Abstract
This study explores the nexus between foreign direct investment, financial development, energy consumption, economic growth and globalization for a selected panel of Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) countries over the period 1990–2016. After employing appropriate panel unit root tests, the Westerlund co-integration test, the DSUR long-run panel estimation approach and the Dumitrescu-Hurlin panel causality test, the results reveal a significant long-run relationship among the analyzed variables. The DSUR results show that energy consumption is boosted by 0.023 and 0.790% when a 1% rise occurs in foreign direct investment and economic growth. A 1% increase in financial development and globalization reduces energy consumption by 0.049 and 0.621%, respectively. We also found bidirectional relationships of energy consumption with financial development and foreign direct investment with globalization for the selected sample of our study. A unidirectional causal relationship exists, moving from energy consumption towards both financial development and foreign direct investment. An increase in FDI, the introduction of energy-efficient technology, and development of the financial sector lead to sustainable economic growth. The findings reveal the need to formulate policies that promote energy efficiency among Belt and Road (BR) countries.
Introduction
The Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) is one of the largest infrastructure and development projects in history, spanning dozens of countries with diverse economic profiles. A central debate among economists and environmental scientists is whether this massive influx of capital leads to "pollution havens"—where developed nations outsource energy-intensive industries—or whether it fosters a "technological leapfrog" through the transfer of green energy solutions.
This paper quantifies the interconnected links (the "nexus") between five key variables: Foreign Direct Investment (FDI), Financial Development (FD), Globalization (GLO), Economic Growth (GDP), and Energy Consumption (EC). By understanding these drivers, policymakers can better balance rapid economic expansion with the necessity of energy security and environmental sustainability.
Data and Methodology
The researchers utilized a panel dataset covering 26 years (1990–2016) for 59 BRI countries. The study draws from the World Development Indicators (WDI) and the KOF Index of Globalization.
To handle the complexities of multi-country data where countries influence one another (cross-sectional dependence), the study employed several sophisticated econometric techniques:
- Second-Generation Unit Root Tests (CIPS and CADF): Ensuring data stationarity for reliable long-term forecasting.
- Westerlund Co-integration Test: Determining if a long-run relationship exists between variables despite country heterogeneity.
- Dynamic Seemingly Unrelated Regression (DSUR): The core estimation approach, accounting for both country differences and "spillover" effects.
- Dumitrescu-Hurlin (DH) Panel Causality Test: Determining the direction of relationships between variables.
Key Results and Insights
The study identifies a significant long-run relationship among the analyzed variables. A central finding is that while economic expansion increases demand, institutional and global integration can mitigate it.
The Efficiency of Finance and Globalization
One of the most important findings is that Financial Development (FD) and Globalization (GLO) act as mitigators for energy use.
- Energy Reducers: A 1% increase in Financial Development and Globalization leads to a 0.049% and 0.621% decrease in energy consumption, respectively.
Well-developed financial systems provide the liquidity and credit necessary for firms to invest in advanced, energy-efficient machinery. Similarly, globalization facilitates the transfer of superior management practices and cleaner technologies from more developed partners.
The Growth Penalty
Unsurprisingly, raw economic growth and FDI remain the primary drivers of energy demand in the region.
- Energy Boosters: A 1% increase in FDI and GDP leads to a 0.023% and 0.790% increase in energy consumption, respectively. In many developing BRI regions, FDI flows primarily into manufacturing and industrial expansion, which are inherently energy-intensive.
Conclusion
The findings reveal that an increase in FDI, the introduction of energy-efficient technology, and the development of the financial sector are essential for sustainable economic growth. While the overall trend for the BRI is positive, country-wise analysis showed significant variation; for instance, FD stimulated energy consumption in 25 countries but reduced it in 16 others. This highlights that the "green" effect of finance depends heavily on local policy and industrial maturity. Policymakers should focus on formulating strategies that promote energy efficiency and leverage global integration to adopt cleaner technologies.
Summary updated