Time for change? Feasibility of introducing micromodules into medical student education: a randomised controlled trial

Chi‐Fai Ng, Kevin Lim, Ch Yee, Peter Kf Chiu, Jeremy Yuen‐Chun Teoh, Franco Pt LaiHong 2023 · DOI

Abstract

In terms of acquiring, retaining, and applying foundational urological knowledge, online micromodules can help medical students to achieve outcomes comparable with the outcomes of didactic lectures. Online micromodules may be a viable alternative to traditional didactic lectures in urology education.

Introduction

Traditional medical education has long relied on 45-to-60-minute didactic lectures. However, pedagogical research indicates that student attention spans typically wane after the first 15 minutes, leading to diminished information acquisition. While the COVID-19 pandemic accelerated the adoption of online learning, simply digitizing long-form lectures often fails to address engagement issues. This study investigates the feasibility of "micromodules"—short, targeted video lessons—as a more efficient alternative for teaching urology to medical students.

Methods

This single-centre, single-blind randomized controlled trial (RCT) enrolled 45 medical students (Years 4–6) with no prior urology exposure. Participants were randomized into two groups:

  1. Traditional Didactic Group (n=22): Watched a pre-recorded 45-minute lecture.
  2. Online Micromodule Group (n=23): Watched two 10-minute videos covering identical content (Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms and haematuria).

The study utilized the Kirkpatrick four-level training evaluation model to assess reaction, learning (via MCQs), and behavior (via OSCEs).

Study design flowchart illustrating the randomization and assessment phases.

Results

The trial demonstrated that micromodules are non-inferior to traditional lectures across all primary performance metrics. Notably, the micromodule group achieved comparable outcomes with less than half the instructional time (20 minutes vs. 45 minutes).

Comparison of assessment scores between didactic lecture and online micromodule groups.

Key findings include:

  • Clinical Skill (OSCE): No significant difference was found in history-taking performance on real patients (P=0.823).
  • Knowledge Acquisition: Post-intervention MCQ scores were statistically similar between the didactic (57.32 ± 3.63) and micromodule (55.91 ± 6.52) groups (P=0.375).
  • Retention: Knowledge decay measured three weeks post-intervention showed no significant difference between groups (P=0.101).

Discussion

The results suggest that information density and delivery method are more critical than session duration. Micromodules not only facilitate efficient knowledge transfer but also successfully translate to bedside clinical skills. This format serves as a vital prerequisite for the "flipped classroom" model, allowing asynchronous digital modules to handle foundational knowledge while reserving face-to-face time for interactive, high-value clinical training.

Limitations and Future Directions

While promising, this pilot study is limited by its small sample size (n=45) and focus on only two urological topics. Future research should explore larger cohorts and the potential for micromodules to teach procedural skills, such as catheterization, through high-quality video demonstrations.

Summary updated

Abstract

In terms of acquiring, retaining, and applying foundational urological knowledge, online micromodules can help medical students to achieve outcomes comparable with the outcomes of didactic lectures. Online micromodules may be a viable alternative to traditional didactic lectures in urology education.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ng2023time,
  author = {Chi‐Fai Ng and Kevin Lim and CH Yee and Peter KF Chiu and Jeremy Yuen‐Chun Teoh and Franco PT Lai},
  title = {{Time for change? Feasibility of introducing micromodules into medical student education: a randomised controlled trial}},
  booktitle = {Hong},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.12809/hkmj219267},
}
Figure