Clustered Wigner-crystal phases of cold polar molecules in arrays of one-dimensional tubes

Michael Knap, Erez Berg, Martin Ganahl, Eugene DemlerPhysical 2012 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: We analyze theoretically polar molecules confined in planar arrays of one-dimensional tubes. In the classical limit, if the number of tubes is finite, new types of "clustered Wigner crystals" with increasingly many molecules per unit cell can be stabilized by tuning the in-plane angle between the dipolar moments and the tube direction. Quantum mechanically these phases melt into distinct "clustered Luttinger liquids." We calculate the phase diagram of the system and study the quantum melting of the clustered phases. We find that the requirements for exploring these phases are reachable in current experiments and discuss possible experimental signatures.

Introduction

In many-body physics, "emulsion" phases—complex structures like bubbles or stripes—emerge from competing long-range interactions. While predicted in electronic systems like two-dimensional electron gases, these phases are notoriously difficult to probe directly. This research proposes cold polar molecules as a solution. These molecules possess strong, long-range, and anisotropic dipolar interactions that can be precisely controlled via external electric fields. By confining these molecules to an array of parallel 1D tubes, the authors investigate the emergence of "clustered" phases that are more accessible for experimental observation and manipulation than traditional solid-state counterparts.

Methodology

The study utilizes a combination of analytical theory and high-performance numerical simulations:

  • Classical Energy Minimization: Ground states in the classical limit were identified by minimizing interaction energy across various particle densities and dipole tilt angles.
  • Density Matrix Renormalization Group (DMRG): This numerical technique was employed to solve 1D quantum systems, providing particle densities and correlation functions.
  • Luttinger Liquid Theory: The authors used bosonization to describe the transition (melting) of clustered crystals into quantum liquids.
  • Multipole Expansion: To ensure experimental relevance, a multipole expansion accounted for finite tube width and small dipole orientation fluctuations.

Key Insights: The Magic of the Tilt

A central discovery is that the interaction between molecules in adjacent tubes is highly sensitive to the dipole tilt angle $\phi$. By adjusting this angle, researchers can induce attraction between molecules in different tubes while maintaining repulsion within the same tube. This leads to the formation of stable clusters containing $q$ particles.

Schematic of the 1D tube array with tilted dipoles (a) and the resulting phase diagram (b) showing regions of stability for different cluster sizes q.

As the cluster size $q$ increases, the system exhibits increasingly classical behavior. This is reflected in the Luttinger parameter $K$, which scales linearly with $q$. These clustered phases are remarkably robust, persisting even when particle counts do not perfectly match cluster sizes or under harmonic confinement.

Results and Experimental Signatures

The theoretical analysis yielded detailed phase diagrams showing "lobes" of stability for various cluster sizes ($q=2, 3, 4, \dots$). Crucially, these clustered phases survive significant quantum fluctuations. Even when kinetic energy reaches approximately 10% of the interaction energy, clustering remains clearly visible in density profiles.

DMRG density profiles for different interaction strengths and cluster sizes, demonstrating the persistence of clustering in the quantum regime.

Candidates like NaCs and LiCs are identified as ideal for experimental verification due to their large dipole moments. The authors suggest that these phases could be detected using existing techniques such as elastic light scattering or noise correlation analysis of time-of-flight images.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While clustering is stable for finite tube arrays, the authors note that an infinite 2D array might lead to total phase separation. Future research will focus on the excitation spectra of these systems, specifically looking for "optical branches"—higher-energy vibrations within the clusters themselves. Given that the crossover temperature is proportional to dipolar energy, these exotic phases should be reachable in current ultracold atom experiments.

Summary updated

Abstract

We analyze theoretically polar molecules confined in planar arrays of one-dimensional tubes. In the classical limit, if the number of tubes is finite, new types of ``clustered Wigner crystals'' with increasingly many molecules per unit cell can be stabilized by tuning the in-plane angle between the dipolar moments and the tube direction. Quantum mechanically these phases melt into distinct ``clustered Luttinger liquids.'' We calculate the phase diagram of the system and study the quantum melting of the clustered phases. We find that the requirements for exploring these phases are reachable in current experiments and discuss possible experimental signatures.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{knap2012clustered,
  author = {Michael Knap and Erez Berg and Martin Ganahl and Eugene Demler},
  title = {{Clustered Wigner-crystal phases of cold polar molecules in arrays of one-dimensional tubes}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevb.86.064501},
}
Figure