Two Sides of a Coin: a Zika Virus Mutation Selected in Pregnant Rhesus Macaques Promotes Fetal Infection in Mice but at a Cost of Reduced Fitness in Nonpregnant Macaques and Diminished Transmissibility by Vectors

Danilo Lemos, Jackson B. Stuart, William Louie, Anil Singapuri, Ana L. Ramírez, Jennifer Watanabe, Jodie Usachenko, Rebekah I. Keesler, Claudia Sánchez-San Martín, Tony Li, Calla Martyn, Glenn Oliveira, Sharada Saraf, Nathan D. Grubaugh, Kristian G. Andersen, James B. Thissen, Jonathan Allen, Monica K. Borucki, Konstantin A. Tsetsarkin, Alexander G. Pletnev, Charles Y. Chiu, Koen K. A. Van Rompay, Lark L. Coffey

TL;DR

This study identifies a specific mutation (M1404I) in the Zika virus (ZIKV) that enhances its ability to infect fetuses in pregnant mice, but at the cost of reduced fitness in non-pregnant macaques and decreased transmission by mosquitoes. This highlights how viral mutations can have complex, context-dependent fitness trade-offs, impacting their potential to spread during outbreaks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Congenital Zika syndrome (CZS) can lead to severe outcomes like microcephaly and fetal death, but the precise viral genetic factors contributing to these outcomes remain unclear. While inter-host evolution of ZIKV has been studied, the role of intra-host evolution (mutations arising within a single infected individual) in influencing disease severity and transmission dynamics is less understood. This paper investigates how specific mutations that emerge within an infected host might impact ZIKV's ability to cause disease, particularly in pregnancy, and its subsequent transmission to vectors.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Deep Sequencing: To identify mutations within ZIKV populations from infected pregnant rhesus macaques and their fetuses.
  • Infectious Clone-Derived Viruses: They created engineered ZIKV strains (M1404 and I1404) that differed only at the specific mutation site to isolate its effects.
  • In Vitro Growth Assays: ZIKV strains were tested in cell cultures (Vero and C6/36 mosquito cells) to assess their replication kinetics.
  • Animal Models:
    • Nonpregnant Rhesus Macaques: Used for competition experiments (mixed infections) to assess relative viral fitness in a primate model.
  • Pregnant Mice (CD-1): Used to evaluate the mutation's impact on fetal infection and placental health.
  • Vector Competence Assays: Aedes aegypti mosquitoes were used to determine if the mutation affected ZIKV's ability to be transmitted by the primary vector.
  • Quantitative Reverse Transcription PCR (qRT-PCR): Used to measure viral RNA levels in various tissues and samples.
  • Sanger Sequencing: Used for targeted sequencing to confirm the presence and identity of the mutation in specific samples.

Datasets

Not applicable. This study involves experimental infections and sequencing of viral RNA from biological samples, rather than training on pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Intrahost Evolution Matters: Mutations arising within a single host can have significant implications for viral fitness and disease dynamics, even if they don't become dominant in the broader population.
  • Fitness Trade-offs are Crucial: The M1404I mutation demonstrates a clear trade-off: it enhances ZIKV's ability to infect fetuses in pregnant hosts but compromises its fitness in non-pregnant hosts and its transmission by mosquitoes. This explains why such a mutation might not readily spread during widespread outbreaks.
  • Pregnancy as a Selective Environment: The pregnant state appears to create a unique selective pressure that favors the M1404I mutation, leading to increased viral replication and fetal infection.
  • Vector Transmission is a Bottleneck: Even if a mutation benefits the virus in a vertebrate host, reduced transmissibility to vectors can prevent its widespread dissemination.

