How is personality related to research performance? The mediating effect of research engagement

Rui Feng, Yunhui Xie, Junjie WuFrontiers in Psychology 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Faculty members' research performance holds great significance for the development of a university. The primary objective of this study is to examine the influences of researchers' personalities on their research performance within universities, as well as the mediating role of research engagement in this relationship. The study encompassed 189 faculty members from a university and employed descriptive statistics, correlation analysis, measurement, and structural equation modeling as the analytical procedures. The results obtained from structural equation modeling reveal significant effects of faculty members' personalities on their objective research performance rather than self-reported performance. Specifically, conscientiousness and openness to experience exhibit a positive correlation with research performance. On the contrary, the neuroticism and social attributes of personality (the integration of extraversion and agreeableness) exhibit a negative correlation with research performance. Furthermore, research engagement mediates the effects of openness to experience and neuroticism on research performance. This study carries significant implications for the training and recruitment selection of faculty members in universities and enhances our understanding of how different personalities lead to a variance in research engagement and performance.

Introduction

A recent study published in Frontiers in Psychology explores the "internal wiring" of academia. While external factors like funding or gender gaps are frequently discussed in the context of research productivity, this research delves into the psychological drivers: how a researcher’s personality dictates their output and the role that "research engagement" plays in bridging that gap.

The Research Problem

In the "publish or perish" environment of modern higher education, identifying the traits of a productive researcher is crucial for university recruitment and faculty development. Research is a unique professional activity requiring long periods of solitary focus, high tolerance for failure, and intense cognitive engagement.

The authors identify a gap in existing literature regarding how personality specifically impacts objective research performance (actual publication metrics) versus subjective self-reporting. They also test a mediation model to determine if personality leads to better performance by fostering higher levels of "engagement" with the work.

Methodology

The researchers employed Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) to analyze data from 189 faculty members at a public university in China. The study combined self-reported survey data (collected between May and June 2021) with objective institutional records of publications, cross-referenced with the InCites-JCR web platform for impact factor rankings.

The hypothesized model illustrating the paths between personality traits, research engagement, and research performance.

Key Variables:

  • Personality Assessment: The Mini-IPIP scale was used to measure the "Big Five" traits. Notably, Extraversion and Agreeableness were clustered into a single factor termed "Social Attributes."
  • Research Engagement: Measured using a modified Utrecht Work Engagement Scale (UWES), focusing specifically on research-related tasks.
  • Performance Metrics: Objective data from university promotion reports were used, calculating weighted scores based on Journal Impact Factor (JIF) quartiles (Q1–Q4).

Key Results and Insights

The study revealed several significant relationships between personality and academic output:

  • Positive Predictors: Conscientiousness ($\beta = 1.259$) and Openness to Experience ($\beta = 0.284$) showed significant positive correlations with research performance.
  • Negative Predictors: Neuroticism ($\beta = -0.187$) and Social Attributes ($\beta = -2.961$) were negative predictors. The negative correlation of "social attributes" suggests that the solitary, concentrated nature of research may be taxing for highly social individuals.
  • The Role of Engagement: Research engagement was found to be the "engine" of productivity. It significantly mediated the relationship for Openness and Neuroticism, supporting the idea that these traits influence how a person works, which in turn influences what they produce.
  • Objective vs. Subjective: Personality traits had a much clearer impact on objective metrics than on researchers' subjective self-evaluations, suggesting that objective data is a more reliable measure for studying productivity.

Discussion and Implications

These findings have significant implications for faculty recruitment and development. Understanding that traits like conscientiousness and openness drive performance through engagement allows universities to better support their staff. However, the negative impact of high sociability suggests that the current structure of academic research may favor "lone wolf" behaviors, which might vary across different scientific disciplines.

Limitations and Future Work

The study's sample was limited to 189 participants from a single Chinese university, which may reflect specific cultural norms. Future research should explore cross-cultural samples and consider field-specific differences; for instance, in highly collaborative "Big Science" fields, extraversion might be an asset rather than a hindrance. Additionally, external factors such as teaching loads, administrative duties, and funding levels were not accounted for in this model. As a cross-sectional study, the directionality of the relationship between engagement and performance remains a subject for longitudinal investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Faculty members' research performance holds great significance for the development of a university. The primary objective of this study is to examine the influences of researchers' personalities on their research performance within universities, as well as the mediating role of research engagement in this relationship. The study encompassed 189 faculty members from a university and employed descriptive statistics, correlation analysis, measurement, and structural equation modeling as the analytical procedures. The results obtained from structural equation modeling reveal significant effects of faculty members' personalities on their objective research performance rather than self-reported performance. Specifically, conscientiousness and openness to experience exhibit a positive correlation with research performance. On the contrary, the neuroticism and social attributes of personality (the integration of extraversion and agreeableness) exhibit a negative correlation with research performance. Furthermore, research engagement mediates the effects of openness to experience and neuroticism on research performance. This study carries significant implications for the training and recruitment selection of faculty members in universities and enhances our understanding of how different personalities lead to a variance in research engagement and performance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{feng2024how,
  author = {Rui Feng and Yunhui Xie and Junjie Wu},
  title = {{How is personality related to research performance? The mediating effect of research engagement}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1257166},
}
Figure