Three-way interaction effect of hindrance research stressors, inclusive mentoring style, and academic resilience on research creativity among doctoral students from China

Chunlei Liu, Min Wu, Gao Xiao-qingScientific 2024 · DOI

Abstract

With the increasingly intense academic competition, the stressors faced by doctoral students are gradually escalating. Based on the Job Demands-Resources Model, this study proposed a moderated moderation to explore how hindrance research stressors affect doctoral students' research creativity. Explicitly, the present study investigates whether the relationship between hindrance research stressors and research creativity is contingent on inclusive mentoring style and academic resilience. By analyzing the survey data from 538 valid questionnaire responses of doctoral students in China, this study has revealed that hindrance research stressors negatively relate to doctoral students' research creativity, and inclusive mentoring style from academic supervisors can mitigate the negative impact of hindrance research stressors on the research creativity of doctoral students. Furthermore, academic resilience strengthens the moderating effect of inclusive mentoring style. Specifically, it buffers the negative impact of hindrance research stressors on research creativity among doctoral students who receive high inclusive mentoring, but not among those with low levels of inclusive mentoring. These findings emphasize that effective strategies to enhance the research creativity of doctoral students who encounter hindrance stressors may require the joint consideration of contextual and personal resources.

Introduction

The "publish or perish" culture is intensifying globally, particularly in China, where PhD enrollment is booming. While stress is a known factor in graduate student life, research often focuses on supportive environments in isolation. This study investigates the impact of "hindrance research stressors"—factors like bureaucratic red tape, role ambiguity, and unfair evaluations—on doctoral students' research creativity. Unlike "challenge stressors" that can motivate, hindrance stressors offer no personal growth and typically deplete cognitive and emotional resources.

Conceptual Framework

The study utilizes the Job Demands-Resources (JD-R) model to explore how external resources (inclusive mentoring) and internal resources (academic resilience) moderate the negative relationship between hindrance stressors and creativity. The researchers hypothesized that these resources would interact to buffer the negative effects of a high-stress environment.

Theoretical model of the moderated moderation effect.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional survey of 538 doctoral students across 25 universities in mainland China. The sample included a balanced gender distribution (54.3% female) and covered various disciplines, with approximately 65% of participants coming from elite "Double First-Class" institutions.

Variables were measured using validated Likert-scale tools adapted for the PhD context:

  • Hindrance Research Stressors (HRS): Measured factors like bureaucracy and role ambiguity.
  • Research Creativity (RC): Self-reported creative output and ideation.
  • Inclusive Mentoring Style (IMS): Assessed PI openness, availability, and accessibility.
  • Academic Resilience (AR): Evaluated the personal psychological capacity to bounce back from academic setbacks.

Data analysis involved Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) to ensure construct validity and hierarchical regression to test the complex interaction effects.

Results

The analysis revealed several critical findings regarding the interplay of stress and support systems. As shown in the regression analysis, the model fit improved significantly as interaction terms were added.

Hierarchical regression results for research creativity across four models.

Main and Interaction Effects

  • Main Effect: Hindrance research stressors have a significant negative main effect on research creativity ($\beta = -0.088$, $p < 0.05$ in Model 2).
  • The PI as a Buffer: Inclusive mentoring significantly moderates the stress-creativity link ($\beta = 0.183$, $p < 0.001$ in Model 3). For students with low inclusive mentoring, stressors severely damage creativity; for those with high inclusive mentoring, this negative effect is neutralized.
  • The Three-Way Interaction: The most striking result is the significant three-way interaction between stressors, mentoring, and resilience ($\beta = 0.185$, $p < 0.001$ in Model 4). In the specific group of students possessing both high academic resilience and highly inclusive mentors, hindrance stressors actually showed a positive correlation with research creativity. This suggests that with the right support and mindset, students can find creative workarounds to bureaucratic hurdles.

Discussion and Conclusion

This research highlights that not all stress is created equal. While hindrance stressors are generally detrimental, the combination of an inclusive leader and personal resilience can transform these obstacles into catalysts for innovation. Supported by a good PI, highly resilient students may view environmental hurdles as puzzles to solve rather than insurmountable threats.

Limitations and Future Directions

The study relies on self-reported data, which may introduce social desirability bias. Additionally, the cross-sectional nature of the survey prevents definitive causal claims. Future research should incorporate objective creativity metrics (e.g., publication quality or independent ratings) and longitudinal designs to track these dynamics over the course of a doctoral program. Ultimately, the findings emphasize that enhancing doctoral creativity requires a dual approach: fostering inclusive leadership among PIs and building psychological resilience within the student body.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the increasingly intense academic competition, the stressors faced by doctoral students are gradually escalating. Based on the Job Demands-Resources Model, this study proposed a moderated moderation to explore how hindrance research stressors affect doctoral students' research creativity. Explicitly, the present study investigates whether the relationship between hindrance research stressors and research creativity is contingent on inclusive mentoring style and academic resilience. By analyzing the survey data from 538 valid questionnaire responses of doctoral students in China, this study has revealed that hindrance research stressors negatively relate to doctoral students' research creativity, and inclusive mentoring style from academic supervisors can mitigate the negative impact of hindrance research stressors on the research creativity of doctoral students. Furthermore, academic resilience strengthens the moderating effect of inclusive mentoring style. Specifically, it buffers the negative impact of hindrance research stressors on research creativity among doctoral students who receive high inclusive mentoring, but not among those with low levels of inclusive mentoring. These findings emphasize that effective strategies to enhance the research creativity of doctoral students who encounter hindrance stressors may require the joint consideration of contextual and personal resources.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2024three,
  author = {Chunlei Liu and Min Wu and Gao Xiao-qing},
  title = {{Three-way interaction effect of hindrance research stressors, inclusive mentoring style, and academic resilience on research creativity among doctoral students from China}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-024-69808-3},
}
Figure