Understanding Zhongyong Using a Zhongyong Approach: Re-examining the Non-linear Relationship Between Creativity and the Confucian Doctrine of the Mean

Ruixiang Gao, Shiqi Huang, Yujie Yao, Xiaoqin Liu, Yujun Zhou, Shijia Zhang, Shaohua Cai, Huang Zuo, Zehui Zhan, Lei MoFrontiers in Psychology 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Zhongyong, a central theme of Confucian thought, refers to the "doctrine of the mean," or the idea that moderation in all things is the optimal path. Despite considerable interest in the relationship between zhongyong and creativity, especially in China, studies of this relationship have not yielded consistent results. Based on a review of the literature, we hypothesized that this inconsistency arises from the dual nature of zhongyong itself, which has both a positive side, promoting creativity, and a negative side, inhibiting creativity. We also hypothesized that the negative side of zhongyong takes the form of excessive zhongyong. Indeed, the observations that every coin has two sides and that too much of a good thing is as bad as too little are core principles of zhongyong in traditional Chinese culture. To test these hypotheses, we conducted two empirical studies (measuring explicit and implicit zhongyong personality, respectively) to examine the relationships between positive and negative zhongyong and creativity (measured in terms of creative personality, divergent thinking, and convergent thinking). The results of both studies revealed an interaction between positive zhongyong and negative zhongyong, indicating that only a moderate level of zhongyong is conducive to creativity; both deficiency and excess are harmful. We discuss the implications of these results, suggesting that a zhongyong approach can help to clarify non-linear relationships between things, and recommending to re-assess the creativity of Chinese culture from a neutral and objective outlook. This paper deepens understanding of zhongyong and offers clear insights into creativity from an in-depth cultural perspective.

Introduction: The Paradox of Confucian Moderation

In cultural psychology, the "Joseph Needham puzzle"—the question of why China’s early scientific dominance was eventually overtaken by the West—often cites Confucianism as a primary factor. Specifically, the doctrine of Zhongyong (the "Mean" or moderation) is frequently criticized for encouraging mediocrity and stifling the radical thinking necessary for innovation. However, empirical research has been inconclusive, with studies showing positive, negative, or no correlation between Zhongyong and creativity.

This paper argues that previous research failed to apply a "Zhongyong approach" to the concept itself. By viewing moderation as a static, purely positive or negative trait, researchers missed its dual nature. We propose that Zhongyong encompasses both integrative, "big picture" thinking (positive) and excessive moderation leading to unprincipled compromise (negative).

Conceptual Framework: The Dual Nature of Zhongyong

To understand Zhongyong, one must recognize its philosophical roots, which synthesize various traditional Chinese perspectives. As illustrated in Figure 1, the concept is not merely about avoiding extremes but involves a complex interplay between Confucian moderation, Taoist dialectics, and the potential for Buddhist-influenced unprincipled compromise.

Conceptual framework of Zhongyong's dual nature, illustrating the synthesis of different philosophical traditions.

We distinguish between "Integrated thinking"—synthesizing contradictions to find higher-level solutions—and "Eclectic thinking," which involves making superficial compromises to avoid conflict. The former is hypothesized to drive creativity, while the latter acts as a bottleneck.

Methodology

We conducted two studies to examine how these dimensions interact with creativity:

  1. Study 1 (Explicit Measure): 114 undergraduate students completed a newly developed personality scale using 12 Chinese idioms representing positive Zhongyong (e.g., "taking the whole situation into account") and negative Zhongyong (e.g., "being a yes-man").
  2. Study 2 (Implicit Measure): 144 students participated in an Implicit Association Test (IAT) to measure reaction times associating the "self" with positive vs. negative Zhongyong traits, bypassing social desirability bias.

Creativity was assessed using the Williams Scale (Creative Personality), the Alternative Uses Task (AUT for divergent thinking), and a modified Chinese Remote Associates Test (RAT for convergent thinking).

Results and Analysis

The statistical analysis confirmed a significant interaction effect between the positive and negative dimensions of Zhongyong. As shown in the correlation matrix (Figure 2), positive Zhongyong significantly correlates with convergent thinking (RAT) and established thinking style scales (ZYTS), while negative Zhongyong shows a significant negative correlation with creative personality.

Correlations between Zhongyong dimensions and creativity measures, showing the distinct statistical paths of positive and negative traits.

Key findings include:

  • Convergent Thinking (RAT): Positive Zhongyong predicted better performance only when negative Zhongyong was low. High negative scores neutralized the benefits of integrative thinking.
  • Creative Personality: Participants with high positive but low negative Zhongyong scores (the "Goldilocks Zone") exhibited the highest creative personality ratings.
  • Divergent Thinking (AUT): No significant interaction was found, suggesting Zhongyong is primarily an evaluative and linking process more aligned with convergent thinking.

Discussion: The "Too Much of a Good Thing" Effect

Our findings suggest that Zhongyong follows an inverted U-shape relationship with creativity. Moderate Zhongyong fosters the integrative thinking necessary to solve complex problems, but excessive Zhongyong leads to a "yes-man" mentality that kills original thought. This recursive philosophy implies that to be truly creative, one must practice moderation even in moderation.

Conclusion

By applying a Zhongyong approach to the study of Confucian moderation, we resolve long-standing contradictions in the literature. This research suggests that Chinese culture is not inherently anti-creative; rather, its creative potential is unlocked when integrative thinking is prioritized over superficial compromise. Future research should explore whether similar non-linear patterns exist in Western doctrines of the mean, such as Aristotelian ethics.

Summary updated

Abstract

<i>Zhongyong</i>, a central theme of Confucian thought, refers to the "doctrine of the mean," or the idea that moderation in all things is the optimal path. Despite considerable interest in the relationship between <i>zhongyong</i> and creativity, especially in China, studies of this relationship have not yielded consistent results. Based on a review of the literature, we hypothesized that this inconsistency arises from the dual nature of <i>zhongyong</i> itself, which has both a positive side, promoting creativity, and a negative side, inhibiting creativity. We also hypothesized that the negative side of <i>zhongyong</i> takes the form of excessive <i>zhongyong</i>. Indeed, the observations that every coin has two sides and that too much of a good thing is as bad as too little are core principles of <i>zhongyong</i> in traditional Chinese culture. To test these hypotheses, we conducted two empirical studies (measuring explicit and implicit <i>zhongyong</i> personality, respectively) to examine the relationships between positive and negative <i>zhongyong</i> and creativity (measured in terms of creative personality, divergent thinking, and convergent thinking). The results of both studies revealed an interaction between positive <i>zhongyong</i> and negative <i>zhongyong</i>, indicating that only a moderate level of <i>zhongyong</i> is conducive to creativity; both deficiency and excess are harmful. We discuss the implications of these results, suggesting that a <i>zhongyong</i> approach can help to clarify non-linear relationships between things, and recommending to re-assess the creativity of Chinese culture from a neutral and objective outlook. This paper deepens understanding of <i>zhongyong</i> and offers clear insights into creativity from an in-depth cultural perspective.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gao2022understanding,
  author = {Ruixiang Gao and Shiqi Huang and Yujie Yao and Xiaoqin Liu and Yujun Zhou and Shijia Zhang and Shaohua Cai and Huang Zuo and Zehui Zhan and Lei Mo},
  title = {{Understanding Zhongyong Using a Zhongyong Approach: Re-examining the Non-linear Relationship Between Creativity and the Confucian Doctrine of the Mean}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2022.903411},
}
Figure