Abstract
This study evaluates the sensitivity and cross-resistance of 126 Botrytis cinerea strains, the cause of strawberry grey mould, to fluazinam (FAN), boscalid (BCI), and phenazine-1-carboxylic acid (PCA) in Hunan Province, China. Mean EC50 values were 0.1349 μg/mL for FAN, 2.1238 μg/mL for BCI, and 5.2601 μg/mL for PCA. Sensitivity frequencies were not normally distributed, indicating sub-populations with reduced sensitivity. Significant cross-resistance was observed between all three fungicides. Field trials confirmed fluazinam as the most effective (84.87% control), while PCA underperformed. These findings provide a critical baseline for managing fungicide resistance in strawberry production.
Introduction
Botrytis cinerea, the necrotrophic fungus responsible for strawberry grey mould, is a major threat to global strawberry production, often causing losses exceeding 25%. Due to its high reproductive rate and genetic plasticity, it rapidly develops resistance to fungicides. In China, traditional treatments like carbendazim are failing, leading growers to adopt newer agents such as fluazinam (FAN), boscalid (BCI), and phenazine-1-carboxylic acid (PCA). Establishing sensitivity baselines and understanding cross-resistance patterns is essential for sustainable disease management.
Methods
Researchers collected 126 B. cinerea isolates from nine regions in Hunan Province. Sensitivity was determined using a mycelial growth rate assay to calculate the EC50 (concentration for 50% inhibition). The distribution of these values was analyzed for normality to detect emerging resistance. Cross-resistance was assessed via correlation analysis of log-transformed EC50 values. Finally, two-year field trials (2017–2018) evaluated the real-world efficacy of these fungicides.
Results and Sensitivity Profiles
The study revealed a wide range of sensitivities across the 126 strains. Fluazinam (FAN) was the most potent in vitro, with the lowest mean EC50. In contrast, PCA required significantly higher concentrations to achieve the same inhibitory effect.
The "resistance gap"—the ratio between the most and least sensitive strains—was particularly high for boscalid (73.15-fold) and fluazinam (70.22-fold), indicating significant diversity in the fungal population's response to these chemicals.
Key Insights: Skewed Distributions and Cross-Resistance
A critical finding was that sensitivity frequencies for all three fungicides were not normally distributed. Instead, they showed a positive skew, suggesting that sub-populations with reduced sensitivity are already present in the field.
Furthermore, the study found strong positive correlations (r > 0.93) between resistance to FAN, BCI, and PCA. This is unexpected given their different modes of action (respiration inhibition vs. SDHI vs. redox disruption) and suggests a non-target-site resistance mechanism, such as multi-drug efflux pumps.
Field Efficacy and Conclusions
Field trials mirrored the laboratory findings. Fluazinam (FAN) provided the best control at 84.87%, outperforming the standard control drug, procymidone. PCA was the least effective, with control rates around 60%.
The presence of cross-resistance and skewed sensitivity distributions highlights the urgent need for integrated pest management. Growers should avoid relying on a single class of fungicide and instead implement strict rotation schedules, potentially incorporating biological control agents to preserve the efficacy of highly effective tools like fluazinam. Future research will focus on the molecular mechanisms, such as efflux pump overexpression, driving this multi-drug resistance.
Summary updated