Emulation of complex open quantum systems using superconducting qubits

Sarah Mostame, Joonsuk Huh, Christoph Kreisbeck, Andrew J. Kerman, Takatoshi Fujita, Alexander Eisfeld, Alán Aspuru-Guzik

Introduction

Simulating "open" quantum systems—those that interact with their environment—is a monumental challenge for classical computing. This paper proposes a novel solution: using analog quantum simulators, specifically superconducting flux qubits coupled to LC oscillators, to model these complex dynamics. By mapping molecular vibrations directly onto superconducting circuits, researchers can potentially outperform state-of-the-art supercomputers in simulating large-scale quantum phenomena, such as photosynthetic light-harvesting.

The Classical Complexity Wall

In nature, quantum systems are rarely isolated. They interact with a "bath" of environmental vibrations, known as phonons. As the number of molecules (system size) or the number of vibrational modes (environmental complexity) increases, the computational resources required for classical simulation grow exponentially.

Current classical methods, such as the Hierarchical Equations of Motion (HEOM), face a sharp trade-off. As shown in Figure 1, one can simulate a large system with a simple environment or a small system with a complex one, but not both simultaneously. Real-world biological systems, like the chlorosome antenna in green sulfur bacteria, involve hundreds of molecules and thousands of vibrational modes, placing them well beyond the reach of classical hardware.

Figure 1: The complexity wall for classical simulation of open quantum systems.

Proposed Analog Simulator Architecture

To overcome these limitations, the authors propose an analog quantum simulator based on the Holstein model, which describes electron-phonon interactions. Unlike digital quantum computers that rely on gates, this analog simulator is "hardwired" to mimic the target system's physics.

The architecture involves a chain of gradiometric flux qubits, where each qubit represents an electronic state (e.g., an exciton on a molecule). Each qubit is coupled to a quantum LC oscillator representing a specific vibrational mode. The setup utilizes tunable $\sigma_z\sigma_z$ couplings between qubits and independent couplings to resonators.

Figure 2: Proposed analog quantum simulator architecture using flux qubits and LC oscillators.

Overcoming Engineering Hurdles

A significant challenge in this design is the physical footprint: fitting hundreds of resonators around a single micron-sized qubit is impractical. The authors address this through a linear-algebraic bath transformation, converting a "star" configuration (many resonators on one qubit) into a "chain" configuration. This allows a complex environment to be represented by a few resonators coupled to the qubit, which are then coupled to each other in parallel chains.

Key Insights and Results

The research demonstrates several critical advantages of this approach:

  • Scaling Advantage: While classical methods require massive memory (e.g., 250 GB for a 20-site system), the analog simulator scales linearly with the number of sites, potentially enabling simulations of thousands of sites.
  • Temperature Rescaling: Although superconducting circuits operate at millikelvin temperatures, the authors show that by rescaling coupling strengths and frequencies, they can accurately emulate the 300K dynamics of biological systems.
  • Feasibility: Using parameters from the chlorosome antenna (which has 253 distinct phonon modes), the authors calculated hardware specifications—such as resonator frequencies around 1.4–1.6 GHz—that are achievable with modern fabrication technology.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

While building a device with hundreds of precisely tuned resonators remains a significant engineering challenge, this work provides a rigorous mathematical and design framework for a new class of simulators. Future efforts will focus on maintaining high quality factors in the oscillators and extending the architecture from 1D chains to 2D and 3D lattices to better represent complex molecular geometries. By specializing in specific physical models, analog simulators offer a viable path to exploring quantum regimes that are fundamentally unreachable by classical means.

Summary updated

Abstract

With quantum computers being out of reach for now, quantum simulators are the alternative devices for efficient and more exact simulation of problems that are challenging on conventional computers. Quantum simulators are classified into analog and digital, with the possibility of constructing "hybrid" simulators by combining both techniques. In this paper, we focus on analog quantum simulators of open quantum systems and address the limit that they can beat classical computers. In particular, as an example, we discuss simulation of the chlorosome light-harvesting antenna from green sulfur bacteria with over 250 phonon modes coupled to each electronic state. Furthermore, we propose physical setups that can be used to reproduce the quantum dynamics of a standard and multiple-mode Holstein model. The proposed scheme is based on currently available technology of superconducting circuits consist of flux qubits and quantum oscillators.
BibTeX
@article{mostame2016emulation,
  author = {Sarah Mostame and Joonsuk Huh and Christoph Kreisbeck and Andrew J. Kerman and Takatoshi Fujita and Alexander Eisfeld and Alán Aspuru-Guzik},
  title = {{Emulation of complex open quantum systems using superconducting qubits}},
  journal = {Quantum Inf. Process},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1007/s11128-016-1489-3},
}
Figure