Tracking Berry curvature effect in molecular dynamics by ultrafast magnetic x-ray scattering

Ming Zhang, Xiaoyu Mi, Linfeng Zhang, Chengyin Wu, Zheng LiarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The spin-dependent Berry force is a genuine effect of Berry curvature in molecular dynamics, which can dramatically result in spatial spin separation and change of reaction pathways. However, the way to probe the effect of Berry force remains challenging, because the time-reversal (TR) symmetry required for opposite Berry forces conflicts with TR symmetry breaking spin alignment needed to observe the effect, and the net effect could be transient for a molecular wave packet. We demonstrate that in molecular photodissociation, the dissociation rates can be different for molecules with opposite initial spin directions due to Berry force. We showcase that the spatially separated spin density, which is transiently induced by Berry force as the molecular wave packet passes through conical intersection, can be reconstructed from the circular dichroism (CD) of ultrafast non-resonant magnetic x-ray scattering using free electron lasers.

Introduction

In the quantum mechanical description of molecular systems, the Berry curvature of an electronic wavefunction acts as an effective magnetic field in momentum space. This curvature gives rise to the "Berry force," a spin-dependent phenomenon that can significantly influence nuclear motion. While well-documented in solid-state physics—underpinning effects like the anomalous Hall effect—observing the Berry force in molecular dynamics has remained an elusive goal for chemical physicists.

The difficulty in detecting this force stems from three primary factors. First, observing the effect requires aligning molecular spins, typically via an external magnetic field. However, a field strong enough to align spins often breaks the time-reversal symmetry necessary for the Berry forces of "up" and "down" spins to be equal and opposite. Second, the force is highly transient, appearing only near conical intersections—the "funnels" where electronic energy levels meet and molecules transition in femtoseconds. Finally, the magnetic signal from electron spins is typically overwhelmed by the much stronger signal from electron charge scattering.

Methodology

To address these challenges, researchers developed a theoretical framework and experimental proposal centered on the photodissociation of the hydroxymethyl radical ($CH_2OH$). The study utilized ab initio calculations via the Restricted Active Space Self-Consistent Field (RASSCF) method to map potential energy surfaces and Berry curvatures.

The molecular dynamics were simulated using a modified "fewest-switches surface hopping" (FSSH) algorithm that explicitly incorporates the Berry force. To isolate the subtle magnetic signal, the team proposed using ultrafast non-resonant magnetic x-ray scattering (MXS) at free-electron lasers (XFELs). By measuring the Circular Dichroism (CD)—the difference in scattering between left- and right-handed circularly polarized x-rays—the dominant charge scattering background is mathematically canceled, leaving the spin-dependent information accessible.

Schematic of the experimental setup for detecting Berry force-induced spin separation using ultrafast magnetic x-ray scattering.

Results and Discussion

The "Goldilocks" Magnetic Field

A critical finding of the study is the identification of an optimal magnetic field strength. At approximately 0.1 Tesla, the field is sufficient to align molecular spins while remaining weak enough that the Berry forces for opposite spins remain nearly perfectly opposite (within 0.01%). This balance allows for observable spatial spin separation without destroying the underlying topological symmetry.

Spin-Dependent Reaction Pathways

The simulations revealed that the Berry force acts as a physical "nudge" during dissociation. In the case of $CH_2OH$, spin-down trajectories were found to dissociate faster than spin-up ones. This occurs because the Berry force preferentially pushes the spin-down wave packet along the reaction coordinate as it traverses the conical intersection, effectively altering the branching ratios of the chemical reaction based on quantum spin.

Signal Reconstruction

The researchers demonstrated that the MXS CD signal provides more than just a qualitative indicator of the Berry force. They developed an analytical model to reconstruct the spatial separation of spins from the diffraction patterns. As shown in the comparison between simulated data and molecular dynamics ground truth, the temporal evolution of the spin-dependent probability density ($\Delta P$) can be recovered with high fidelity.

Comparison of the simulated magnetic x-ray scattering signal and the reconstructed spin-dependent probability density against the molecular dynamics ground truth.

Conclusion

This work provides a theoretical and computational roadmap for observing topological forces in real-time chemical dynamics. By leveraging the high flux and ultrafast pulses of modern XFELs, it is possible to detect the fleeting spatial separation of spins induced by the Berry force. While technically demanding—requiring sub-100 femtosecond resolution and careful management of rotational averaging—this approach opens a new window into how quantum topology shapes the fundamental pathways of chemical reactions. Future research will explore these effects in more complex catalytic and biological systems where conical intersections play a pivotal role.

Summary updated

Abstract

The spin-dependent Berry force is a genuine effect of Berry curvature in molecular dynamics, which can dramatically result in spatial spin separation and change of reaction pathways. However, the way to probe the effect of Berry force remains challenging, because the time-reversal (TR) symmetry required for opposite Berry forces conflicts with TR symmetry breaking spin alignment needed to observe the effect, and the net effect could be transient for a molecular wave packet. We demonstrate that in molecular photodissociation, the dissociation rates can be different for molecules with opposite initial spin directions due to Berry force. We showcase that the spatially separated spin density, which is transiently induced by Berry force as the molecular wave packet passes through conical intersection, can be reconstructed from the circular dichroism (CD) of ultrafast non-resonant magnetic x-ray scattering using free electron lasers.
BibTeX
@misc{zhang2023tracking,
  author = {Ming Zhang and Xiaoyu Mi and Linfeng Zhang and Chengyin Wu and Zheng Li},
  title = {{Tracking Berry curvature effect in molecular dynamics by ultrafast magnetic x-ray scattering}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2307.06523},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2307.06523},
}
Figure