Abstract
Overall, computed tomography (CT) use in pediatric patients has decreased significantly since 2007 following targeted clinical interventions. While pediatric ultrasound (US) use also showed a decreasing trend, the abdominal US/CT ratio increased, indicating a shift toward non-ionizing modalities. However, adolescents remain an outlier, with abdominal CT rates failing to show a similar decline.
Introduction
Computed tomography is a critical diagnostic tool, but its use in children carries significant risks. Pediatric tissues are more sensitive to ionizing radiation due to active cellular division, and children have a longer life expectancy to manifest potential radiation-induced neoplasms. Despite these concerns, CT utilization surged globally during the late 1990s and early 2000s. This study investigates the impact of institutional efforts to prioritize ultrasound and implement evidence-based guidelines to reduce radiation exposure in a high-volume pediatric emergency department (PED).
Methods and Data
Researchers conducted a retrospective observational study at a tertiary hospital in Seoul, Korea, analyzing electronic medical records from 2000 to 2014. The dataset included 196,371 pediatric visits, 12,996 CT scans (brain and abdomen), and 12,424 abdominal US examinations.
In 2007, the department implemented a series of interventions designed to curb unnecessary CT use:
- Physician Education: Training PED doctors to prioritize US over CT.
- Radiology Consultation: Establishing a "hotline" for direct discussion of alternative imaging with radiologists.
- Clinical Guidelines: Adopting PECARN (Pediatric Emergency Care Applied Research Network) rules for head trauma in 2009.
- Performance Feedback: Providing direct feedback to physicians when "unnecessary" CTs were performed.
Trends were analyzed using piecewise Poisson regression to compare utilization slopes before and after the 2007 intervention.
Key Results
The study identified 2007 as a clear inflection point. The overall CT rate peaked at 116.7 per 1,000 visits in 2007 before dropping to 36.8 per 1,000 visits by 2014.
Modality Shifts and Age-Specific Trends
The most dramatic decline occurred in brain CTs for infants, likely driven by the successful implementation of PECARN guidelines. In abdominal imaging, the preference shifted toward ultrasound; the US/CT ratio increased significantly after 2007 (coefficient of 2.68; 95% CI, 1.87 to 3.49).
However, adolescents (ages 13–18) presented a different pattern. While CT rates for younger children dropped, adolescent abdominal CT usage did not show a statistically significant decrease. This is attributed to larger body habitus—which can limit US clarity—and more complex, adult-like clinical presentations.
Patient Safety
Importantly, the reduction in CT usage did not appear to compromise patient safety. Ward and ICU admission rates remained stable throughout the study period, suggesting that the shift toward more conservative imaging did not lead to missed diagnoses of severely ill patients.
Conclusion
Institutional policy and physician education can effectively reverse trends in over-utilization of CT scans in pediatric settings. While significant progress has been made in reducing radiation exposure for infants and younger children, further work is needed to optimize diagnostic pathways for adolescents. Future research should explore whether improved US techniques or new clinical decision rules can help bring adolescent radiation exposure in line with younger cohorts.
Summary updated