The application of flipped classroom to teaching diabetic retinopathy and glaucoma in ophthalmology undergraduate education: a randomized study

Chan Wu, Yutong Liu, Mingyue Luo, Rongping Dai, Gangwei Cheng, Yang Zhang, Xuan Zou, Lue Li, Jun Zhao, Youxin Chen, Yong Zhong, Meifen ZhangScientific 2024 · DOI

Abstract

The efficacy of flipped classroom in ophthalmology education has not been well proved. This study aimed to investigate the efficacy of flipped classroom on diabetic retinopathy (DR) and glaucoma in ophthalmology education. Ninety-three medical students in Peking Union Medical College participated and were randomly assigned into two groups. Students in "Group A" participated in a flipped classroom on diabetic retinopathy (DR) and a regular course on glaucoma, while students in "Group B" had a flipped classroom on glaucoma and a regular one on DR. The primary outcome measure of this study was the exam score after class. The secondary outcome measure was the result of a post-classroom questionnaire. The final exam revealed numerically better scores for questions in the same section as flipped classroom that students joined with no statistical significance. The post-class questionnaire revealed an overall satisfaction rate of 93.48%. Most students thought the flipped classroom enhance personal abilities compared with the traditional lecture-based class. However, further amendments should also be made to improve defects such as students' comprehension of basic knowledge and the overall degree of involvement of students. The concept of the flipped classroom could be applied to diabetic retinopathy and glaucoma with satisfactory results.

Introduction

As the global population ages, the demand for well-trained eye care professionals is rising. Paradoxically, medical schools are compressing ophthalmology class hours and marginalizing the curriculum. Traditional lecture-based teaching often results in passive learning and low student engagement, making it difficult to maximize these limited class hours.

Active learning strategies, specifically the "flipped classroom"—where students learn foundational concepts via video before class and spend in-class time on collaborative problem-solving—theoretically solve this engagement issue. However, the efficacy of this model hasn't been rigorously proven for highly specific and visual ophthalmology topics like diabetic retinopathy (DR) and glaucoma. The authors set out to determine if flipping the classroom actually yields better academic performance and student satisfaction compared to standard lectures.

Methods

The researchers conducted a randomized controlled trial involving 93 sixth-year medical students at Peking Union Medical College. They used a cross-over design to ensure all students experienced both teaching styles:

  • Group A participated in a flipped classroom for Diabetic Retinopathy (DR) and a traditional lecture for Glaucoma.
  • Group B participated in a flipped classroom for Glaucoma and a traditional lecture for DR.
Figure 1: Flowchart of the teaching plan, detailing the preparation, 60-minute lesson, and feedback stages for both flipped and traditional classroom groups.

One week before class, students were given a learning video, a real clinical case, and a list of targeted questions. Students were required to prepare an 8-minute presentation in small groups. The 60-minute in-class time was entirely dedicated to student presentations and teacher-guided discussion. The primary outcome was measured via a standardized final exam taken two months later, and the secondary outcome was measured using a modified Course Experience Questionnaire (CEQ).

Key Results

Quantitative Outcomes

Students scored numerically higher on the specific topics they learned via the flipped classroom, though the results were not statistically significant:

  • DR scores: Group A (Flipped) 84.96 vs. Group B (Standard) 82.12 (p=0.199).
  • Glaucoma scores: Group B (Flipped) 91.63 vs. Group A (Standard) 89.20 (p=0.257).

Qualitative Feedback and Skill Acquisition

The flipped model was highly received by students. 93.48% of participants reported overall satisfaction, and 88.04% explicitly preferred the flipped classroom over traditional lectures.

Figure 2: Results of the post-class questionnaire for Group A (top) and Group B (bottom), highlighting high levels of student satisfaction and perceived skill development across multiple domains.

A vast majority of students agreed that the flipped classroom improved their personal abilities, including problem-solving, written communication, and collaboration. Interestingly, students handled the more abstract, theoretical topic (glaucoma) better in the flipped format than the highly visual topic (DR), where they struggled to independently describe retinal images and explain examination results.

Discussion and Limitations

The study highlights a shift in focus between student-led and teacher-led sessions: students emphasized basic science (e.g., molecular pathways), while teachers focused on clinical applications (anatomy and diagnosis). However, the flipped model also increased student workload, with over 20% reporting difficulties in preparation or fully understanding the pre-class contents.

Limitations include the small, homogeneous sample size from a highly selective program and the potential lack of sensitivity in the final exam. The timing of the test (two months post-class) may also have been too early to capture long-term retention benefits typically associated with active learning.

Conclusion

The flipped classroom model can be successfully applied to complex ophthalmology topics like diabetic retinopathy and glaucoma. While immediate academic gains were modest, the significant boost in student engagement and perceived skill acquisition suggests it is a valuable addition to undergraduate medical education.

Summary updated

Abstract

The efficacy of flipped classroom in ophthalmology education has not been well proved. This study aimed to investigate the efficacy of flipped classroom on diabetic retinopathy (DR) and glaucoma in ophthalmology education. Ninety-three medical students in Peking Union Medical College participated and were randomly assigned into two groups. Students in "Group A" participated in a flipped classroom on diabetic retinopathy (DR) and a regular course on glaucoma, while students in "Group B" had a flipped classroom on glaucoma and a regular one on DR. The primary outcome measure of this study was the exam score after class. The secondary outcome measure was the result of a post-classroom questionnaire. The final exam revealed numerically better scores for questions in the same section as flipped classroom that students joined with no statistical significance. The post-class questionnaire revealed an overall satisfaction rate of 93.48%. Most students thought the flipped classroom enhance personal abilities compared with the traditional lecture-based class. However, further amendments should also be made to improve defects such as students' comprehension of basic knowledge and the overall degree of involvement of students. The concept of the flipped classroom could be applied to diabetic retinopathy and glaucoma with satisfactory results.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2024application,
  author = {Chan Wu and Yutong Liu and Mingyue Luo and Rongping Dai and Gangwei Cheng and Yang Zhang and Xuan Zou and Lue Li and Jun Zhao and Youxin Chen and Yong Zhong and Meifen Zhang},
  title = {{The application of flipped classroom to teaching diabetic retinopathy and glaucoma in ophthalmology undergraduate education: a randomized study}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-024-79807-z},
}
Figure