The Impacts of Economic Growth on Per Capita Consumption-Based Co2 Emission Between China and United States

Qing NieInternational Journal of Business & Management Studies 2023 · DOI

Abstract

This paper investigates the impact of economic growth, population, and energy consumption on consumption-based CO2 emissions for a global panel of China and the U.S. By comparing two dynamic models—pooled Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) and Least Squares Dummy Variable (LSDV)—for the period 1990–2016, the study provides empirical evidence of the drivers behind environmental impact. The findings indicate significant positive impacts of economic growth and energy consumption, alongside a surprising negative effect of population on per capita CO2 emissions. Furthermore, the results highlight the differing responsibilities for reducing energy consumption and emissions between developing and developed nations.

Introduction

The relationship between economic prosperity and environmental degradation is often framed by the "Environmental Kuznets Curve" hypothesis, which suggests that environmental impact eventually decreases as a country reaches a certain level of wealth. However, validating this relationship is complex due to variables like population size and energy intensity.

This study addresses the tension between development and protection by focusing on consumption-based CO2 emissions. Unlike production-based metrics, which count emissions within a country's borders, consumption-based metrics account for the carbon footprint of goods and services actually used by the population. By comparing the United States (the world’s largest developed economy) with China (its largest developing economy), this research explores whether the drivers of pollution differ across stages of national development.

Methodology and Variables

The researcher employed two primary econometric approaches to analyze a panel dataset spanning 26 years:

  1. Pooled Ordinary Least Squares (OLS): A baseline model that treats all data points as a single group, effectively ignoring unique institutional or geographic differences between the two nations.
  2. Least Squares Dummy Variable (LSDV): A fixed-effects approach that adds dummy variables for each country. This captures country-specific intercepts, allowing the model to account for inherent differences such as policy frameworks or industrial structures.
Table of variables and expected economic implications

The study modeled CO2 emissions as a function of three independent variables: GDP per capita, total population, and energy consumption per capita. Data was sourced from the World Development Indicators (WDI) for the period 1990–2016.

Results and Analysis

The empirical results demonstrate that the LSDV model significantly outperformed the pooled OLS model, with an $R^2$ of 0.9982 compared to 0.9972. This confirms that the internal structures of the US and China are too distinct to be accurately represented by a single global average.

Comparison of Pooled OLS and LSDV regression results

Key Findings:

  • Economic Impact: A 1,000 USD increase in GDP per capita is associated with a 0.1-unit increase in per capita CO2 emissions (LSDV model, $p < 0.000$).
  • Energy Intensity: Energy consumption remains the strongest predictor of emissions. For every 1,000-unit increase in energy consumption per capita, CO2 emissions rise by approximately 0.32 units.
  • The Population Paradox: Interestingly, the LSDV model showed a negative correlation between population growth and per capita emissions (coefficient of -0.0108, $p < 0.000$). This suggests that in these economies, population growth may lead to urban efficiencies or infrastructure scaling that lowers the individual footprint.

Discussion: The Responsibility Gap

The data underscores a massive disparity in environmental impact. Between 1990 and 2016, the average American's carbon footprint was approximately 5.68 times larger than that of the average Chinese citizen. This disparity supports the argument that developed nations bear a disproportionate responsibility for historical and current consumption-based emissions.

While economic growth and energy use inevitably drive up emissions, the "starting points" for these two nations differ wildly. The higher F-statistic for the LSDV model (6790.80 vs 5885.88 for OLS) emphasizes that national context is critical when designing environmental policy.

Conclusion and Future Work

This study confirms that while economic growth remains a primary driver of CO2 emissions, the relationship is nuanced by national context and population dynamics. However, the research is limited by its exclusive focus on CO2, omitting other stressors like deforestation or water pollution. Furthermore, as the dataset ends in 2016, future research should incorporate more recent data to account for the rapid shift toward renewables and the impact of international climate agreements like the Paris Accord. Updated studies would likely reveal evolving trends in the decoupling of economic growth from carbon intensity.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper attempts to investigate the impact of economic growth, population, and energy consumption on consumption-based CO2 emissions for a global panel of China and U.S. with the comparison of two dynamic models, pooled OLS and LSDV, for the period 1990–2016. The empirical evidence indicates significant positive impacts of economic growth and energy consumption and negative effect of population on CO2 emissions for global panels. Besides, it shows the different responsibilities on reducing energy consumption and CO2 emissions between developing and developed countries.
BibTeX
@article{nie2023impacts,
  author = {Qing Nie},
  title = {{The Impacts of Economic Growth on Per Capita Consumption-Based Co2 Emission Between China and United States}},
  journal = {International Journal of Business \& Management Studies},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.56734/ijbms.v4n2a1},
}
Figure