A Framework for Advancing Sustainable MRI Access in Africa
Udunna Anazodo, Jinggang J. Ng, Boaz Ehiogu, Johnes Obungoloch, Abiodun Fatade, Henk Mutsaerts, Mario Forjaz Secca, Mamadou Diop, Abayomi Emmanuel Opadele, Daniel C. Alexander, Michael O. Dada, Godwin Ogbole, Rita Nunes, Patrícia Figueiredo, Matteo Figni, Benjamin Aribisala, Bamidele O. Awojoyogbe, Christian Sprenger, Alausa Olakunle, Dominic J. Romeo, Francis Fezeu, Akintunde T. Orunmuyi, Sairam Geethanath, Vikas Gulani, Edward Nganga, Sola Adeleke, Ntusi Ntobeuko, Frank J. Minja, Andrew Webb, Iris Asllani, Farouk DakomedRxiv2022 · DOI
Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) is a cornerstone of modern diagnostics, yet its availability in Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) is critically limited. With a rising burden of non-communicable diseases, there is an urgent need to address the continent's low MRI density—currently averaging fewer than one scanner per million people. This paper introduces the CAMERA Conceptual Framework, developed by the Consortium for Advancement of MRI Education & Research in Africa. Based on a comprehensive Needs Assessment Survey (NAS) and expert symposia, the framework provides a strategic roadmap focused on advocacy, specialized training, and technological innovation to establish a sustainable and equitable neuroimaging ecosystem across SSA.
Introduction: The MRI Access Gap
While non-communicable diseases (NCDs) such as cancer, stroke, and cardiovascular disorders are often associated with high-income nations, their impact is rapidly increasing in Sub-Saharan Africa. MRI is the gold standard for diagnosing these conditions, but access is hindered by a "perfect storm" of barriers. These include prohibitive out-of-pocket costs (averaging $200 per scan), unstable power infrastructure, and a severe shortage of trained personnel, such as MRI physicists and biomedical engineers. Consequently, many existing scanners are either obsolete or underutilized.
Methodology
To map the current landscape and design a viable solution, researchers utilized a mixed-methods approach:
Needs Assessment Survey (NAS): A 68-question survey completed by 157 clinicians and scientists across 12 SSA countries.
Data Integration: NAS results were synthesized with global databases from the World Health Organization (WHO) and the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA).
Expert Symposia: Qualitative insights were gathered through three international symposia held at ISMRM and ESMRMB meetings.
The CAMERA Conceptual Framework
The resulting CAMERA Conceptual Framework is built upon four strategic pillars designed to create an enabling environment for clinical and research MRI.
The CAMERA Conceptual Framework illustrates the integration of Advocacy, Training, Networking, and Innovation to improve MRI accessibility.
Advocacy and Networking: Building partnerships between African experts and global societies to influence policy and resource allocation.
Effective Training: Moving beyond basic operation to "train-the-teacher" models that build local capacity for maintenance and research.
Translational Innovation: Prioritizing technologies suited for low-resource settings. This includes modern low-field MRI (<1T), which is more robust against power fluctuations and does not require expensive liquid helium.
AI Integration: Leveraging techniques like Image Quality Transfer (IQT) to use AI to "up-sample" images from affordable low-field scanners, achieving quality comparable to high-field systems.
Results: The Current Landscape
The integrated data reveals a stark disparity in global imaging resources. Africa averages just 0.8 scanners per million people, compared to 11.6 in Eurasia.
Map of Africa showing current and projected MRI density (pmp), highlighting the significant gap in access.
Equipment Status: 39% of scanners in the region are low-field systems, and 81% of these are considered obsolete.
The Paradox of Underutilization: Despite the scarcity of equipment, only 8% of facilities scan more than 15 patients daily. This is largely due to the fact that 89% of services must be paid for out-of-pocket, making them inaccessible to most patients.
Staffing Crisis: 65% of facilities operate without a staff MRI physicist, which is a critical factor in equipment downtime and poor protocol optimization.
Conclusion and Future Directions
The CAMERA framework aims to shift the paradigm from Africa being a passive recipient of donated, often obsolete technology to becoming a hub for "need-specific innovation." By fostering local expertise and adopting sustainable technologies, the goal is to achieve lasting and equitable MRI access for all Africans. Future work will focus on establishing an African Chapter of the ISMRM and expanding training programs to ensure the long-term viability of the continent's neuroimaging infrastructure.
Summary updated
Abstract
Summary MRI technology has profoundly transformed current healthcare and research systems globally. The rapidly growing burden of non-communicable diseases in Africa has underscored the importance of improving access to MRI equipment as well as training and research opportunities on the continent. The Consortium for Advancement of MRI Education & Research in Africa (CAMERA) is a network of African experts, global partners, and ISMRM/ESMRMB members implementing novel strategies to advance MRI access and research in Africa. To identify challenges to MRI usage and provide a framework for addressing MRI needs in the region, CAMERA conducted a Needs Assessment Survey (NAS) and a series of symposia at international MRI society meetings over a 2-year period. The 68-question NAS was distributed to MRI users in Africa and completed by 157 clinicians and scientists from across Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA). On average, the number of MRI scanners per million people remained at <1, of which, 39% were obsolete low-field systems yet still in use to meet clinical needs. The feasibility of coupling stable energy supplies from various sources has contributed to the growing number of higher-field (1.5T) MRI scanners in the region. However, these systems are underutilized with only 8% of facilities reporting clinical scans of 15 or more patients daily per scanner. The most frequently reported MRI scans were neurological and musculoskeletal. Our NAS combined with the World Health Organization and International Atomic Energy Agency data provides the most up-to-date data on MRI density in Africa and offers unique insight into Africa’s MRI needs. Reported gaps in training, maintenance, and research capacity indicate ongoing challenges in providing sustainable high-value MRI access in SSA. Findings from the NAS and focused discussions at ISMRM and ESMRMB provided the basis for the framework presented here for advancing MRI capacity in SSA. Graphical Abstract Africa has a massive population with few infrastructural resources and an untapped potential to effect transformative change in healthcare. To advance MRI access across all African countries and meet the sustainable development goals of improving health and wellbeing in low-resource settings over the next decade, the MRI community is called to partner with CAMERA to create enabling clinical and research MRI environments that will utilize the rich intellectual resources in Africa to realize lasting and equitable MRI for all Africans and the world at large.
BibTeX
@misc{anazodo2022framework,
author = {Udunna Anazodo and Jinggang J. Ng and Boaz Ehiogu and Johnes Obungoloch and Abiodun Fatade and Henk Mutsaerts and Mario Forjaz Secca and Mamadou Diop and Abayomi Emmanuel Opadele and Daniel C. Alexander and Michael O. Dada and Godwin Ogbole and Rita Nunes and Patrícia Figueiredo and Matteo Figni and Benjamin Aribisala and Bamidele O. Awojoyogbe and Christian Sprenger and Alausa Olakunle and Dominic J. Romeo and Francis Fezeu and Akintunde T. Orunmuyi and Sairam Geethanath and Vikas Gulani and Edward Nganga and Sola Adeleke and Ntusi Ntobeuko and Frank J. Minja and Andrew Webb and Iris Asllani and Farouk Dako},
title = {{A Framework for Advancing Sustainable MRI Access in Africa}},
year = {2022},
doi = {10.1101/2022.05.02.22274588},
howpublished = {medRxiv},
}