Culture at the Core: Invented Traditions and Imagined Communities. Part I: Identity Formation

Cecily MorrisonInternational Review of Scottish Studies 2007 · DOI

Culture at the Core Series Logo

Introduction

The concept of "Scottish traditional dance" is often perceived as an ancient, static relic of a bygone era. However, research by Cecily Morrison suggests a more complex reality. These dance forms are not merely inherited artifacts but are "invented traditions"—20th-century constructs designed to forge specific national and cultural identities. By deconstructing four distinct dance genres, Morrison demonstrates how "authenticity" is a curated tool used to navigate the tensions between Scottish nationalism, English influence, and internal Highland-Lowland divides.

The Invention of Tradition

The paper addresses the colloquial assumption that tradition is a static practice passed down unchanged. In reality, the category of "Scottish traditional dance" did not exist until the 20th century. Prior to this, dance in Scotland was organic, adaptive, and not a self-conscious marker of national identity.

Morrison utilizes Eric Hobsbawm’s framework of "Invented Tradition" to explore how historical upheavals—such as the Highland Clearances and the Union of Parliaments—created an identity vacuum. This vacuum was filled by 20th-century organizers who established new practices through repetition and a claimed link to a suitable historic past, creating what Benedict Anderson calls an "imagined community."

Methodology and Data

The study employs a qualitative historical and sociological analysis, performing a comparative study of four dance genres: Scottish Country Dance, Highland Dance, Scottish Stepdance, and Cheilidh Dance. Morrison evaluates each through its historical origin, method of codification, and the specific "stream" of Scottish identity it aims to project.

The "data" for this humanities research includes:

  • Historical Primary Sources: Documents like David Anderson’s Ballroom Guide (1886) and 17th-century records of the Perth Glover’s dance.
  • Organizational Records: Founding principles and newsletters from the Royal Scottish Country Dance Society (RSCDS) and the Scottish Official Board of Highland Dance (SOBHD).
  • Ethnographic Observation: Analysis of movement styles, dress (kilts, ghillies), and social contexts like the "Cheilidh house."

Four Paths to Identity

Morrison identifies three historical movements that shaped modern Scottishness: the internal Highland-Lowland divide, the "Scotticization" of English refinement, and the Celtic Revival. These streams manifest differently across the four genres:

1. Scottish Country Dance (RSCDS)

Formed in 1923, the RSCDS represents a "top-down" invention. It bypassed the immediate 19th-century past to revive 18th-century "Golden Age" ballroom styles. The goal was to prove that Scottish culture could be as refined and "polite" as English culture, effectively "Scotticizing" English social norms.

2. Highland Dance

Standardized in 1952, Highland Dance has 19th-century roots in stage performance but relies heavily on "fabricated lore." For instance, the Sword Dance is often presented as a pre-battle omen. This genre creates a romanticized, warrior-like Celtic identity, heavily utilizing symbols like the kilt and bagpipes to differentiate Scotland from England.

3. Scottish Stepdance

In contrast to the national focus of the first two, Stepdance represents a "bottom-up" revival. Having survived in Cape Breton, Canada, it was reintroduced to Scotland as a marker of a "minority identity"—specifically that of the Gaelic-speaking Gaidhealtachd. Its authenticity is found in the "living community" rather than ancient manuscripts.

4. Cheilidh Dance

Emerging as a youth "craze" in the 1970s, Cheilidh is an "unselfconsciously Scottish" form. It rejects the formal rules of the RSCDS in favor of high-energy, informal social interaction. Because it lacks a formal "invented" history, it is highly innovative, evolving rapidly alongside contemporary music.

The Innovation Paradox

A key insight of the paper is the trade-off between constructed authenticity and innovation. The more a dance form relies on rigid standardization (like Highland Dance), the less room there is for evolution. Conversely, "living" traditions like Cheilidh dance, which are less concerned with historical "purity," are free to innovate and remain relevant to contemporary participants.

Conclusion

"Authenticity" in Scottish dance is a strategy rather than a static fact. Whether found in 18th-century manuscripts, warrior lore, or living Gaelic communities, it serves to anchor an imagined community in a turbulent history. While this first part of the study focuses on identity formation, future work will explore how these dances function in community formation today, both within Scotland and across its global diaspora.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{morrison2007culture,
  author = {Cecily Morrison},
  title = {{Culture at the Core: Invented Traditions and Imagined Communities. Part I: Identity Formation}},
  journal = {International Review of Scottish Studies},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.21083/irss.v28i0.174},
}
Figure