Deconstructing Identity Struggles of Cross-Cultural People in When We Were Orphans

Wang Fangyuan, Yu Sun, Tong ZhangInternational Journal of Culture and History (EJournal) 2018 · DOI

Abstract

When We Were Orphans by Kazuo Ishiguro portrays the fractured lives of cross-cultural individuals displaced by the Second World War. Caught between conflicting cultural backgrounds and rejected by both their native and adopted societies, these characters experience a profound loss of a stable self. This paper applies deconstruction theory to reveal the inherent instability of identity in these characters and highlights how the "evil of war" dismantles personal constructs of heroism and belonging.

Introduction: The Crisis of the Cross-Cultural Identity

The "identity struggle" is a central theme for cross-cultural individuals, particularly those caught in the global upheaval of the mid-20th century. While previous scholarship on Kazuo Ishiguro’s When We Were Orphans has often focused on feminist perspectives or the mechanics of traumatic narration, there remains a critical gap in understanding how identity itself is "deconstructed"—rendered unstable and ultimately impossible—for those caught between East and West. This paper addresses how cross-cultural individuals suffer from identity crises when forced to navigate societies that view them as perpetual outsiders, illustrating that identity is not a fixed destination but a fragile construct that collapses under the weight of war and cultural divergence.

Methods: A Deconstructive Case Study

This research employs a qualitative literature analytical method, utilizing a case study approach focused on four primary characters: the protagonist Christopher Banks, his childhood friend Akira, the socialite Sarah Hemmings, and Banks’s mother. The analysis is framed through Deconstruction Theory, as originated by Jacques Derrida. In this context, deconstruction is used to expose the "irreducibly complex" and "unstable" nature of the characters' identities. Rather than seeking a cohesive character arc, the study identifies the contradictions and failures in the characters' attempts to assimilate into their respective societies.

Key Insights: Identity as Failed Performance

A primary finding is that identity for the cross-cultural subject often functions as a failed performance. The protagonist, Christopher Banks, spends his life attempting to "imitate" a native Englishman by meticulously absorbing gestures, phrases, and etiquettes. However, these efforts are perceived by native society as "odd" or "absurd," highlighting that his identity is a performance that fails to convince its intended audience.

The character of Akira further illustrates the irony of patriotism. Despite being raised to adore Japan and eventually serving in the Japanese army, he is mercilessly ostracized for his perceived foreignness. His eventual punishment by the very country he sought to serve underscores the futility of his identity-seeking mission.

Furthermore, the paper explores the deconstruction of the "hero" archetype. Characters like Sarah Hemmings and Banks’s mother begin with identities rooted in grand, righteous missions—such as fighting the opium trade or saving the world. By the novel's conclusion, these identities are dismantled: Sarah realizes her powerlessness, and Banks’s mother is revealed to have sacrificed her principles to survive as a warlord's concubine.

Results: The Broken Dream of Belonging

The analysis concludes that for cross-cultural people in times of conflict, identity is a "broken dream." The characters face universal rejection, accepted by neither their home nor host countries. This leads to a state of permanent liminality, where estrangement is an inevitable byproduct of the "huge divergence" between nations during the war era. Ultimately, the realization of individual weakness against the "evil of war" serves as the final blow to these constructed identities, as seen in Banks’s failure to fulfill his role as a "famous detective" who can save his parents.

Limitations and Future Directions

While this study successfully applies deconstructive concepts to character motivations, it does not deeply engage with the linguistic or structural deconstruction of Ishiguro’s prose—a hallmark of Derridean analysis. Future research could involve:

  • Comparative Analysis: Examining identity instability across Ishiguro’s broader body of work, such as The Remains of the Day or Never Let Me Go.
  • Sociological Frameworks: Applying modern theories of "Third Culture Kids" (TCKs) to provide a contemporary lens for understanding these historical psychological struggles.
  • Narrative Theory: Expanding the study to include the role of memory and "unreliable narration" in how these identities are deconstructed by the characters themselves.

Summary updated

Abstract

When We Were Orphans tells the stories of several cross-cultural people. They have to live in a different country and cultural background because of the Second World War. Being unaccepted by both cultural circles, they constantly lose their original identities. Based on deconstruction theory, this paper reveals confusion of cross-cultural people and evil of war from their deconstructing identity struggles.
BibTeX
@article{fangyuan2018deconstructing,
  author = {Wang Fangyuan and Yu Sun and Tong Zhang},
  title = {{Deconstructing Identity Struggles of Cross-Cultural People in When We Were Orphans}},
  journal = {International Journal of Culture and History (EJournal)},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.18178/ijch.2018.4.3.125},
}
Figure