H2 formation via non-Born-Oppenheimer hydrogen migration in photoionized ethane

Yizhang Yang, Hao Ren, Ming Zhang, Shengpeng Zhou, Xiangxu Mu, Xiaokai Li, Zhenzhen Wang, Ke Deng, Mingxuan Li, Pan Ma, Zheng Li, Xiaolei Hao, Weidong Li, Jing Chen, Chuncheng Wang, Dajun DingNature Communications 2023 · DOI

Abstract: Neutral H<sub>2</sub> formation via intramolecular hydrogen migration in hydrocarbon molecules plays a vital role in many chemical and biological processes. Here, employing cold target recoil ion momentum spectroscopy (COLTRIMS) and pump-probe technique, we find that the non-adiabatic coupling between the ground and excited ionic states of ethane through conical intersection leads to a significantly high yield of neutral H<sub>2</sub> fragment. Based on the analysis of fingerprints that are sensitive to orbital symmetry and electronic state energies in the photoelectron momentum distributions, we tag the initial electronic population of both the ground and excited ionic states and determine the branching ratios of H<sub>2</sub> formation channel from those two states. Incorporating theoretical simulation, we established the timescale of the H<sub>2</sub> formation to be ~1300 fs. We provide a comprehensive characterization of H<sub>2</sub> formation in ionic states of ethane mediated by conical intersection and reveals the significance of non-adiabatic coupling dynamics in the intramolecular hydrogen migration.

Introduction

In molecular chemistry, hydrogen migration—the internal movement of hydrogen atoms within a molecule—is a fundamental process driving the formation of new products. This "dance" is critical in diverse fields, from interstellar chemistry to biological radiation damage. Traditionally, these dynamics are described using the Born-Oppenheimer approximation, which assumes that electrons adjust instantaneously to the motion of nuclei, allowing the nuclei to move on a single, static potential energy surface.

However, as the lightest atom, hydrogen often moves fast enough to break this approximation. When electronic states approach each other in energy, they can "couple," allowing the molecule to jump between states at a conical intersection (CI). Capturing these non-adiabatic effects during the formation of neutral $H_2$ from hydrocarbons like ethane ($C_2H_6$) is challenging due to the ultrafast nature of the process and the difficulty of detecting neutral fragments directly.

Non-Adiabatic Dynamics and the Conical Intersection

The study identifies a non-adiabatic "shortcut" for $H_2$ formation. While the ground ionic state ($^2E_g$) does not inherently favor $H_2$ loss, the molecule can transition to a dissociative excited state by "hopping" through a conical intersection.

Mechanism of H2 formation in ethane: (a) potential energy curves showing wavepacket motion, (b) energy level diagram of the ionization process, and (c) 3D potential energy surface of the conical intersection.

This non-adiabatic coupling is a major contributor to the high yield of $H_2$. The researchers found that over 60% of the population in the ground state and over 70% in the excited state eventually relax into the $H_2$ formation channel. The 3D potential energy surface illustrates the complex landscape the molecule must navigate to reach the CI.

Methods: Tracking Ultrafast Snapshots

To track this reaction, researchers combined coincidence spectroscopy with femtosecond laser pulses. The primary experimental tool was COLTRIMS (Cold Target Recoil Ion Momentum Spectroscopy), which measures the 3D momentum of electrons and ions simultaneously.

Calculated photoelectron momentum distribution (PMD) for the 2A1g state, illustrating the 'jet-like' pattern used for state tagging.

A key innovation in this study is the use of electronic state tagging. By analyzing the "fingerprints" in the photoelectron momentum distributions (PMDs), the team could determine the initial electronic state of the ionized ethane. Electrons from the ground ionic state ($^2E_g$) exhibit a "fanning-out" pattern, whereas those from the excited state ($^2A_{1g}$) produce a distinct "jet-like" structure. This allowed for the precise determination of branching ratios from specific initial populations.

The temporal evolution was mapped using a pump-probe technique, where a 40-fs "pump" pulse initiated ionization and a subsequent "probe" pulse captured snapshots of the $H_2$ formation progress. These experimental results were supported by Non-adiabatic Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations and Coulomb-corrected strong-field approximation (CCSFA) modeling.

Results: The 1.3 Picosecond Journey

Contrary to many hydrogen migrations in small ions that occur in under 200 fs, the formation of $H_2$ in ethane was found to be a relatively "slow" ultrafast process, taking approximately 1300 fs. This extended duration suggests that the molecule must undergo significant, large-amplitude structural deformations to reach the specific geometry required for the conical intersection.

Pump-probe data showed a clear rise in $H_2$ production starting around 700 fs and peaking near 1234 fs. Furthermore, Fourier analysis of the time-delayed ion yields revealed vibrational frequencies (100–200 $cm^{-1}$) corresponding to the calculated "branching space" of the conical intersection, providing further evidence of the non-Born-Oppenheimer journey.

Conclusion and Outlook

This work provides a comprehensive characterization of $H_2$ formation in ethane mediated by non-adiabatic coupling. The discovery of a long-lived intermediate state opens possibilities for active reaction control. By using shaped laser pulses, it may be possible to "steer" molecules through or away from conical intersections, effectively dictating the chemical outcome. Future research using extreme ultraviolet (XUV) pulses could further refine our understanding of these dynamics in larger, more complex hydrocarbons.

Summary updated

Abstract

Neutral H<sub>2</sub> formation via intramolecular hydrogen migration in hydrocarbon molecules plays a vital role in many chemical and biological processes. Here, employing cold target recoil ion momentum spectroscopy (COLTRIMS) and pump-probe technique, we find that the non-adiabatic coupling between the ground and excited ionic states of ethane through conical intersection leads to a significantly high yield of neutral H<sub>2</sub> fragment. Based on the analysis of fingerprints that are sensitive to orbital symmetry and electronic state energies in the photoelectron momentum distributions, we tag the initial electronic population of both the ground and excited ionic states and determine the branching ratios of H<sub>2</sub> formation channel from those two states. Incorporating theoretical simulation, we established the timescale of the H<sub>2</sub> formation to be ~1300 fs. We provide a comprehensive characterization of H<sub>2</sub> formation in ionic states of ethane mediated by conical intersection and reveals the significance of non-adiabatic coupling dynamics in the intramolecular hydrogen migration.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2023h,
  author = {Yizhang Yang and Hao Ren and Ming Zhang and Shengpeng Zhou and Xiangxu Mu and Xiaokai Li and Zhenzhen Wang and Ke Deng and Mingxuan Li and Pan Ma and Zheng Li and Xiaolei Hao and Weidong Li and Jing Chen and Chuncheng Wang and Dajun Ding},
  title = {{H2 formation via non-Born-Oppenheimer hydrogen migration in photoionized ethane}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-023-40628-9},
}
Figure