 2D surface states and confirming a 3D bulk origin.
Scaling and Fermionic Nature
To understand the nature of these excitations, the team analyzed the temperature dependence of the double peaks. The distance between the two peaks in a pair (denoted $B'$ and $B''$) was found to increase linearly with temperature.
This splitting follows a specific mathematical relationship ($4.8 k_B T$), which is a hallmark of the Fermi-Dirac distribution. This confirms that the quasiparticles responsible for the thermodynamic signal behave as fermions. By modeling the Density of States (DoS), the researchers were able to estimate the energy-field dispersion ($d\epsilon/dB$) for these neutral states, providing a quantitative foundation for future theoretical work on electron fractionalization.
Discussion and Conclusion
The observation of large thermodynamic signatures in the insulating bulk of YbB<sub>12</sub> provides compelling evidence for the existence of neutral fermionic quasiparticles. These results suggest that the electrons in Kondo insulators can indeed fractionalize, forming a neutral version of a Fermi surface within an electrical insulator.
While this study confirms the existence of these states, the exact mechanism of their formation remains a subject for future research. Potential next steps include using spectroscopic probes like Inelastic Neutron Scattering to directly observe the energy spectrum of these neutral excitations and investigating whether similar phenomena exist in other strongly correlated mixed-valence compounds.
Summary updated