Abstract
Adherent cells exert traction forces on to their environment, which allows them to migrate, to maintain tissue integrity, and to form complex multicellular structures. This traction can be measured in a perturbation-free manner with traction force microscopy (TFM). In TFM, traction is usually calculated via the solution of a linear system, which is complicated by undersampled input data, acquisition noise, and large condition numbers for some methods. Therefore, standard TFM algorithms either employ data filtering or regularization. However, these approaches require a manual selection of filter- or regularization parameters and consequently exhibit a substantial degree of subjectiveness. This shortcoming is particularly serious when cells in different conditions are to be compared because optimal noise suppression needs to be adapted for every situation, which invariably results in systematic errors. Here, we systematically test the performance of new methods from computer vision and Bayesian inference for solving the inverse problem in TFM. We compare two classical schemes, L1- and L2-regularization, with three previously untested schemes, namely Elastic Net regularization, Proximal Gradient Lasso, and Proximal Gradient Elastic Net. Overall, we find that Elastic Net regularization, which combines L1 and L2 regularization, outperforms all other methods with regard to accuracy of traction reconstruction. Next, we develop two methods, Bayesian L2 regularization and Advanced Bayesian L2 regularization, for automatic, optimal L2 regularization. Using artificial data and experimental data, we show that these methods enable robust reconstruction of traction without requiring a difficult selection of regularization parameters specifically for each data set. Thus, Bayesian methods can mitigate the considerable uncertainty inherent in comparing cellular traction forces.
Introduction: The Subjectivity Gap in TFM
Cells function as mechanical engines, exerting forces on their environment to facilitate movement, division, and tissue maintenance. Traction Force Microscopy (TFM) is the primary tool for measuring these forces, typically by placing cells on a soft, elastic gel embedded with fluorescent beads. By tracking bead displacement, researchers can mathematically reconstruct the traction field.
However, this reconstruction is a notoriously "ill-conditioned" inverse problem. Minor experimental noise in bead tracking can lead to disproportionately large errors in force calculation. To mitigate this, researchers use regularization, which penalizes unphysical solutions using a tuning parameter ($\lambda$). Traditionally, $\lambda$ is selected manually or via heuristics like the "L-curve" method. This introduces significant subjectivity; different researchers may tune the same data differently, making it nearly impossible to objectively compare cellular forces across different experimental conditions or time-series data.
Methods and Datasets
The authors systematically evaluated several reconstruction strategies categorized into two main groups:
- Advanced Regularization Schemes: Classical L1 (Lasso) and L2 (Ridge) methods were compared against three computer vision techniques: Elastic Net (EN) (a hybrid of L1 and L2), and wavelet-based approaches Proximal Gradient Lasso (PGL) and Proximal Gradient Elastic Net (PGEN).
- Bayesian Inference Models: Two automated methods were developed: Bayesian L2 (BL2), which treats the regularization parameter as a random variable, and Advanced Bayesian L2 (ABL2), which infers both the optimal regularization and the noise level directly from the data.
These methods were tested using both artificial test data (simulated force spots with Gaussian noise) and biological data, including primary murine podocytes and rat embryonic heart muscle cells (cardiomyocytes) to evaluate performance in static and time-series contexts.
Key Insights: Accuracy vs. Automation
- The "Fishing Net" Advantage: Elastic Net (EN) emerged as the most accurate method for static images. By combining L1 and L2 penalties, it effectively filters background noise while retaining significant force signals, acting much like a stretchable fishing net.
- Simplicity in Bayesian TFM: While complex hierarchical Bayesian models are popular in machine learning, the authors found they often overfit noise in TFM. The simpler global prior used in BL2 and ABL2 proved significantly more robust.
- Dynamic Adaptation: In time-series data, such as beating heart cells, signal-to-noise ratios fluctuate rapidly. The Bayesian approach (BL2) automatically adapts the regularization parameter for every frame, ensuring faithful reconstruction throughout the entire contraction cycle without manual intervention.
Results and Computational Trade-offs
The study demonstrated that while Elastic Net (EN) provides the highest reconstruction accuracy, it comes with a significant computational cost. As shown in the performance comparison below, EN requires substantially more time and memory than standard L2 methods.
Key findings include:
- Accuracy: EN outperformed all other methods, particularly in undersampled data regimes.
- Automation: BL2 and ABL2 produced results comparable to the "best possible" manually tuned L2 regularization, effectively removing human subjectivity.
- Robustness: Bayesian methods remained reliable even when noise levels were high, a scenario where traditional L-curve selection typically fails.
Discussion and Future Work
The primary limitation of the most advanced methods is their computational demand. While L2 regularization takes seconds, the superior EN method can take nearly an hour for the same dataset. This may present a bottleneck for high-throughput screening. Future research will likely focus on applying these Bayesian frameworks to 3D traction force microscopy and complex substrate geometries, where the subjectivity of manual tuning is even more problematic.
Summary updated