Co-creating engaging experiences in the Chinese restaurant sector: a cross-regional study

Tengfei MaNottingham 2018

Abstract

In the evolving landscape of service marketing, the shift toward Service-Dominant (S-D) logic has placed customer co-creation and engagement at the forefront of strategic value. While extensively researched in Western contexts, these concepts remain under-explored within the unique cultural and economic landscape of China. This study investigates how traditional Chinese values—specifically face, guanxi, and harmony—influence customer co-creation behaviors in the full-service restaurant sector across different city tiers and economic regions. Utilizing a mixed-methods approach, the research reveals a surprising cultural homogeneity and a strong positive correlation between traditional values and active customer engagement.

Introduction: The Cultural Context of Co-creation

The adage "food is the first necessity of the people" underscores the central role restaurants play in Chinese social life. Beyond mere sustenance, dining is a platform for social interaction and value co-creation. However, existing literature on customer experience often focuses on large multinational corporations, leaving a gap in our understanding of the restaurant sector in developing economies. This research addresses this gap by examining whether regional economic disparities and varying strengths of traditional culture influence a diner's disposition to co-create their experience.

Methodology

Adopting a post-positivist stance, the study employed a two-phase mixed-methods design:

  1. Qualitative Phase: Four online focus groups were conducted with 24 frequent diners recruited from the Dianping forum (China’s equivalent of Yelp). This phase identified specific engagement behaviors and refined a measurement scale from an initial 99 items down to 56, ensuring the variables were contextually relevant to the Chinese restaurant experience.
  2. Quantitative Phase: A large-scale consumer survey was deployed across 12 cities, stratified by economic regions (East, Central, West, Northeast) and city tiers (Tier 1, 2, and 3).
  3. Data Analysis: Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) and Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) were used to analyze 657 usable responses. The analysis tested the relationships between cultural constructs, cognitive engagement, and co-creation behaviors (participation and citizenship).

Key Findings: The "Homogeneity" Surprise

A primary hypothesis of the study was that rapid urbanization and Western influence in "Tier 1" cities (like Tianjin) would lead to a decline in traditional values compared to developing regions. Surprisingly, the data rejected this notion. Chinese consumers across all city tiers and regions displayed a high degree of cultural homogeneity. Traditional values—face (social status), guanxi (relationships), and harmony—remain robust drivers of consumer behavior regardless of geographic or economic location.

Culture as a Catalyst for Engagement

The research confirmed that traditional values are positively related to co-creation behaviors. Specifically:

  • Citizenship Behavior: Diners who value social harmony and "giving face" are more likely to engage in voluntary "extra-role" behaviors, such as providing constructive feedback to staff or helping other customers.
  • Cognitive Engagement: The quality of the dining experience acts as a mediator; positive cognitive engagement amplifies the influence of cultural values on a customer's willingness to advocate for the brand.

New Dimensions of Interaction

The study identified three unique constructs of interaction within the Chinese context:

  • Interest Interaction: A desire to understand the provenance and preparation of food.
  • Novel Interaction: An appetite for tech-driven or unique service innovations.
  • Communication Interaction: The importance of polite and respectful information exchange between staff and diners.

Theoretical and Practical Implications

Theoretically, this research expands S-D logic by integrating cultural variables (face, guanxi, harmony) into the co-creation framework within a non-Western, developing country context. It challenges the assumption that economic development necessarily leads to a dilution of traditional cultural drivers in consumer behavior.

Practically, the findings offer a roadmap for restaurant practitioners. The willingness of Chinese consumers to co-create suggests that restaurants should provide more opportunities for interaction and feedback. Managers should recognize that "giving face" and maintaining "harmony" are not just social graces but strategic tools that encourage customer loyalty and advocacy. Furthermore, the lack of regional variation suggests that standardized engagement strategies may be effective across different Chinese markets.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This study demonstrates that traditional culture remains a powerful force in the modern Chinese service economy. While the research focused on positive engagement, future studies should explore the "dark side" of these values—how a loss of "face" might lead to intense negative engagement or "co-destruction." As China continues to evolve, longitudinal research will be essential to track whether this cultural homogeneity persists or if new middle-class subcultures emerge to redefine the dining experience.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the rise of the service-dominant logic paradigm, the notion of co-creation and its associated term customer engagement have attracted a great deal of attention. Although they are explored extensively in the Western context and being suggested as strategic tools that can bring higher value for both firm and its customers, only a few studies have examined them in a Chinese context. Existing studies on customer experience are mainly concerned with large companies and their customers, but not on restaurants and their customers. The notion that 'food is the first thing for people' is the most critical and essential idea in Chinese life. Restaurants play a significant role in Chinese social life. To help close the gap between what currently know about Chinese consumer behaviour and what don’t know, especially in the specific context of co-creation behaviour in China full-service restaurant, five objectives along with six general hypotheses are set.
\n 
\nThis research is from a post-positivist stance, utilising two kinds of methods in research. A qualitative strand is used to develop a set of scales/questionnaire, which represents relevant latent variables in respect of co-creation and customer engagement in the specific research context. In the quantitative strand, the questionnaire/scale is used for conducting a major consumer survey in China's economic regions and city tiers, with the intention of measuring the nature, direction and strength of relevant relationships between a range of latent variables. The objective here is to test the overall position that because of inherent regional and socio-economic variety in the strength of Chinese culture, customer disposition to co-create the restaurant experience will similarly vary. For the analysis, descriptive analysis was used initially (frequencies, percentages) to for primary data. Cronbach’s alpha, confirmatory factor analysis (CFA), and structural equation modelling are used to test a conceptual model. Hypothesis testing is employed in the analysis and the presentation of the findings of this study. This research confirms there is a positive relationship between Chinese culture and co-creation behaviour (participation behaviour and citizenship behaviour), irrespective of which city tier or geographical region they live in.
\n 
\nThis research contributes to understandings of Chinese restaurant consumer behaviour in two main respects. For the theory, three additional variables have been added to expand the initial set of variables in order tocapture all pertinent co-creational content in China full-restaurant context fully; Drawing on consumer behaviour theory generally and consumer culture theory in particular, this research assesses their manifestations and fills the gap of the notions co-creation, customer engagement in less-developed country; this research is the first study to adopt the variables city tier and economic regions as moderator to explore co-creation/engagement behaviour under Chinese culture. For the practice, this research offers reviews and guidance for restaurant and service practitioners, suggests Chinese restaurant consumers are more willing to participate in the co-creation of their dining experiences than might have been expected and that neither expected variations in strength of Chinese culture across regions or city tiers, nor an associated variation in disposition to co-create in a restaurant context, are in evidence.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ma2018co,
  author = {Tengfei Ma},
  title = {{Co-creating engaging experiences in the Chinese restaurant sector: a cross-regional study}},
  booktitle = {Nottingham},
  year = {2018},
}
Figure