Key Results

  • A single mutation, M1404I, was identified in the ZIKV NS2B protein in a rhesus macaque fetus that died after inoculation. This mutation was also found at subconsensus frequencies in other pregnant macaques and their fetuses.
  • In nonpregnant rhesus macaques, ZIKV with the M1404I mutation (I1404) exhibited lower viremias and was a weaker competitor compared to the wild-type (M1404).
  • In pregnant mice, ZIKV I1404 significantly increased the magnitude and rate of placental infection and conferred fetal infection, a phenotype not observed with ZIKV M1404.
  • Aedes aegypti mosquitoes transmitted ZIKV I1404 less efficiently than ZIKV M1404.
  • The M1404I mutation showed context-specific fitness advantages, being beneficial in pregnant mice but detrimental in nonpregnant macaques and vectors.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Human Data: While the mutation was identified in macaques, its rarity in human consensus genomes limits direct conclusions about its role in human CZS. The study acknowledges that only one microcephalic fetus had this mutation.
  • Time and Tissue Specificity: The fitness advantage of the M1404I mutation in pregnant mice appeared to be time and tissue-specific, with some reversion to the wild-type observed and a lack of fetal infection at later stages. Further investigation into the kinetics of fetoplacental infection over time is warranted.
  • Vector Transmission Dynamics: While transmission was reduced at 7 days post-feeding, further studies examining mosquito saliva at earlier or later time points could clarify the full transmission dynamics of ZIKV I1404.
  • Mechanisms of Action: The precise molecular mechanisms by which the M1404I mutation enhances fetoplacental infection and its interaction with host factors remain to be fully elucidated. Future work could explore subcellular changes and virus-host interactions mediated by this mutation.
  • Extrapolation to Humans: The authors caution against directly extrapolating findings from mice and macaques to humans, emphasizing the need for continued research across multiple systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although fetal death is now understood to be a severe outcome of congenital Zika syndrome, the role of viral genetics is still unclear. We sequenced Zika virus (ZIKV) from a rhesus macaque fetus that died after inoculation and identified a single intrahost substitution, M1404I, in the ZIKV polyprotein, located in nonstructural protein 2B (NS2B). Targeted sequencing flanking position 1404 in 9 additional macaque mothers and their fetuses identified M1404I at a subconsensus frequency in the majority (5 of 9, 56%) of animals and some of their fetuses. Despite its repeated presence in pregnant macaques, M1404I has occurred rarely in humans since 2015. Since the primary ZIKV transmission cycle is human-mosquito-human, mutations in one host must be retained in the alternate host to be perpetuated. We hypothesized that ZIKV I1404 increases viral fitness in nonpregnant macaques and pregnant mice but is less efficiently transmitted by vectors, explaining its low frequency in humans during outbreaks. By examining competitive fitness relative to that of ZIKV M1404, we observed that ZIKV I1404 produced lower viremias in nonpregnant macaques and was a weaker competitor in tissues. In pregnant wild-type mice, ZIKV I1404 increased the magnitude and rate of placental infection and conferred fetal infection, in contrast to ZIKV M1404, which was not detected in fetuses. Although infection and dissemination rates were not different, <i>Aedes aegypti</i> mosquitoes transmitted ZIKV I1404 more poorly than ZIKV M1404. Our data highlight the complexity of arbovirus mutation-fitness dynamics and suggest that intrahost ZIKV mutations capable of augmenting fitness in pregnant vertebrates may not necessarily spread efficiently via mosquitoes during epidemics.<b>IMPORTANCE</b> Although Zika virus infection of pregnant women can result in congenital Zika syndrome, the factors that cause the syndrome in some but not all infected mothers are still unclear. We identified a mutation that was present in some ZIKV genomes in experimentally inoculated pregnant rhesus macaques and their fetuses. Although we did not find an association between the presence of the mutation and fetal death, we performed additional studies with ZIKV with the mutation in nonpregnant macaques, pregnant mice, and mosquitoes. We observed that the mutation increased the ability of the virus to infect mouse fetuses but decreased its capacity to produce high levels of virus in the blood of nonpregnant macaques and to be transmitted by mosquitoes. This study shows that mutations in mosquito-borne viruses like ZIKV that increase fitness in pregnant vertebrates may not spread in outbreaks when they compromise transmission via mosquitoes and fitness in nonpregnant hosts.
BibTeX
@article{lemos2020two,
  author = {Danilo Lemos and Jackson B. Stuart and William Louie and Anil Singapuri and Ana L. Ramírez and Jennifer Watanabe and Jodie Usachenko and Rebekah I. Keesler and Claudia Sánchez-San Martín and Tony Li and Calla Martyn and Glenn Oliveira and Sharada Saraf and Nathan D. Grubaugh and Kristian G. Andersen and James B. Thissen and Jonathan Allen and Monica K. Borucki and Konstantin A. Tsetsarkin and Alexander G. Pletnev and Charles Y. Chiu and Koen K. A. Van Rompay and Lark L. Coffey},
  title = {{Two Sides of a Coin: a Zika Virus Mutation Selected in Pregnant Rhesus Macaques Promotes Fetal Infection in Mice but at a Cost of Reduced Fitness in Nonpregnant Macaques and Diminished Transmissibility by Vectors}},
  journal = {Journal of Virology},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1128/jvi.01605-20},
}
Figure