Abstract
Adolescents (ages 15–18) often occupy a medical "gray zone," receiving care in either pediatric or general emergency departments (EDs). This study investigates how the ED setting influences the use of computed tomography (CT) for common complaints like headaches and abdominal pain. Findings indicate that adolescents in general EDs are significantly more likely to receive CT scans than those in pediatric EDs within the same hospital, despite no difference in diagnostic yield.
Introduction
While the medical community has successfully reduced CT use in young children due to concerns over ionizing radiation and lifetime cancer risks, adolescents remain a vulnerable outlier. Physically similar to adults but biologically still developing, they are frequently funneled into general EDs where the "culture of caution" regarding radiation is often less pronounced than in pediatric-specific settings. This study sought to determine if the physical environment and the specialty of the treating department independently influence the decision to order a CT scan.
Methodology
A retrospective chart review was conducted at Seoul National University Hospital, covering a five-year period (2010–2014). The researchers analyzed data from 1,387 adolescent patients (aged 15–18) presenting with either a headache or abdominal pain. By examining a single tertiary hospital that operates both a general and a pediatric ED, the study controlled for institutional resources and protocols.
The analysis employed multivariable logistic regression to calculate Odds Ratios (ORs) for CT use, adjusting for confounding factors such as age, sex, analgesic use, and underlying diseases. "Positive CT findings" were strictly defined—for example, intracranial hemorrhage for brain scans and appendicitis or bowel obstruction for abdominal scans—to evaluate whether increased scanning led to more frequent diagnoses.
Results
The quantitative gap between the two settings was significant across both primary complaints:
- Headache Cohort: CT rates were 42.4% in the general ED compared to 20.5% in the pediatric ED ($P < 0.001$).
- Abdominal Pain Cohort: CT rates were 29.0% in the general ED versus 18.4% in the pediatric ED ($P < 0.001$).
Risk factor analysis identified the general ED setting as the strongest predictor for receiving a CT. For headache patients, the adjusted Odds Ratio was 3.95, meaning they were nearly four times more likely to be scanned in the general ED. For abdominal pain, the OR was 1.76. Crucially, the rate of positive findings did not differ significantly between groups (6-8% for headaches; 56-61% for abdominal pain), suggesting that the higher scanning rate in the general ED represents over-utilization rather than improved diagnostic sensitivity.
Discussion
The most compelling aspect of this study is the "same hospital" control. Since the same pool of residents often rotates through both EDs, the disparity in CT rates suggests that the environment and supervising culture of the pediatric ED drive lower radiation exposure. Pediatric departments demonstrated a "pediatric-first" diagnostic mindset, prioritizing safety by utilizing ultrasound or MRI more frequently.
The study also highlights the "Adolescent Gap." Older adolescents in the general ED were scanned at much higher rates than younger adolescents in the pediatric ED, despite having similar biological risks from radiation. This suggests that clinical decision-making is heavily influenced by the adult-oriented norms of the general ED.
Conclusion
The ED setting significantly impacts the diagnostic pathway for adolescent patients. The higher utilization of CT in general EDs without a corresponding increase in diagnostic yield points to a need for standardized, child-friendly protocols across all emergency settings. Implementing radiation awareness campaigns and "pediatric-style" triage in general EDs could help protect adolescent patients from unnecessary radiation exposure.
Summary updated