Trajectory Inference via Mean-field Langevin in Path Space

Lénaïc Chizat, Stephen Zhang, Matthieu Heitz, Geoffrey Schiebinger

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, grid-free algorithm called Mean-Field Langevin (MFL) dynamics for inferring the underlying continuous-time dynamics of a population from discrete snapshots. This method offers end-to-end theoretical guarantees and outperforms existing approaches, particularly in low-data regimes, making it a powerful tool for analyzing complex biological systems like single-cell RNA sequencing data.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the dynamic behavior of populations, especially in biological contexts like cell development or disease progression, is crucial. Single-cell RNA sequencing provides snapshots of cell states at different time points, but inferring the continuous trajectories and underlying stochastic processes from these discrete, often sparse, observations is a significant challenge. Existing methods often rely on discretizing the problem space, which can be computationally expensive and may struggle with limited data. This paper tackles the problem of trajectory inference by developing a theoretically grounded, efficient, and robust method that directly models the continuous-time dynamics.

Methods

The core of this work is the development of Mean-Field Langevin (MFL) dynamics for trajectory inference. This approach builds upon a min-entropy estimator proposed in prior work, which seeks a probability distribution over paths that is consistent with observed temporal marginals while minimizing its divergence from a reference Brownian motion.

The key innovation is a grid-free algorithm that reformulates the problem into a reduced optimization problem over the space of marginal distributions at each time point. This reduced problem is then solved using MFL dynamics, a class of stochastic differential equations inspired by mean-field theory. MFL dynamics are designed to minimize objectives of the form $G(\mu) + \tau H(\mu)$, where $G$ is a function related to data fitting and $H$ is the differential entropy. The method leverages Schrödinger bridges to couple the marginals and employs a noisy gradient descent approach.

The paper also introduces an extension to handle branching processes (cell birth and death) by modifying the Schrödinger bridge problem to incorporate growth rates and relax marginal constraints, making it more applicable to real biological data.

Datasets

The paper uses simulated data for evaluation. Specifically:

  • Section 4.1: Simulated data from a bifurcating stochastic differential equation.
  • Section 4.2: A modified version of a bistable process from a previous study.
  • Section 4.3: A real-world dataset from single-cell RNA sequencing of iPSC reprogramming, subsampled to simulate low-data regimes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Grid-free inference is feasible and effective: The MFL dynamics approach avoids the need for discretizing the path space, offering a more direct and potentially more accurate way to model continuous dynamics.
  • Mean-field approximation unlocks theoretical guarantees: By leveraging the mean-field limit, the authors achieve global convergence guarantees for their optimization algorithm, a significant theoretical advancement in this field.
  • Schrödinger bridges are key to coupling marginals: The use of Schrödinger bridges provides a principled way to connect the observed snapshots and infer the underlying continuous paths.
  • Branching processes can be incorporated: The extension to handle cell birth and death is crucial for applying trajectory inference to realistic biological scenarios where populations are not static.
  • Robustness to low-data regimes: The MFL approach demonstrates remarkable robustness when only a few samples are available at intermediate time points, a common scenario in biological experiments.

Key Results

  • Theoretical Guarantees: The paper provides end-to-end theoretical guarantees for the convergence of the MFL dynamics to the min-entropy estimator.
  • Performance Comparison: In simulations and on a real dataset, MFL dynamics consistently outperform Global Waddington-OT (gWOT), especially in low-sample regimes. For instance, Figure 1 shows MFL performing comparably to gWOT with uniform sampling but significantly better with only one sample per intermediate time point.
  • Branching Dynamics: Figure 3 demonstrates that accounting for branching rates allows for better separation of spatial dynamics from growth, leading to more accurate reconstructions of population trajectories.
  • Real-world Data Application: Figure 4 shows that MFL dynamics improve upon subsampled snapshots from a stem cell reprogramming dataset, outperforming gWOT.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Statistical Efficiency in High Dimensions: The authors acknowledge that the min-entropy estimator, and thus their method, may suffer from limited statistical efficiency in high-dimensional settings due to the lack of explicit structural priors on the Waddington potential.
  • Learning the Waddington Potential: Future work could focus on quantifying the statistical performance and adapting the algorithm to learn the Waddington potential within a structured parameterized class of functions.
  • Interpreting Dynamics as Path Space Diffusion: A theoretical question remains about rigorously interpreting the MFL dynamics as a diffusion process in path space.
  • Extension to Non-Compact Domains: The current convergence results for MFL dynamics are proven for the d-torus. Extending these to non-compact domains would require addressing more profound theoretical challenges.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{chizat2022trajectory,
  author = {Lénaïc Chizat and Stephen Zhang and Matthieu Heitz and Geoffrey Schiebinger},
  title = {{Trajectory Inference via Mean-field Langevin in Path Space}},
  booktitle = {Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=Mftcm8i4sL},
}
Figure