20 years of African Neuroscience: Waking a sleeping giant

Mahmoud Bukar Maina, Umar Ahmad, Ha Ibrahim, Salihu Hamidu, Fayza Eid Nasr, Abubakar Tijjani Salihu, Ai Abushouk, Muhammad Abdurrazak, Ma Awadelkareem, Abdulbasit Amin, Aminu Imam, Id Akinrinade, Ah Yakubu, Idris A. Azeez, Gm Yunusa, A N D U A L E M T S E H A Y E Adamu, Am Bukar, A. U. Yaro, Lucia L. Prieto-Godino, Tom BadenbioRxiv 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Understanding the function and dysfunction of the brain remains one of the key challenges of our time. However, an overwhelming majority of brain research is carried out in the Global North, by a minority of well-funded and intimately interconnected labs. In contrast, with an estimated one neuroscientist per million people in Africa, news about neuroscience research from the Global South remains sparse. Clearly, devising new policies to boost Africa’s neuroscience landscape is imperative. However, the policy must be based on accurate data, which is largely lacking. Such data must reflect the extreme heterogeneity of research outputs across the continent’s 54 countries. Here, we analysed all of Africa’s Neuroscience output over the past 21 years. Uniquely, we individually verified in each of 12,326 publications that the work was indeed performed in Africa and led by African-based researchers. The remaining number of African-led Neuroscience publications was 5,219, on average only ~5 per country and year. Our unique dataset allows us to gain accurate and in-depth information on the current state of African Neuroscience research, and to put it into a global context.

Introduction

Neuroscience research is overwhelmingly dominated by the Global North. While Africa accounts for 15% of the global population and a disproportionate share of the global disease burden, its research landscape has historically been a "black box." Previous attempts to quantify African research output often relied on simple database scrapes that "grossly inflated" figures by including "helicopter science"—studies where data or samples are collected in Africa but analyzed and led by labs in Europe or North America. To build effective science policy, a granular, "ground-truth" dataset is required to distinguish truly African-led research from international collaborations where the primary work happens elsewhere.

Methods

The researchers performed a massive manual curation of the literature, starting with 12,326 PubMed-listed publications from 1996 to 2017. The novel step was manual verification: the team screened the full text of every paper to ensure the work was actually performed in an African lab and led by an African-based researcher. This process eliminated ~58% of the initial results, leaving a core dataset of 5,219 African-led papers. These were categorized by research topic, techniques used, model systems, and funding/collaboration networks. This primary dataset was compared against 1,100 randomly selected papers from the UK, USA, Australia, Japan, and Brazil to provide global context.

Results and Discussion

Geographic Concentration and Growth

African neuroscience output is growing exponentially, yet it remains heavily concentrated. Just five countries—Egypt, South Africa, Nigeria, Morocco, and Tunisia—produce over 75% of the continent's neuroscience. More than half of African countries produce fewer than 10 papers over the entire 20-year period.

Comprehensive overview of African neuroscience research output, including geographic distribution (A), temporal growth (B), and research themes (C).

Socioeconomic Drivers

Analysis of external metrics revealed strong correlations between research output and national wealth. GDP (p = 0.80) and population size (p = 0.81) are major predictors of publication volume. Interestingly, R&D spending showed a moderate correlation (p = 0.58), while the Corruption Perception Index had a weak negative correlation (p = -0.22), suggesting that economic scale is a more dominant factor than governance quality in determining current research volume.

Correlations between publication output and GDP, R&D spending, population, and corruption index.

The Technical and Model System Gap

A significant disparity exists in the use of "advanced" techniques. Less than 10% of publications from most African countries used methods like fluorescence microscopy or molecular biology, compared to 75% in the UK, USA, and Japan. Furthermore, genetically tractable models like Drosophila (fruit flies) or zebrafish are almost entirely absent, with most research relying on wild-type rodents or human clinical observations.

Collaboration and Funding

African researchers rarely collaborate with their neighbors; "intra-African" collaboration is nearly non-existent compared to "outward" collaboration with Europe and North America. Funding also remains a critical bottleneck. 35% of Africa’s top-cited papers declared no funding at all, suggesting a high degree of self-funding. Southern Africa was the only region where domestic funding mentions exceeded international ones.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While African neuroscience is "waking up," significant structural barriers remain. The authors propose several actionable recommendations to support future growth:

  1. Policy Advocacy: Lobbying African governments to meet the African Union’s target of investing 1% of GDP into R&D.
  2. Open Hardware: Promoting the design and local production of research-grade equipment to bypass the high cost of imported tools.
  3. Regulatory Frameworks: Establishing national guidelines for the import and use of transgenic animals to encourage the adoption of modern genetic models.
  4. Natural Product Discovery: Leveraging West Africa's unique strength in medicinal plant research to lead in natural product drug discovery.

Summary updated

Abstract

Understanding the function and dysfunction of the brain remains one of the key challenges of our time. However, an overwhelming majority of brain research is carried out in the Global North, by a minority of well-funded and intimately interconnected labs. In contrast, with an estimated one neuroscientist per million people in Africa, news about neuroscience research from the Global South remains sparse. Clearly, devising new policies to boost Africa’s neuroscience landscape is imperative. However, the policy must be based on accurate data, which is largely lacking. Such data must reflect the extreme heterogeneity of research outputs across the continent’s 54 countries distributed over an area larger than USA, Europe and China combined. Here, we analysed all of Africa’s Neuroscience output over the past 21 years. Uniquely, we individually verified in each of 12,326 publications that the work was indeed performed in Africa and led by African-based researchers. This step is critical: previous estimates grossly inflated figures, because many of Africa’s high-visibility publications are in fact the result of internationally led collaborations, with most work done outside of Africa. The remaining number of African-led Neuroscience publications was 5,219, on average only ~5 per country and year. From here, we extracted metrics such as the journal and citations, as well as detailed information on funding, international collaborations and the techniques and model systems used. We link these metrics to demographic data and indicators of mobility and economy. For reference, we also extracted the same metrics from 220 randomly selected publications each from the UK, USA, Australia, Japan and Brazil. Our unique dataset allows us to gain accurate and in-depth information on the current state of African Neuroscience research, and to put it into a global context. This in turn allows us to make actionable recommendations on how African research might best be supported in the future.
BibTeX
@misc{maina2020years,
  author = {Mahmoud Bukar Maina and Umar Ahmad and HA Ibrahim and SALIHU HAMIDU and Fayza Eid Nasr and Abubakar Tijjani Salihu and AI Abushouk and Muhammad Abdurrazak and MA Awadelkareem and Abdulbasit Amin and Aminu Imam and ID Akinrinade and AH Yakubu and Idris A. Azeez and GM Yunusa and A N D U A L E M T S E H A Y E Adamu and H. B. Ibrahim and AM Bukar and A. U. Yaro and Lucia L. Prieto-Godino and Tom Baden},
  title = {{20 years of African Neuroscience: Waking a sleeping giant}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.06.03.131391},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure