The Impacts of Non-Renewable Energy Consumption and Education Expenditure on CO2 Emission Intensity of Real GDP in China

He Huang, Qiu Shi Deng, Liang LiResearch Square 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Background: With economic development, China has become the world's largest CO2 emitter. Given that climate warming has increasingly become the focus of the international community, the Chinese government committed to reducing its CO2 emission intensity substantially. Prior studies find that the evolution of economic structure and technological progress can reduce CO2 emissions, but lack consideration of CO2 emissions and output as a whole. In addition, the role of education expenditure is relatively overlooked. This paper contributes to the literature by examining the link between CO2 emission intensity, non-renewable energy consumption, and education expenditure in China during 1971-2014. Results: We use the ARDL approach and find that in the long run, every 1% increase in non-renewable energy consumption results in a 0.92% increase in CO2 intensity, while every 1% increase in operational education expenditure reduces the CO2 intensity by 0.86%. In the short term, 36% of the deviation from the long-run equilibrium is corrected in the next period. Conclusions: We draw two important conclusions and make policy recommendations. First, as long as the increase in operational educational expenditure exceeds the increase in non-renewable energy consumption, CO2 intensity of real GDP will decrease in the long run. Second, the increase in non-renewable energy consumption will result in an increase in CO2 intensity of real GDP. Therefore, gradually increasing the proportion of clean energy consumption is another powerful starting point for China to achieve its goal of reducing CO2 intensity.

Introduction

As the world's largest CO2 emitter, China faces immense international pressure to decarbonize while maintaining economic growth. To balance these competing priorities, the Chinese government focuses on reducing CO2 emission intensity—the amount of CO2 emitted per unit of real GDP.

Historically, researchers have studied how industrial structure, foreign trade, and urbanization impact emissions. However, the role of human capital—specifically, government expenditure on education—has been largely overlooked. Furthermore, simply reducing non-renewable energy consumption is a double-edged sword: it cuts emissions, but it also cuts economic output (GDP). This study investigates the macroeconomic relationship between CO2 emission intensity, non-renewable energy consumption, and public education expenditure in China from 1971 to 2014.

Methodology

The authors employ the Autoregressive Distributed Lag (ARDL) bounds testing approach. This econometric technique is particularly well-suited for this study because it performs reliably on small sample sizes (44 annual observations) and can test for cointegrating (long-term) relationships even if the underlying variables have mixed orders of integration.

The study relies on historical data from the World Bank’s World Development Indicators (WDI) for China (1971-2014). The primary variables are:

  • CO2_PG: CO2 emissions intensity of real GDP (kg per constant 2010 US$).
  • EN_PC: Non-renewable energy consumption per capita (kg of oil equivalent).
  • EDU_PC: Education expenditure per capita (constant 2010 US$).

The methodology follows a standard time-series pipeline, starting with unit root tests (ADF, PP, and KPSS) to ensure none of the variables are integrated of order 2 or higher.

Unit root test results for the study variables

The core of the analysis involves comparing two models to see if a stable long-run relationship exists.

ARDL model equations for CO2 intensity

Key Insights and Results

The Missing Stabilizer

A critical finding is that there is no long-term cointegrating relationship between CO2 intensity and non-renewable energy consumption on their own (Equation 1). Because cutting fossil fuels reduces both emissions and GDP simultaneously, the net effect on the ratio (intensity) is ambiguous. A stable, long-term relationship only emerges when education expenditure is added to the model (Equation 2). Education acts as a catalyst for upgrading industrial structures and driving technological progress, which decouples economic growth from carbon emissions.

Long-run and Short-run Dynamics

  • Long-run Elasticities: In the long term, a 1% increase in non-renewable energy consumption per capita leads to a 0.92% increase in CO2 intensity. Conversely, a 1% increase in education expenditure per capita yields a 0.86% decrease in CO2 intensity.
  • Short-run Dynamics: The Error Correction Model (ECM) yielded a coefficient of -0.36, indicating that 36% of any deviation from long-term equilibrium is corrected within the next year.

The "Race of Rates"

The findings suggest a straightforward policy heuristic: as long as the percentage increase in operational education expenditure outpaces the percentage increase in non-renewable energy consumption, a country's CO2 intensity will decrease over the long run. Historically, China's non-renewable energy consumption grew much faster (32.87x) than education spending (4.81x) during the sample period, explaining the difficulty in reducing intensity.

Conclusion and Policy Recommendations

The study concludes that increasing public education expenditure is a novel and powerful lever for climate mitigation. As long as the growth in education spending exceeds the growth in non-renewable energy consumption, CO2 intensity will decrease. Additionally, transitioning to clean energy remains a vital strategy.

While the study is limited by its historical scope (ending in 2014) and broad definition of "education expenditure," it provides a strong foundation for future research. Applying this ARDL framework to other developing nations or incorporating renewable energy data could further refine these insights for the post-Paris Agreement era.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> BackgroundWith the economic development, China has become the world's largest CO2 emitter. Given that climate warming has increasingly become the focus of the international community, Chinese government committed to reducing its CO2 emission intensity substantially. Prior studies find that the evolution of economic structure and technological progress can reduce CO2 emissions, but lack of considering CO2 emissions and output as a whole. In addition, the role of education expenditure is relatively overlooked. This paper contributes to the literature by examining the link of CO2 emission intensity, non-renewable energy consumption and education expenditure in China during 1971-2014. ResultsWe use the ARDL approach and find that in the long run, every 1% increase in non-renewable energy consumption results in a 0.92% increase in CO2 intensity, while every 1% increase in operational education expenditure reduces the CO2 intensity by 0.86%. In the short term, 36% of the deviation from the long run equilibrium is corrected in the next period.ConclusionsWe draw out two important conclusions and make important policy recommendations. First and foremost, as long as the increase in operational educational expenditure exceeds the increase in non-renewable energy consumption, CO2 intensity of real GDP will decrease in the long run. This means that in the development stage when economic activities are still highly dependent on non-renewable energy sources, the Chinese government should continue to vigorously increase expenditures on public education. Second, the increase in non-renewable energy consumption will result in an increase in CO2 intensity of real GDP. Therefore, gradually increasing the proportion of clean energy consumption in the energy nexus is another powerful starting point for China to achieve its goal of reducing CO2 intensity of real GDP.JEL ClassificationC32. I2. Q4. Q53. Q56.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2021impacts,
  author = {He Huang and Qiu Shi Deng and Liang Li},
  title = {{The Impacts of Non-Renewable Energy Consumption and Education Expenditure on CO2 Emission Intensity of Real GDP in China}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-233481/v1},
}
Figure