Prevalence and spatial distribution of cranberry fruit rot pathogens in British Columbia, Canada and potential fungicides for fruit rot management

Brandon M. Wood, Ethan L. Mcbride, Keiko Nabetani, Taylor Griffin, Siva SabaratnamFrontiers in Plant Science 2023 · DOI

Introduction

Cranberry fruit rot (CFR) is a complex disease caused by a diverse group of fungal pathogens, rather than a single agent. While British Columbia (BC) is a major global producer of cranberries, management strategies have historically relied on data from the United States Northeast. However, BC’s unique climate and peat-based soils create a distinct "fungal neighborhood" compared to the sand-based bogs of Massachusetts or Wisconsin. This study provides the first comprehensive map of the CFR disease complex in BC, identifying primary regional threats and screening potential fungicides for effective management.

Methods and Field Survey

Researchers conducted a multi-year investigation involving 28 commercial farms across six key cranberry-producing regions in southwestern British Columbia: Chilliwack, Langley, Surrey, Pitt Meadows, Richmond, and Delta.

Map of the 28 cranberry farms surveyed across six regions in southwestern British Columbia.

Samples were collected at three critical phenological stages: flowering, green fruit, and ripe fruit (cv. 'Stevens'). Fungi were isolated using acidified growth media and identified through a combination of colony morphology and molecular barcoding of the ITS rDNA region.

Additionally, the team performed in vitro screening of 26 fungicides representing nine different FRAC (Fungicide Resistance Action Committee) groups. They measured efficacy based on the inhibition of mycelial growth and spore germination across 10 major fungal species.

Key Insights and Results

The "Big Three" Pathogens

While the fungal complex is diverse, three pathogens dominated the BC landscape: Allantophomopsis cytisporea (black rot), Phyllosticta spp. (early rot), and Physalospora vaccinii (blotch rot). These pathogens were present across all surveyed regions, suggesting that a province-wide management strategy is more feasible than hyper-local protocols.

The Latency Trap

Pathogens were detected as early as the flowering stage, long before visible rot appeared. This confirms that many CFR fungi are "latent" invaders that enter the plant early and wait for the fruit to ripen. Ripe fruit showed the highest pathogen recovery, with A. cytisporea reaching up to 71% incidence. Notably, when healthy-looking fruit was stored for three weeks at room temperature, rot incidence skyrocketed, sometimes jumping from less than 5% at harvest to over 60%.

Fungicide Efficacy

The study highlighted that a fungicide's ability to stop mycelial growth does not always correlate with its ability to stop spore germination. Key findings included:

  • Group M (Multi-site): Copper-based fungicides and Captan were highly effective across all metrics.
  • Group 3 (DMIs): Difenoconazole, prothioconazole, and propiconazole showed high efficacy in growth inhibition.
  • Group 7 (SDHIs): Benzovindiflupyr was a standout performer.
  • Group 33: Fosetyl-Al effectively inhibited both growth and germination for most pathogens.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While this study identifies a data-driven path for improving crop yields, the results are currently limited to in vitro observations. In a real-world bog, factors such as UV degradation, rain wash-off, and the plant's cuticle may alter fungicide performance. Furthermore, the industry must remain vigilant regarding fungicide resistance, particularly when relying on single-site modes of action (Groups 3 or 7). Future research should focus on in planta field trials to validate these findings and develop robust rotation programs to preserve the long-term utility of these chemical tools.

Summary updated

Abstract

Twenty-eight cranberry farms in southwestern British Columbia were investigated for the prevalence and spatial distribution of fungal pathogens that contribute to fruit rot incidence. Farms were selected from six regions where most cranberry production is concentrated. Flowers, and green and ripe fruit (var. 'Stevens') samples, collected during two consecutive crop seasons, were analyzed for fruit rot pathogens. The most frequently isolated pathogens were identified as <i>Allantophomopsis cytisporea</i>, <i>Botrytis cinerea</i>, <i>Coleophoma empetri</i>, <i>Colletotrichum fioriniae</i>, <i>Colletotrichum gloeosporioides</i>, <i>Fusicoccum putrefaciens</i>, <i>Glomerella</i> sp., <i>Phomopsis vaccinii</i>, <i>Phyllosticta elongata</i>, <i>Phyllosticta vaccinii</i> and <i>Physalospora vaccinii</i>. The pathogens <i>Allantophomopsis cytisporea</i>, <i>Phyllosticta</i> spp., and <i>Physalospora vaccinii</i> were found at high incidence. These pathogens were present in all cranberry growing regions, although their mean percentage incidence varied from farm-to-farm and region-to-region. Amongst the pathogens from three phenological stages of cranberry crop examined, ripe fruit had the highest percentage incidence of fruit rot pathogens compared to that of flowers or green fruit; thus, indicating their presence at the early stages of crop development. The efficacy to inhibit the mycelial growth and spore germination of the fruit rot pathogens by twenty six fungicides, belonging to nine different modes of actions, were evaluated <i>in vitro</i>. The copper-based fungicides and captan of group M, flutriafol, triforine, difenoconazole, prothioconazole and propiconazole of group 3, benzovindiflupyr of group 7, and fosetyl-Al of group 33 demonstrated a high degree of efficacy in inhibiting the mycelial growth of all fruit rot pathogens. The fungicides chlorothalonil of group M, fenbuconazole of group 3, pyrimethanil and cyprodinil of group 9, and fludioxonil of group 12 also demonstrated activity against most fruit rot pathogens. The copper-based fungicides, chlorothalonil, captan, flutriafol, triforine, difenoconazole, prothioconazole, propiconazole, benzovindiflupyr, and fosetyl-Al effectively prevented the spore germination of most fruit rot pathogens. This demonstrated activity of the fungicides towards cranberry fruit rot pathogens should be assessed for efficacy <i>in planta</i> under field conditions. The current study identified the most critical fungal pathogens causing fruit rot of cranberry in British Columbia and potential fungicides that could be used in the management of fruit rot and to improve fruit quality and yield.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wood2023prevalence,
  author = {Brandon M. Wood and Ethan L. Mcbride and Keiko Nabetani and Taylor Griffin and Siva Sabaratnam},
  title = {{Prevalence and spatial distribution of cranberry fruit rot pathogens in British Columbia, Canada and potential fungicides for fruit rot management}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2023.1274094},
}
Figure