Tropospheric ozone retrieval by a combination of TROPOMI/S5P measurements with BASCOE assimilated data

Klaus-Peter Heue, Diego Loyola, Fabian Romahn, Walter Zimmer, Simon Chabrillat, Quentin Errera, J. R. Ziemke, N. A. Kramarova

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a new high-resolution global dataset for tropospheric ozone by combining TROPOMI satellite measurements with the BASCOE stratospheric assimilation model. This "residual" approach provides daily global coverage at an unprecedented spatial resolution of 5.5 x 3.5 km², offering a powerful new tool for monitoring air quality and greenhouse gas dynamics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Tropospheric ozone is a "double agent" in atmospheric science: it is a harmful pollutant that damages human health and crop yields, and it acts as a potent greenhouse gas. However, measuring it from space is notoriously difficult. About 90% of the Earth's ozone resides in the stratosphere; the tropospheric signal is a small fraction of the total column measured by satellites.

Existing methods often fall short. The Convective Cloud Differential (CCD) method is highly accurate but only works in the tropics. Other "limb-nadir matching" techniques, which subtract stratospheric profiles from total columns, often suffer from low spatial resolution or gaps in global coverage. This paper addresses the need for a high-resolution, daily, global tropospheric ozone product that can resolve local pollution plumes and complex atmospheric transport.

Methods

The authors employ a "residual method" consisting of three primary steps:

  1. Total Column Retrieval: They use data from the TROPOMI instrument on the Sentinel-5 Precursor satellite, which measures the total ozone column at high resolution using ultraviolet spectroscopy.
  2. Stratospheric Estimation: They utilize the BASCOE (Belgian Assimilation System for Chemical ObsErvations). This system assimilates high-quality vertical ozone profiles from the Microwave Limb Sounder (MLS) to create a robust 3D map of stratospheric ozone.
  3. Subtraction: The BASCOE stratospheric data is interpolated to the exact time and location of the TROPOMI pixels and subtracted from the total column. The remaining "residual" is the tropospheric ozone column.

What sets this apart from standard methods is the integration of a sophisticated chemical transport model (BASCOE) constrained by actual limb-sounding measurements, allowing the high resolution of the TROPOMI sensor to be preserved in the final tropospheric product.

Datasets

  • TROPOMI/S5P: Total ozone columns (the primary high-resolution input).
  • BASCOE/MLS: Stratospheric ozone profiles used for the subtraction.
  • OMPS-MERRA-2: A secondary satellite-based tropospheric ozone product used for global cross-comparison.
  • TROPOMI_CCD: The operational tropical tropospheric ozone product used to validate results in the equatorial belt.
  • Ozonesondes: Data from over 60 globally distributed weather balloon stations (2,254 individual comparisons) served as the "ground truth" for validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Preserving Resolution: By interpolating the model data to the satellite's grid rather than binning the satellite data into a coarse model grid, the researchers maintained a resolution of 5.5 x 3.5 km². This allows for the detection of localized features like stratospheric intrusions or urban pollution plumes.
  • The Power of Assimilation: Using BASCOE (which is constrained by MLS observations) is more reliable than using a "pure" model. It ensures the stratospheric "background" being subtracted is as accurate as possible, reducing errors in the tropospheric residual.
  • Consistency Across Methods: The new S5P-BASCOE product showed excellent agreement with the established CCD method in the tropics (bias of only -0.91 DU), suggesting the residual method is robust even in regions where other specialized algorithms exist.

Key Results

  • Global Accuracy: Compared to ground-based ozonesondes, the S5P-BASCOE data showed a global mean deviation of only 2.6 DU (Dobson Units), indicating high reliability.
  • Bias vs. Models: A global mean positive bias of 3.3 DU was found when compared to the OMPS-MERRA-2 dataset.
  • Regional Performance: The agreement was best between 50° S and 60° N. However, larger deviations (up to 12 DU) were noted in northern polar regions (north of 70° N), likely due to the complexities of the polar tropopause and satellite albedo effects.
  • Phenomena Detection: The dataset successfully captured well-known atmospheric structures, such as the "wave one" pattern in the tropics and the seasonal summer maximums in mid-latitudes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Polar Sensitivity: The increased deviations at high latitudes suggest that the method needs further refinement for polar applications, where the distinction between the troposphere and stratosphere is less clear.
  • Boundary Layer Sensitivity: Like most UV satellite instruments, TROPOMI is less sensitive to ozone at the very bottom of the atmosphere (the boundary layer). This means very localized, ground-level pollution events might still be underestimated.
  • Cloud Interference: The current retrieval is limited to cloud-free observations (less than 20% cloud fraction). Future iterations may look to incorporate cloudy pixels to increase data density.
  • Long-term Trends: The authors plan to apply this algorithm to older satellite data (like OMI and GOME-2) to create a consistent, multi-decadal record of tropospheric ozone.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present a new tropospheric ozone dataset based on TROPOspheric Monitoring Instrument (TROPOMI)/Sentinel-5 Precursor (S5P) total ozone measurements combined with stratospheric ozone data from the Belgian Assimilation System for Chemical ObsErvations (BASCOE) constrained by assimilating ozone observations from the Microwave Limb Sounder (MLS). The BASCOE stratospheric data are interpolated to the S5P observations and subtracted from the TROPOMI total ozone data. The difference is equal to the tropospheric ozone residual column from the surface up to the tropopause. The tropospheric ozone columns are retrieved at the full spatial resolution of the TROPOMI sensor (5.5×3.5 km2) with daily global coverage. Compared to the Ozone Mapping and Profiler Suite Modern-Era Retrospective analysis for Research and Applications 2 (OMPS-MERRA-2) data, a global mean positive bias of 3.3 DU is found for the analysed period April 2018 to June 2020. A small negative bias of about −0.91 DU is observed in the tropics relative to the operational TROPOMI tropical tropospheric data based on the convective cloud differential (CCD) algorithm throughout the same period. The new tropospheric ozone data (S5P-BASCOE) are compared to a set of globally distributed ozonesonde data integrated up to the tropopause level. We found 2254 comparisons with cloud-free TROPOMI observations within 25 km of the stations. In the global mean, S5P-BASCOE deviates by 2.6 DU from the integrated ozonesondes. Depending on the latitude the S5P-BASCOE deviate from the sondes and between −4.8 and 7.9 DU, indicating a good agreement. However, some exceptional larger positive deviations up to 12 DU are found, especially in the northern polar regions (north of 70∘). The monthly mean tropospheric column and time series for selected areas showed the expected spatial and temporal pattern, such as the wave one structure in the tropics or the seasonal cycle, including a summer maximum, in the mid-latitudes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{heue2022tropospheric,
  author = {Klaus-Peter Heue and Diego Loyola and Fabian Romahn and Walter Zimmer and Simon Chabrillat and Quentin Errera and J. R. Ziemke and N. A. Kramarova},
  title = {{Tropospheric ozone retrieval by a combination of TROPOMI/S5P measurements with BASCOE assimilated data}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.5194/amt-15-5563-2022},
}
Figure