Tranquil Clouds: Neural Networks for Learning Temporally Coherent Features in Point Clouds

Lukas Prantl, Nuttapong Chentanez, Stefan Jeschke, Nils Thuerey

Abstract

Point clouds are a versatile Lagrangian representation for 3D data, yet they pose significant challenges for deep learning due to their unordered nature. When processing dynamic point clouds, standard upsampling techniques often result in temporal flickering and "halo" artifacts. We present "Tranquil Clouds," a framework that introduces temporal coherence through a Siamese training setup and a novel "mingling loss." By penalizing velocity and acceleration errors using Earth Mover’s Distance (EMD) for correspondence, our method produces spatially accurate and temporally stable upsampled point clouds.

Introduction

Point clouds consist of discrete points moving through space, making them ideal for 3D scanning, geometry processing, and physical simulations. However, their lack of inherent order makes them difficult for deep learning models to process. While static point cloud processing has advanced significantly, the temporal dimension remains largely unaddressed. Applying static upsampling networks frame-by-frame to moving point clouds typically results in two major artifacts:

  1. Flickering: High-frequency visual noise caused by points "jumping" between frames due to a lack of temporal awareness.
  2. Halo Artifacts: A form of mode collapse where the network clusters generated points directly onto input points to minimize loss, failing to reconstruct a smooth surface.

Methodology

The "Tranquil Clouds" architecture is designed to ensure temporal stability (tranquility) through three primary innovations.

Siamese Training and Temporal Loss

The framework utilizes a Siamese training setup that evaluates three consecutive time steps ($t-1, t, t+1$) simultaneously. To address the unordered nature of point clouds, the Earth Mover’s Distance (EMD) is employed to establish a mapping between generated points and ground truth. New loss terms, $L_{EV}$ and $L_{EA}$, are introduced to penalize deviations in velocity and acceleration relative to the ground truth motion.

Siamese training architecture (a) and temporal loss calculation (b).

The Mingling Loss ($L_M$)

To counteract the "halo" effect, the authors developed a "mingling loss." Unlike standard repulsion losses that merely push neighboring points apart, the mingling loss encourages a global distribution of points within a generated group, preserving the underlying geometric shape while preventing local clustering.

Variable Input Handling

To handle real-world point clouds with varying point counts, the system uses a truncation and masking approach. Smaller point sets are padded with values outside the coordinate range, and a mask ensures these "dummy" points are ignored during inference and loss calculation.

Experiments and Results

The model was trained on synthetic data from IISPH fluid simulations to ensure perfect ground-truth motion. Evaluation was performed on complex deforming meshes, including a moving spider and a walking human.

Qualitative comparison of upsampling results on a walking human model, showing the improvement from baseline (a) to the proposed method (b).

Quantitative Performance

Compared to PU-Net, a state-of-the-art static upsampling network, the proposed method achieved significant improvements in temporal metrics. Velocity error ($L_{2V}$) was reduced from 0.325 to 8.04e-04, and acceleration error ($L_{2A}$) dropped from 1.299 to 2.0e-06.

Qualitative and Efficiency Gains

Qualitatively, the method produces more even point distributions with fewer outliers. Efficiency is also improved; for a "Moving Person" sequence, the network achieved superior reconstruction using approximately 367k points, whereas fixed-output architectures required roughly 5.2 million points to achieve comparable coverage.

Conclusion

"Tranquil Clouds" demonstrates that higher-order derivatives—velocity and acceleration—are critical for achieving temporal coherence in point cloud processing. By utilizing EMD for correspondence and a targeted mingling loss, the framework effectively mitigates flickering and halo artifacts. While the current dependency on ground-truth correspondences in training presents a challenge for raw sensor data, the patch-based approach offers a scalable solution for processing large-scale dynamic simulations. Future work may extend this temporal framework to tasks such as 3D scan classification and animated mesh generation.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{prantl2020tranquil,
  author = {Lukas Prantl and Nuttapong Chentanez and Stefan Jeschke and Nils Thuerey},
  title = {{Tranquil Clouds: Neural Networks for Learning Temporally Coherent Features in Point Clouds}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Learning Representations},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=qiDlglaci1S},
}
Figure