Tranquil Clouds: Neural Networks for Learning Temporally Coherent Features in Point Clouds

Lukas Prantl, Nuttapong Chentanez, Stefan Jeschke, Nils Thuerey

Point clouds serve as a highly flexible "Lagrangian" representation of 3D data—essentially a collection of points in space without a fixed grid. While they are incredibly useful for applications like 3D scanning and physical simulations, they are notoriously difficult for deep learning because they are unordered.

Until recently, most research has focused on static point clouds. When applying those methods to moving objects—such as a walking person or splashing water—the results often suffer from "flickering," where points jump around erratically between frames. They also suffer from "halos," where points cluster unnaturally around the original input positions instead of forming a smooth, continuous surface.

"Tranquil Clouds" introduces a novel deep-learning framework specifically designed to learn temporally coherent features in dynamic point clouds. By combining a Siamese training setup with novel temporal and "mingling" loss functions, the authors successfully eliminate the flickering and halo artifacts that typically plague time-varying 3D point data.

Methodology: Siamese Training and Novel Losses

The authors propose a super-resolution (upsampling) architecture that processes point clouds in localized patches. Their approach features several key innovations designed to enforce temporal coherence:

Siamese training architecture and temporal loss setup
  • Siamese Training Setup: As shown in the architecture diagram, the network is trained by looking at sequences of three frames simultaneously ($X^{t-1}$, $X^t$, $X^{t+1}$). This allows the model to observe motion and learn how points should transition over time.
  • EMD-based Temporal Loss ($L_{EV}$ and $L_{EA}$): Instead of a simple distance check, the framework uses the Earth Mover’s Distance (EMD) to calculate velocity and acceleration. This ensures the generated points mimic the motion of the ground truth data in a permutation-invariant way.
  • Mingling Loss ($L_M$): To prevent "mode collapse"—where the network takes the easy path and simply sticks points to the input locations, creating halos—the authors introduced a mingling loss. This encourages points to distribute themselves globally across the target shape, forcing the network to actually reconstruct the underlying surface.
  • Variable Size Handling: Most neural networks require fixed input sizes. The authors developed a truncation and masking approach that allows the network to handle patches with different numbers of points, making it much more flexible for real-world, variable-density data.

Datasets and Key Results

The researchers used a variety of data sources to prove their method's versatility, including synthetic fluid simulations (using an IISPH fluid simulator) and animated meshes of a moving spider and a walking human.

Visual comparison of point cloud upsampling on a walking human model

When evaluating the model, several key insights and improvements emerged:

  • Visual Quality: Compared to previous state-of-the-art methods like PU-Net, "Tranquil Clouds" produced much smoother animations with far fewer outliers and more even point distributions. The upsampled models maintain surface integrity without the erratic jumping seen in baseline approaches.
  • Quantitative Gains: In 3D tests, the method reduced the spatial error ($L_S$) from approximately 0.09 to 0.03. More impressively, it slashed the temporal velocity error ($L_{EV}$) by nearly two orders of magnitude compared to previous work.
  • Acceleration Matters: The authors found that merely matching velocity isn't enough to stop flickering. By including a loss term for acceleration ($L_{EA}$), they significantly reduced high-frequency jitter in the output.
  • Latent Space Stability: By analyzing the network's latent space, the researchers proved that their temporal loss helps the network learn more stable, meaningful features that don't fluctuate wildly from frame to frame.
  • Efficiency: Because the network can adapt its output size, it avoids generating redundant points in sparse areas, leading to more efficient representations of complex deforming objects.

Limitations and Future Work

While the results represent a significant step forward for dynamic point cloud processing, the authors note a few areas for future exploration. The current method relies on decomposing volumes into patches; while this helps scaling to millions of points, it might miss very large-scale global structures.

Furthermore, the authors suggest their temporal loss could be integrated into other architectures, such as those that generate point clouds directly from images. Future work could also extend this "temporal awareness" to other tasks beyond super-resolution, such as classifying 3D scans over time or generating fully animated meshes from raw point data.

Summary updated

Abstract

Point clouds, as a form of Lagrangian representation, allow for powerful and flexible applications in a large number of computational disciplines. We propose a novel deep-learning method to learn stable and temporally coherent feature spaces for points clouds that change over time. We identify a set of inherent problems with these approaches: without knowledge of the time dimension, the inferred solutions can exhibit strong flickering, and easy solutions to suppress this flickering can result in undesirable local minima that manifest themselves as halo structures. We propose a novel temporal loss function that takes into account higher time derivatives of the point positions, and encourages mingling, i.e., to prevent the aforementioned halos. We combine these techniques in a super-resolution method with a truncation approach to flexibly adapt the size of the generated positions. We show that our method works for large, deforming point sets from different sources to demonstrate the flexibility of our approach.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{prantl2020tranquil,
  author = {Lukas Prantl and Nuttapong Chentanez and Stefan Jeschke and Nils Thuerey},
  title = {{Tranquil Clouds: Neural Networks for Learning Temporally Coherent Features in Point Clouds}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Learning Representations},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=qiDlglaci1S},
}
Figure