The Value of Rudyard Kipling’s Kim—An Ethnocentric Perspective

Xin YuanInternational Journal of Culture and History (EJournal) 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Rudyard Kipling’s Kim, the 1901 novel that contributed to his 1907 Nobel Prize in Literature, follows the journey of an Anglo-Indian boy navigating the "Great Game" of espionage and a spiritual pilgrimage with a Tibetan lama. This paper analyzes Kim’s development through the lens of sociological ethnocentrism, arguing that his identity evolves into a unique hybridity that challenges traditional binary definitions of in-group and out-group loyalty. By examining Kim's psychological arc, we uncover a "hybrid ethnocentrism" that balances colonial superiority with a profound, lived attachment to the colonized land.

Introduction: The Problem of the "Hybrid" Identity

Traditional theories of ethnocentrism, first defined by William Graham Sumner in 1906, describe a binary world: the "in-group" is the center of everything (virtuous and superior), while the "out-group" is scaled and rated with contempt. However, this binary fails to account for individuals who exist in the "interstitial space" between two incompatible cultures—specifically the Anglo-Indians of the British Raj.

This paper tackles the long-standing controversy surrounding Kipling’s imperialist viewpoints. By analyzing the character of Kim, we explore how an individual can simultaneously adopt the discriminatory attitudes of a colonizer while maintaining a deep, "in-group" style affection for the colonized population.

Methodology

This study employs qualitative textual analysis and literary criticism, applying Sumner’s sociological framework to the narrative arc of the novel. The analysis segments Kim’s psychological development into three distinct chronological stages to track the evolution of his ethnocentric perspective.

The Three-Stage Evolution of Kim’s Ethnocentrism

Stage 1: The "Friend of all the World" (Innocence)

In his early childhood in Lahore, Kim’s identity is "liminal." Despite his "white man mark" (his birth certificate), he is culturally Indian in behavior, language, and dress. At this stage, his ethnocentrism is muddled; he navigates all social strata without a sense of group superiority, effectively treating the Indian population as his primary in-group.

Stage 2: The Construction of the "Sahib" (Confidence)

Upon being "discovered" by the British military, Kim undergoes a radical shift. Under the tutelage of figures like Father Victor and Colonel Creighton, he is institutionalized into the British world. He undergoes a process of "in-group favoritism," learning to view colonization as a rational necessity and his own ethnicity as inherently superior. During this period, he begins to see Indians as "the other."

Stage 3: The Hybrid Synthesis (Enlightenment)

After graduation and his return to the "Great Game," Kim experiences a profound identity crisis. He realizes he cannot fully integrate his British education with his Indian soul. Ultimately, he reaches a state where two values coexist: he accepts his role as a British "Sahib" (maintaining in-group favoritism) but rejects the standard "out-group derogation." He maintains a "profound love" and gratitude for the Indian people, creating a unique, non-binary ethnocentric model.

Key Results and Sociological Contribution

The analysis concludes that Kim’s ethnocentrism is atypical. While he eventually accepts the British hierarchy, he fails to maintain the "negative orientation toward others" required by orthodox ethnocentrism.

  • Qualitative Finding: Kim’s final state is one of "interstitial space." He acknowledges his sense of superiority due to his white identity but refuses to negate the value of Indian culture.
  • Sociological Contribution: For descendants of colonizers (Anglo-Indians), ethnocentrism is not a zero-sum game but a "faith stuck between ethnocentrism and attachment."

Limitations and Future Work

This study is limited to a single fictional representative. Because Kim’s experience is a product of specific colonial rules and a unique upbringing, his "hybrid ethnocentrism" might only be applicable to specific, small communities with similar "go-between" identities. Future research could extend this framework to the broader historical Anglo-Indian community to see if this three-stage evolution holds true for the group at large.

Author Xin Yuan

Summary updated

Abstract

Kim is the representative novel of Rudyard Kipling, with which he won the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1907. The story is about an Anglo-Indian boy Kim who encounters a series of adventures during the pilgrim of looking for the River of Arrow with a Tibetan lama and finally grows to adulthood. In this novel, Kipling vividly depicted the images of the British colonizers and Indians and brought the Anglo-Indian group into the public's sight. Generally, ethnocentrism emphasizes on the group division and advocates the positivity of the in-group and negativity of the out-group. However, descendants of colonizers, like Anglo-Indian, are easily trapped into a go-between identity, thus, forming a faith stuck between ethnocentrism and attachment to the colonized culture, which is different from the ethnocentrism that colonizers usually believe in. Therefore, based on ethnocentrism, this paper aims to discover the ethnocentrism of the protagonist Kim by studying the novel Kim. One the one hand, he is ethnocentric about the British national culture, manifested in the superiority of ethnicity and the advocation of colonization. On the other hand, his ethnocentrism is both complemented and sometimes contradicted by his attachment to the Indian culture, embodied in his gratitude to Indians and profound love to this country.
BibTeX
@article{yuan2020value,
  author = {Xin Yuan},
  title = {{The Value of Rudyard Kipling’s Kim—An Ethnocentric Perspective}},
  journal = {International Journal of Culture and History (EJournal)},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.18178/ijch.2020.6.1.142},
}
Figure