Abstract
This study investigates the impact of structured clinical communication on guardian preferences for cranial computed tomography (CT) in pediatric minor head injury cases. By providing a formal explanation of risks and benefits based on institutional clinical practice guidelines, emergency physicians significantly reduced guardian preference for imaging, potentially mitigating unnecessary radiation exposure in children.
Introduction
Head injuries represent a substantial portion of pediatric emergency department (ED) visits. While cranial CT scans are the definitive tool for diagnosing intracranial injuries, they involve exposure to ionizing radiation. Children are particularly vulnerable to these risks, with research indicating a small but measurable increase in the lifetime risk of leukemia and brain tumors following CT exposure.
Clinicians typically utilize decision rules, such as the Pediatric Emergency Care Applied Research Network (PECARN) rule, to determine the necessity of imaging. However, parental anxiety often leads to significant pressure on physicians to perform CT scans even when clinical criteria are not met. This study explores whether a structured, guideline-based explanation can effectively bridge the gap between parental concern and evidence-based medical practice.
Methods
A prospective survey study was conducted at a metropolitan tertiary hospital ED between 2010 and 2012. The study included 208 guardians of children under the age of 16 presenting with minor head injuries (defined by a Glasgow Coma Scale score of 15).
Upon initial assessment, a board-certified emergency physician examined the child and then delivered a structured explanation regarding the risks (specifically radiation-induced cancer risks estimated at 1 in 1,000 to 5,000) and benefits of CT scans. This explanation was based on an institutional clinical practice guideline derived from the PECARN rule. Guardians recorded their preference for a CT scan on a 100-mm Visual Analog Scale (VAS) both before and after the physician's explanation, where "0" indicated no desire for a scan and "100" indicated a strong desire. A 90-day telephone follow-up was performed to ensure no clinically important traumatic brain injuries (CiTBI) were missed.
Results
The study population consisted of 208 patient-guardian pairs, with a mean patient age of 3.6 years. The majority of guardians (75%) were female and highly educated (91.8% with at least some college education).
Key findings include:
- Reduction in Preference: The mean guardian preference score significantly decreased from 46.7 mm to 17.4 mm following the physician's explanation (P < 0.01).
- Decreased Imaging Rates: The actual rate of CT scans performed during the study period was 7.3%, a notable decrease from the historical control rate of 13.6% recorded prior to guideline implementation.
- Predictors of Change: Multivariate analysis identified the initial pre-explanation preference and the perceived strength of the physician's recommendation as the primary factors influencing the change in guardian preference.
- Safety Outcomes: The 90-day follow-up confirmed that no children discharged without a scan subsequently presented with a serious brain injury, validating the safety of the guideline-based approach.
Discussion
The data revealed a significant knowledge gap; nearly half (47.1%) of the guardians were unaware of the radiation risks associated with CT scans prior to the intervention. Interestingly, previous experience with CT scans did not correlate with better knowledge of these risks.
The most substantial shifts in preference occurred among guardians who initially expressed a high desire for imaging. This suggests that parental demand for CT scans is often rooted in a lack of information rather than an immutable preference. The study highlights that the "strength of the physician’s recommendation" is a critical variable; clear, evidence-based communication can align parental expectations with clinical best practices.
Limitations and Conclusion
While the results are promising, the study has limitations. The survey was conducted during daytime hours (10 am to 10 pm), potentially missing different demographic patterns associated with overnight visits. Additionally, the high education level of the participants may limit the generalizability of the findings to populations with lower health literacy.
In conclusion, providing guardians with a structured explanation of the risks and benefits of cranial CT scans—aligned with established clinical guidelines—is an effective strategy for reducing unnecessary imaging in pediatric minor head injuries. This approach supports shared decision-making and enhances the safety of pediatric emergency care.
Summary updated