Abstract
Effective strategies to reduce the occurrence of wheat powdery mildew include the use of resistant varieties and application of fungicides. However, most studies rarely focus on the quantitative value of fungicide reduction using resistant varieties. To explore how the fungicides performed on different resistant wheat varieties to powdery mildew, field experiments were conducted during wheat growing seasons in 2018/19 and 2019/20 to investigate the control efficacies of enostroburin⋅epoxiconazole 18% SC and triadimefon 20% EC to wheat powdery mildew on a highly resistant wheat variety ("Baofeng104") and a highly susceptible wheat variety ("Jingshuang16"). The analyses of variance on control efficacies showed that the control efficacies of enostroburin⋅epoxiconazole 18% SC to wheat powdery mildew were mostly significantly higher than triadimefon 20% EC under the same conditions (i.e., varieties, dosages). However, both fungicide and variety resistance made variabilities in the mildew disease index and played a significant role in mildew management. Particularly, the variety resistance made the greatest contribution in mildew-reducing, and the disease index could significantly be reduced on the highly resistant variety even in the absence of fungicide treatment. The control efficacies to mildew on the highly susceptible variety mainly depended on the high efficiency of fungicides whereas the highly resistant variety were mainly by virtue of variety resistance through the comparative analyses of linear regression models. Furthermore, the random-coefficient regression models and quantile models quantificationally expounded that the relationships between active ingredient dosage and disease index or control efficacy varied from the effects of variety, fungicide, and year, particular from variety. Thus, a dosage reference table of enostroburin⋅epoxiconazole 18% SC or triadimefon 20% EC for different resistant wheat varieties were provided; it would be helpful for users to formulate an appropriate dosage of fungicide on mildew management in the field and avoid overusing or superfluous application. Further study needs to consider the effects of fungicide reduction on wheat yields, only then the maximum-economic benefits on mildew management can be determined.
Introduction
Wheat powdery mildew, caused by the fungus Blumeria graminis f. sp. tritici, is a global threat to food security. To combat this pathogen, farmers typically rely on two primary strategies: planting resistant wheat varieties and applying fungicides. While it is qualitatively understood that resistant plants require less chemical intervention, there is a lack of precise, quantitative data on exactly how much fungicide can be reduced without risking crop loss. This knowledge gap often leads to "insurance spraying"—the over-application of chemicals—which increases costs, harms the environment, and accelerates the development of fungicide resistance. This paper seeks to quantify the relationship between host resistance and chemical efficacy to create actionable dosage guidelines.
Methodology
The researchers conducted field experiments over two growing seasons (2018–2020) in Hebei Province, China. They compared a highly resistant variety (Baofeng104) against a highly susceptible one (Jingshuang16) using two fungicides: enostroburin·epoxiconazole 18% SC and triadimefon 20% EC.
The study utilized a robust statistical toolkit, including ANOVA to determine the primary drivers of disease reduction and linear regression to model the relationship between dosage and disease index. Advanced random-coefficient regression and quantile models were employed to account for environmental variability across different years.
Key Results and Discussion
The Dominance of Host Resistance
Variety resistance was identified as the single most important factor, accounting for 70% to 80% of the total variation in the disease index. Even with zero fungicide application, the resistant variety "Baofeng104" maintained high control efficacy, often outperforming the susceptible variety treated with high chemical dosages.
Chemical Efficacy and Environmental Factors
Enostroburin·epoxiconazole was consistently more effective than triadimefon. On susceptible wheat, using the more effective chemical allowed for a 30% reduction in active ingredient dosage to achieve the same level of control. However, quantile models revealed that disease outcomes can vary significantly based on the year (weather, humidity, etc.), highlighting the limitations of static label recommendations.
Conclusion
This study provides a quantitative roadmap for reducing fungicide use by leveraging host plant resistance. By modeling the interaction between wheat varieties and chemical treatments, the researchers demonstrated that highly resistant varieties can achieve superior disease control with minimal chemical input. Future work should integrate yield data to determine the maximum economic benefits of these reduced-dosage strategies and expand testing to moderately resistant varieties.
Summary updated