Abstract
6th generation (6G) communication research is currently focusing on non-terrestrial networks (NTNs) to promote ubiquitous and ultra-high-capacity global connectivity. Specifically, multi-layered hierarchical networks, i.e., the orchestration among different aerial/space platforms, including Low and High Altitude Platforms (LAPs and HAPs), and satellites co-operating at different altitudes, currently represent one the most attractive technological options to solve coverage and latency constraints associated with the NTN paradigm. However, there are still several issues to be resolved for proper network design. In this work, we evaluate the performance of different multi-layered non-terrestrial configurations, and provide guidelines on the optimal working point(s) for which it is possible to achieve a good compromise between improved system flexibility and network performance, with respect to a baseline standalone deployment.
Introduction
As we move toward 6G, the goal is "ubiquitous connectivity"—internet access everywhere, from the middle of the ocean to the highest mountain peaks. Terrestrial base stations alone cannot meet this demand. Non-terrestrial networks (NTNs) using satellites and aerial platforms offer a solution, but standalone deployments face significant challenges. Geostationary (GEO) satellites provide massive coverage but suffer from high latency and severe path loss. Low Earth Orbit (LEO) satellites offer lower latency but require complex constellations due to their rapid movement. High Altitude Platforms (HAPs), such as balloons or drones, provide high local capacity but limited coverage. This paper investigates the orchestration of these layers into hierarchical architectures to maximize capacity and minimize signal outages.
Architectural Framework and Methodology
The researchers evaluated four distinct networking architectures to determine the most effective configuration for 6G connectivity:
- GE (GEO-to-Earth): The baseline standalone satellite model.
- GLE (GEO-to-LEO-to-Earth): Utilizing LEO satellites as intermediate relays.
- GHE (GEO-to-HAP-to-Earth): Using HAPs in the stratosphere as relays.
- GLHE (GEO-to-LEO-to-HAP-to-Earth): A fully integrated three-hop system.
The study employed analytical models for Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) using an Amplify-and-Forward (AF) relaying protocol. These models account for environmental factors such as atmospheric gas absorption, tropospheric scintillation, rain attenuation, and clutter loss. The theoretical framework was validated through 10,000 Monte Carlo simulations across the S-band (2 GHz) and Ka-band (20/30 GHz), using standardized parameters from 3GPP and ITU-R.
Performance Analysis and Key Insights
The evaluation revealed several critical insights into the performance of multi-layered NTNs:
The HAP Advantage
HAPs, operating at an altitude of approximately 20 km, emerged as the "sweet spot" for relaying. By acting as a relay, they significantly reduce the distance of the Earth link—the segment most vulnerable to atmospheric interference—compared to LEO satellites orbiting at 600 km or more. In the S-band, the GHE architecture provided up to a 6x increase in capacity over the standalone GEO baseline.
The LEO Power Paradox
A counter-intuitive finding was that LEO satellites are not always superior relays. Due to stricter power and antenna constraints (lower EIRP) compared to massive GEO satellites, LEO relays can actually degrade signal quality in high-frequency Ka-band scenarios.
Diminishing Returns of Complexity
The most complex architecture, GLHE, consistently underperformed compared to the simpler GHE setup. The additional hop through a LEO satellite introduced more noise and path loss than it mitigated, resulting in a capacity approximately 42% lower than that of GHE.
Frequency and Reliability
Transitioning from the S-band to the Ka-band delivered a 10x increase in average capacity, reaching nearly 3 Gbps. Reliability also varied significantly; at 2 GHz, the GHE setup achieved an outage probability of less than 1% at a 24 dB SNR threshold, whereas the standalone GE architecture failed to reach this level even at much lower thresholds.
Conclusion and Future Work
While multi-layering generally enhances coverage and capacity, the hybrid GEO-HAP (GHE) architecture offers the best balance of performance and complexity. Future research should explore alternative relaying protocols like Decode-and-Forward (DF) to mitigate noise accumulation. Additionally, modeling the mobility dynamics of LEO and HAP platforms and conducting a deeper analysis of end-to-end latency will be crucial for supporting real-time 6G applications.
Summary updated