The Stiffness of 3-PRS PM Across Parasitic and Orientational Workspace

Hassen Nigatu, Jihao Li, Keqi Zhu, Junhan Zhang, Haotian Guo, Guodong Lu, Doik Kim

Abstract

This study investigates the stiffness characteristics of the Sprint Z3 head, also known as 3-PRS Parallel Kinematics Machines, which are among the most extensively researched and viably successful manipulators for precision machining applications. Despite the wealth of research on these robotic manipulators, no previous work has demonstrated their stiffness performance within the parasitic motion space. Such an undesired motion influences their stiffness properties, as stiffness is configuration-dependent. Addressing this gap, this paper develops a stiffness model that accounts for both the velocity-level parasitic motion space and the regular workspace. Numerical simulations are provided to illustrate the stiffness characteristics of the manipulator across all considered spaces. The results indicate that the stiffness profile within the parasitic motion space is both shallower and the values are smaller when compared to the stiffness distribution across the orientation workspace. This implies that evaluating a manipulator's performance adequately requires assessing its ability to resist external loads during parasitic motion. Therefore, comprehending this aspect is crucial for redesigning components to enhance overall stiffness.

Introduction

In the realm of high-precision machining—critical for aerospace and automotive sectors—parallel kinematics machines (PKMs) like the Sprint Z3 are favored for their high speed and structural rigidity. However, these mechanisms often suffer from parasitic motion: unintended translations or rotations that occur as a geometric byproduct when the robot moves in its intended directions. While engineers have extensively mapped the stiffness of these robots in their primary orientational workspace, the stiffness within the parasitic motion space has been largely overlooked. Because stiffness is configuration-dependent, a robot that appears rigid during intended tilts may be significantly "softer" and prone to vibration during unintended parasitic shifts. This paper fills this research gap by modeling and simulating stiffness across the entire operational range.

Architecture of the 3-PRS parallel manipulator and its kinematic representation.

Methodology

The authors developed a comprehensive stiffness model using several classical engineering approaches:

  • Kinematic Modeling: An analytic inverse Jacobian was derived via the reciprocal screw approach to define the relationship between joint movements and platform motion.
  • Parasitic Motion Equations: Equations were derived at the velocity level to isolate how independent task variables (like tilt) generate parasitic ones (like unintended horizontal shifts).
  • Series-Spring Model: Each limb was conceptualized as a series of connected springs, including the carriage assembly (slider/lead screw), revolute joints, and the limb body (fixed-length links and spherical joints).
  • Virtual Work Principle: By applying the principle of virtual work and Hooke’s Law, the kinematic Jacobian was transformed into a 6x6 stiffness matrix that accounts for both actuation and structural constraints.

Numerical simulations were performed using geometric parameters specific to the Sprint Z3, such as a base radius of 326.923 mm and a moving plate radius of 250 mm. Material properties were integrated using stiffness coefficients for components like the Carriage Assembly ($3.8 \times 10^7$ N/m) and Revolute Joints ($3.2 \times 10^9$ N/m).

Key Insights: The "Soft" Parasitic Space

The most critical finding is that the stiffness profile in the parasitic motion space is both shallower and lower in value than in the orientational workspace. This suggests that the robot is less predictable and less rigid when undergoing unintended movements.

Furthermore, the study confirms that parasitic motion is purely a result of the structural constraints embedded in the Jacobian matrix. Interestingly, vertical movement ($v_z$) does not contribute to generating parasitic motion in this specific architecture. While peak stiffness is often found at the "zero orientation" (the robot's home position), the stiffness is much more uniform across rotational movements than it is across parasitic translational movements.

Key Results and Comparative Mapping

The paper provides detailed 3D plots comparing stiffness across the $x, y,$ and $z$ axes. In the parasitic space, stiffness covers a much narrower and lower range.

Stiffness distribution $k_{pz}$ across (a) orientation workspace and (b) parasitic motion space.

As illustrated in the mapping of $z$-axis axial stiffness ($k_{pz}$), the orientation space shows a robust distribution, whereas the parasitic space exhibits a sharp, narrow peak. This indicates that even small unintended shifts can lead to a rapid drop in rigidity, potentially compromising machining precision if these "soft spots" are not accounted for in the control or design phases.

Conclusion and Future Work

The findings argue that simply evaluating the intended workspace is insufficient for high-precision tasks. To improve performance, engineers must redesign components specifically to resist external loads during parasitic phases. Future research directions include moving beyond static analysis to account for inertia-induced bending and vibrations at high speeds, as well as refining the model to account for real-world joint friction and plate elasticity.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study investigates the stiffness characteristics of the Sprint Z3 head, also known as 3- PRS Parallel Kinematics Machines, which are among the most extensively researched and viably successful manipulators for precision machining applications. Despite the wealth of research on these robotic manipulators, no previous work has demonstrated their stiffness performance within the parasitic motion space. Such an undesired motion influences their stiffness properties, as stiffness is configuration-dependent. Addressing this gap, this paper develops a stiffness model that accounts for both the velocity-level parasitic motion space and the regular workspace. Numerical simulations are provided to illustrate the stiffness characteristics of the manipulator across all considered spaces. The results indicate that the stiffness profile within the parasitic motion space is both shallower and the values are smaller when compared to the stiffness distribution across the orientation workspace. This implies that evaluating a manipulator's performance adequately requires assessing its ability to resist external loads during parasitic motion. Therefore, comprehending this aspect is crucial for redesigning components to enhance overall stiffness.
BibTeX
@misc{nigatu2024stiffness,
  author = {Hassen Nigatu and Jihao Li and Keqi Zhu and Junhan Zhang and Haotian Guo and Guodong Lu and Doik Kim},
  title = {{The Stiffness of 3-PRS PM Across Parasitic and Orientational Workspace}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2405.08418},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08418},
}
Figure