Two decades of neuroscience publication trends in Africa

Mahmoud Bukar Maina, Umar Ahmad, Ibrahim Harun Arrashid, Salihu Hamidu, Fayza Eid Nasr, Abubakar Tijjani Salihu, Abdelrahman Ibrahim Abushouk, Muhammad Abdurrazak, Mosab Ali Awadelkareem, Abdulbasit Amin, Aminu Imam, Ibukun Akinrinade, Abdulbasit Haliru Yakubu, Idris A. Azeez, Yunusa Garba Mohammed, A N D U A L E M T S E H A Y E Adamu, H. B. Ibrahim, Ali Maina Bukar, A. U. Yaro, Baba Waru Goni, Lucia L. Prieto-Godino, Tom BadenNature Communications 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Neuroscience research in Africa remains sparse. Devising new policies to boost Africa's neuroscience landscape is imperative, but these must be based on accurate data on research outputs which is largely lacking. Such data must reflect the heterogeneity of research environments across the continent's 54 countries. Here, we analyse neuroscience publications affiliated with African institutions between 1996 and 2017. Of 12,326 PubMed indexed publications, 5,219 show clear evidence that the work was performed in Africa and led by African-based researchers - on average ~5 per country and year. From here, we extract information on journals and citations, funding, international coauthorships and techniques used. For reference, we also extract the same metrics from 220 randomly selected publications each from the UK, USA, Australia, Japan and Brazil. Our dataset provides insights into the current state of African neuroscience research in a global context.

Introduction

Africa carries 25% of the global disease burden and possesses the world’s greatest human genetic diversity, yet its contribution to global neuroscience has historically been underrepresented. Previous attempts to quantify African research output often relied on automated keyword searches that failed to distinguish between research about Africa (often led by Western labs) and research led by African institutions. This study addresses the lack of granular, curated data needed to inform policy, seeking to identify who is conducting the research, how it is funded, and its visibility on the global stage.

Methodology

Researchers performed a manual curation of 12,326 neuroscience-related articles from PubMed (1996–2017) associated with all 54 African countries. A team of trained neuroscientists screened every paper to ensure the work was performed in Africa and led by African-based researchers, resulting in a final dataset of 5,219 "African-led" papers. Research methods were classified into Type 1 (low-resource: histology, behavior) and Type 2 (high-resource: fMRI, molecular cloning, electron microscopy). For global context, African metrics were compared against 871 randomly selected papers from the UK, USA, Australia, Japan, and Brazil.

The analysis reveals a continent with rapidly growing output but significant concentration. Neuroscience output in Africa is at an all-time high, following an exponential increase over the study period. However, 75% of all African neuroscience originates from just five countries: Egypt, South Africa, Nigeria, Morocco, and Tunisia.

Figure 4: Geographic distribution of neuroscience publications across Africa (a), temporal growth by region (b), and research area distribution compared to non-African benchmarks (c).

Research Focus and Technological Gaps

African research shows unique regional strengths, such as West Africa’s high concentration of studies on endemic medicinal plants. However, a significant "technological lag" persists. While 75% of papers from the UK, USA, and Japan utilized advanced "Type 2" techniques, most African nations utilized these methods in fewer than 10% of their publications. Furthermore, there is a near-total absence of cost-effective, genetically tractable models like Drosophila or zebrafish, with African research remaining heavily reliant on wild-type rats and mice.

Visibility and Impact

Scientific visibility varies significantly by region. Southern Africa leads the continent in impact, with citation rates comparable to Brazil. In contrast, West African papers averaged significantly fewer citations. The study also identified a "collaboration paradox," where African researchers are more likely to collaborate with scientists in Europe or North America than with colleagues in neighboring African regions, a pattern that closely mirrors international flight routes.

Figure 5: Comparison of citations (a) and journal impact factors (b) across African regions, Brazil, and the Global North. (c) Correlation between citations and journal impact factor.

Discussion and Future Outlook

The data suggests that for African neuroscience to reach its potential, governments must move beyond international aid and establish sustainable, domestic funding streams. Currently, 35% of top-cited African papers declared no funding, suggesting a reliance on self-funding or hidden institutional support.

To bridge the technological and resource gap, the authors advocate for the adoption of "research-grade open hardware" (such as 3D-printed lab equipment) and a shift toward invertebrate model systems (C. elegans, Drosophila) which provide high genetic power at a fraction of the cost of rodent facilities. Only by meeting the African Union’s recommendation of investing 1% of GDP into R&D can African nations ensure the long-term sustainability of their neuroscience landscapes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Neuroscience research in Africa remains sparse. Devising new policies to boost Africa's neuroscience landscape is imperative, but these must be based on accurate data on research outputs which is largely lacking. Such data must reflect the heterogeneity of research environments across the continent's 54 countries. Here, we analyse neuroscience publications affiliated with African institutions between 1996 and 2017. Of 12,326 PubMed indexed publications, 5,219 show clear evidence that the work was performed in Africa and led by African-based researchers - on average ~5 per country and year. From here, we extract information on journals and citations, funding, international coauthorships and techniques used. For reference, we also extract the same metrics from 220 randomly selected publications each from the UK, USA, Australia, Japan and Brazil. Our dataset provides insights into the current state of African neuroscience research in a global context.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{maina2021two,
  author = {Mahmoud Bukar Maina and Umar Ahmad and Ibrahim Harun Arrashid and SALIHU HAMIDU and Fayza Eid Nasr and Abubakar Tijjani Salihu and Abdelrahman Ibrahim Abushouk and Muhammad Abdurrazak and Mosab Ali Awadelkareem and Abdulbasit Amin and Aminu Imam and Ibukun Akinrinade and Abdulbasit Haliru Yakubu and Idris A. Azeez and Yunusa Garba Mohammed and A N D U A L E M T S E H A Y E Adamu and H. B. Ibrahim and Ali Maina Bukar and A. U. Yaro and Baba Waru Goni and Lucia L. Prieto-Godino and Tom Baden},
  title = {{Two decades of neuroscience publication trends in Africa}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-021-23784-8},
}
Figure