An Effective Intercropping Pattern Reducing the Incidence of Pepper Phyllosticta Leaf Blight in Capsicum Fields

Chunyuan Wu, Dongming Wu, Yang Gui-sheng, Wei Li, Qinfen Li2017 · DOI

Abstract Phyllosticta leaf blight, caused by Phyllosticta penicillariae, is a major constraint on pepper production in tropical regions. This study investigated the efficacy of various intercropping patterns involving pepper (P), maize (M), and soybean (S) in reducing disease incidence. Field experiments tested nine combinations: P-mono, P2M1, P4M2, P6M2, P2S1, P4S2, P6S2, P4S1M1, and P6S1M1. Results indicated that pepper-maize intercropping significantly reduced disease incidence (25.0%–29.1%) compared to mono-culture (41.6%). The P2M1 pattern was the most effective, achieving a 53% efficacy rate. Conversely, pepper-soybean intercropping showed no significant disease suppression. These findings suggest that specific agro-ecological arrangements, particularly those utilizing maize as a companion crop, offer a sustainable alternative to chemical pesticides for managing leaf blight in pepper fields.

Introduction

Red cluster pepper is an essential spice crop in Southern China. However, its cultivation in tropical climates is frequently disrupted by fungal pathogens, most notably Phyllosticta penicillariae, the causal agent of Phyllosticta leaf blight. This disease manifests as necrotic lesions, yellowing, and stunted growth, often leading to severe defoliation and fruit drop. Given the difficulty of curing established infections, preventative measures are critical. While chemical pesticides are the traditional defense, there is a growing need for sustainable "agro-ecological" strategies. Intercropping—the practice of growing two or more crops in proximity—presents a potential solution by naturally disrupting pathogen dispersal and altering microclimates.

Methods

Field trials were conducted at Hongling Farm in Hainan Province, China. Using a randomized complete block design with four replications, researchers evaluated nine planting patterns over a six-month period. The treatments included a mono-culture control (P-mono), pepper-maize (P-M) ratios (2:1, 4:2, 6:2), pepper-soybean (P-S) ratios (2:1, 4:2, 6:2), and mixed combinations (P4S1M1, P6S1M1). Disease incidence and severity were monitored through 15 observations over 119 days. A modified formula-grading scheme was employed to calculate the disease index and the overall efficacy of each intercropping system relative to the control.

Key Results

The study revealed a stark contrast in the performance of different companion crops. Maize acted as a highly effective biological shield, whereas soybean provided negligible protection.

Temporal progress of disease incidence (%) across different intercropping patterns.

As shown in Figure 1, the mono-culture pepper reached a disease incidence of 41.6% by the end of the assessment period. In comparison, the P2M1 pattern (2 rows of pepper to 1 row of maize) reduced incidence to just 25%. The data suggests a density-dependent effect: as the number of contiguous pepper rows increased, so did the disease incidence, likely due to easier spore transmission between host plants.

Temporal progress of the disease index across different intercropping patterns.

The disease index—a measure of severity—further confirmed the superiority of the pepper-maize system. As illustrated in Figure 2, the disease index for pepper-maize plots ranged from 3.9% to 4.5%, significantly lower than the 7.6% to 8.3% observed in the mono-culture and soybean-intercropped plots. The P2M1 pattern achieved the highest efficacy at 53%, followed by P4M2 (50.6%) and P6M2 (45.8%).

Discussion and Conclusion

The effectiveness of maize is likely attributed to its physical architecture. Its height may serve as a mechanical barrier to wind-borne spores or create a microclimate less conducive to fungal growth. The failure of soybean intercropping underscores that crop diversity alone is insufficient; the specific biological and structural traits of the companion crop are paramount.

While P2M1 offered the highest disease suppression, the researchers suggest that P4M2 may be more practical for commercial farming, as it potentially balances disease control with higher total economic yield. Future research should investigate the precise mechanisms of this "maize shield" and conduct long-term economic assessments to encourage the adoption of these sustainable practices in pepper cultivation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Field experiments were conducted to investigate the most effective intercropping pattern of capsicum and maize/soybean to reduce the incidence of pepper phyllosticta leaf blight disease. The treatment combinations were P-mono, P2M1, P4M2, P6M2, P2S1, P4S2, P6M2, P4S1M1 And P6S1M1, (P, Pepper; M, Maize; S, Soybean; 1-6, number of rows of capsicum, maize or soybean per plot). The results showed that combination of C2M1, C4M2 and C6M2 reduced incidence of phyllosticta leaf blight, with the incidence rate from 25.0% to 29.1%, which were significantly over their counterpart mono capsicum treatment (incidence rate, 41.6%). The combination of C2M had the most drastic effect in reducing the disease on pepper. The incidence of the disease increased with increasing number of rows of capsicum in the intercrop combination. The combination of capsicum-soybean had no effect on the incidence of the disease. The disease index ranged from 3.9 % ~ 4.5% in pepper-maize, significantly lower than the other 6 treatments. The efficacy was ranged from 2.4% to 53% at the end of assessment, and the intercropping system of P2M1 achieved the highest efficacy (53%). The results signified that particular agro-ecological systems are effective approach in diseases control on pepper, and the proper intercropping pattern might decrease the input quantity of pesticides in capsicum planting systems.
BibTeX
@misc{wu2017effective,
  author = {Chunyuan Wu and Dongming Wu and Yang Gui-sheng and Wei Li and Qinfen Li},
  title = {{An Effective Intercropping Pattern Reducing the Incidence of Pepper Phyllosticta Leaf Blight in Capsicum Fields}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.2991/iceesd-17.2017.90},
}
Figure