The effect of long range interactions on the stability of classical and quantum solids

Debanjan Chowdhury, Amit DuttaarXiv 2008 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We generalise the celebrated Peierls' argument to study the stability of a long-range interacting classical solid. Long-range interaction implies that all the atomic oscillators are coupled to each other via a harmonic potential, though the coupling strength decays as a power-law $1/x^\alpha$, where $x$ is the distance between the oscillators. We show that for the range parameter $\alpha < 2$, the long-range interaction dominates and the one-dimensional system retains a crystalline order even at a finite temperature whereas for $\alpha \geq 2$, the long-range crystalline order vanishes even at an infinitesimally small temperature. We also study the effect of quantum fluctuations on the melting behaviour of a one-dimensional solid at $T=0$, extending Peierls' arguments to the case of quantum oscillators.

Introduction: The Fragility of One-Dimensional Solids

In condensed matter physics, the stability of crystalline order is a fundamental concern. Standard theorems, such as the Mermin-Wagner theorem, suggest that one-dimensional (1D) and two-dimensional (2D) crystals are inherently unstable when governed by short-range interactions. In these systems, thermal fluctuations at any temperature above absolute zero are sufficient to disrupt the long-range order, causing the lattice to "melt."

However, many physical systems are characterized by long-range interactions where the force between particles decays slowly as a power-law, $1/x^\alpha$. This paper investigates whether these long-range forces can stabilize 1D and 2D solids against thermal and quantum fluctuations.

Methodology: Generalizing Peierls' Argument

The researchers utilize a generalized version of Peierls’ argument to assess stability. The core of this approach involves calculating the mean-square displacement of an atom from its equilibrium position, $\langle \delta^2 \rangle$. If this value remains finite as the system size increases, the crystal is stable; if it diverges, the crystal is unstable.

Schematic representation of (a) a 1D chain and (b) a 2D lattice of coupled oscillators.

The model treats the solid as a collection of oscillators coupled by a potential decaying as $1/x^\alpha$. By analyzing the dispersion relations—how the vibration frequency $\omega$ relates to the wavenumber $k$—the authors found that long-range interactions alter the standard linear relationship ($\omega \sim k$) to a power-law form ($\omega \sim k^{(\alpha-1)/2}$). Integrating these vibrational modes across the system allows for the determination of the total displacement fluctuations.

Key Insights: The Role of the Decay Exponent $\alpha$

The stability of the system is dictated by the exponent $\alpha$. In a 1D classical system at finite temperature ($T > 0$), the long-range "tugging" between distant atoms is strong enough to maintain order if $\alpha < 2$. Once $\alpha \geq 2$, the interaction decays too quickly to counteract thermal noise, and the system becomes unstable.

A significant finding of this work is the "Quantum-Classical Correspondence." The researchers demonstrate that a $d$-dimensional quantum system at absolute zero ($T=0$) is mathematically analogous to a $(d+1)$-dimensional classical system at finite temperature. Because quantum fluctuations (governed by the uncertainty principle) are generally less disruptive than thermal fluctuations, 1D quantum solids exhibit a higher stability threshold, remaining ordered for $\alpha < 3$.

Results and Stability Criteria

The findings provide a comprehensive map of stability across different dimensions and interaction types. The introduction of long-range interactions allows for stable crystalline phases in dimensions where they were previously thought impossible under short-range assumptions.

Summary of stability criteria for classical and quantum solids in various dimensions.

As shown in the table above, the marginal cases (where $\alpha=2$ for classical 1D or $\alpha=3$ for quantum 1D) result in logarithmic divergence of fluctuations. This represents a slow transition to instability as the system size grows.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While this generalized Peierls' argument effectively predicts the existence of stable phases, it does not determine specific melting temperatures ($T_c$). Furthermore, the harmonic approximation used here does not account for topological defects like dislocations, which are central to many melting theories. Future experimental work, potentially using mercury chain salts ($Hg_{3-\delta}AsF_6$), could help validate these theoretical thresholds and further explore the interplay between long-range forces and lattice stability.

Summary updated

Abstract

We generalise the celebrated Peierls' argument to study the stability of a long-range interacting classical solid. Long-range interaction implies that all the atomic oscillators are coupled to each other via a harmonic potential, though the coupling strength decays as a power-law $1/x^α$, where $x$ is the distance between the oscillators. We show that for the range parameter $α&lt;2$, the long-range interaction dominates and the one-dimensional system retains a crystalline order even at a finite temperature whereas for $α\geq2$, the long-range crystalline order vanishes even at an infinitesimally small temperature. We also study the effect of quantum fluctuations on the melting behaviour of a one-dimensional solid at T=0, extending Peierls' arguments to the case of quantum oscillators.
BibTeX
@misc{chowdhury2008effect,
  author = {Debanjan Chowdhury and Amit Dutta},
  title = {{The effect of long range interactions on the stability of classical and quantum solids}},
  year = {2008},
  eprint = {0801.0299},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/0801.0299},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure