The Potential of Multilayered Hierarchical Nonterrestrial Networks for 6G: A Comparative Analysis Among Networking Architectures

Dengke Wang, Marco Giordani, Mohamed‐Slim Alouini, Michele Zorzi

Abstract

6th generation (6G) communication research is currently focusing on non-terrestrial networks (NTNs) to promote ubiquitous and ultra-high-capacity global connectivity. Specifically, multi-layered hierarchical networks, i.e., the orchestration among different aerial/space platforms, including Low and High Altitude Platforms (LAPs and HAPs), and satellites co-operating at different altitudes, currently represent one the most attractive technological options to solve coverage and latency constraints associated with the NTN paradigm. However, there are still several issues to be resolved for proper network design. In this work, we evaluate the performance of different multi-layered non-terrestrial configurations, and provide guidelines on the optimal working point(s) for which it is possible to achieve a good compromise between improved system flexibility and network performance, with respect to a baseline standalone deployment.

Introduction

As 5G deployments mature, the research community is looking toward 6G to deliver "ubiquitous connectivity"—high-speed internet access in remote rural areas, deep deserts, and across oceans where terrestrial infrastructure is non-existent. Non-Terrestrial Networks (NTNs) are the cornerstone of this vision. While Geostationary (GEO) satellites offer vast coverage, they are hampered by significant path loss and high latency. Conversely, Low Earth Orbit (LEO) satellites and High Altitude Platforms (HAPs) provide lower latency but smaller coverage footprints. The central challenge lies in determining the optimal hierarchical "stack" of these layers to maximize capacity and reliability.

Networking Architectures

To identify the architectural "sweet spot," this study evaluates four distinct networking configurations:

  1. GE (GEO-to-Earth): The baseline standalone satellite approach.
  2. GLE (GEO-to-LEO-to-Earth): Utilizing LEO satellites as intermediate relays.
  3. GHE (GEO-to-HAP-to-Earth): Utilizing HAPs as intermediate relays.
  4. GLHE (GEO-to-LEO-to-HAP-to-Earth): A complex, three-hop integrated architecture.
The four non-terrestrial networking configurations evaluated: GE (standalone), GLE (LEO relay), GHE (HAP relay), and GLHE (integrated LEO-HAP relay).

Methodology

The performance of these architectures was assessed using a mathematical framework based on an Amplify-and-Forward (AF) relay protocol. The model incorporates sophisticated channel dynamics, including atmospheric gas attenuation, ionospheric scintillation, rain fading, and clutter loss. Simulations were conducted across two primary frequency bands: the S-band (2 GHz) for robust reliability and the Ka-band (20/30 GHz) for high-capacity throughput. The theoretical models were validated through 10,000 Monte Carlo simulation runs, utilizing standardized system parameters from 3GPP (Rel-17/18) and ITU-R reports to ensure realistic hardware and environmental constraints.

Performance Analysis and Key Results

The comparative analysis reveals that HAPs serve as a critical "atmospheric bridge." Because HAPs operate at approximately 20km altitude—above the majority of the lower atmosphere where the most significant signal degradation occurs—they effectively shorten the bottleneck Earth-link.

Average capacity vs. elevation angle for different architectures at (a) 2 GHz and (b) 20/30 GHz, highlighting the performance gains of HAP-based relaying.

Key Findings:

  • Capacity Gains: In the 2 GHz band, the GHE architecture achieves up to 6x higher capacity than the standalone GE baseline. Transitioning to the Ka-band (20/30 GHz) offers a further 10x capacity increase over the S-band, though it remains highly sensitive to atmospheric conditions and alignment.
  • The LEO Bottleneck: Surprisingly, LEO-based relaying (GLE) can underperform direct GEO links in the Ka-band. This is attributed to the power constraints and smaller antenna sizes of LEO satellites compared to GEO platforms, leading to lower Effective Isotropic Radiated Power (EIRP).
  • Complexity vs. Performance: Increasing architectural complexity does not necessarily yield better results. The three-hop GLHE model showed a 42% decrease in capacity compared to the simpler two-hop GHE model, as the additional LEO hop introduces more noise and hardware limitations without a proportional gain in signal strength.
  • Reliability and Elevation: Performance is heavily dependent on the elevation angle ($\alpha$). Below 20°, capacity drops sharply due to increased atmospheric thickness and clutter. In terms of reliability, the GHE architecture maintains a 1% outage probability at an SNR threshold of 24 dB, whereas the standalone GEO baseline fails at thresholds above -6 dB.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research demonstrates that integrating HAPs as relays (GHE) provides the optimal balance of capacity, reliability, and architectural simplicity for 6G NTNs. While this study provides a foundational physical-layer analysis, it represents a "snapshot" in time.

Future work will address the dynamic nature of these networks, including:

  • End-to-End Latency: Quantifying processing delays in multi-hop scenarios.
  • Mobility and Handover: Managing seamless connectivity as LEO satellites and HAPs move relative to ground stations.
  • Network Layer Performance: Expanding the analysis to include packet delivery rates and throughput under varying traffic loads.

Summary updated

Abstract

6th generation (6G) communication research is currently focusing on non-terrestrial networks (NTNs) to promote ubiquitous and ultra-high-capacity global connectivity. Specifically, multi-layered hierarchical networks, i.e., the orchestration among different aerial/space platforms, including Low and High Altitude Platforms (LAPs and HAPs), and satellites co-operating at different altitudes, currently represent one the most attractive technological options to solve coverage and latency constraints associated with the NTN paradigm. However, there are still several issues to be resolved for proper network design. In this work, we evaluate the performance of different multi-layered non-terrestrial configurations, and provide guidelines on the optimal working point(s) for which it is possible to achieve a good compromise between improved system flexibility and network performance, with respect to a baseline standalone deployment.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2021potential,
  author = {Dengke Wang and Marco Giordani and Mohamed‐Slim Alouini and Michele Zorzi},
  title = {{The Potential of Multilayered Hierarchical Nonterrestrial Networks for 6G: A Comparative Analysis Among Networking Architectures}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Veh. Technol. Mag},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=znu5JHsZ2zI},
}
Figure