The compensation incentive effect of athletes: A structural equation model

Huan Zhao, Zhaoxia Liu, Susu Zhang, Feiyan Xiao, Meng Liu, Ruiyuan Li, Liqing Zhang, Chengcheng XuFrontiers in Psychology 2022 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates the factors driving motivation among professional athletes using a structural equation model (SEM). By analyzing survey data from 352 athletes across six Chinese provinces, the research evaluates an assessment index system comprising direct and indirect economic and non-economic compensation. The findings reveal that direct economic, direct non-economic, and indirect non-economic satisfaction significantly enhance the incentive effect. Conversely, indirect economic compensation—such as insurance and retirement benefits—showed no significant impact. Direct economic satisfaction, particularly through bonuses and subsidies, emerged as the most influential factor. These results suggest that athlete compensation strategies should prioritize immediate financial rewards and social recognition to maximize performance.

Introduction

As China evolves from a "large" sports nation into a global "strong" sports power, the management of its elite human capital—the athletes—has become a critical area of study. Historically, the Chinese sports system operated under an egalitarian, planned-economy model. However, the transition to a market-oriented system has introduced complexities, including widening income disparities and inconsistent incentive structures.

The central challenge lies in understanding what truly motivates an athlete to sustain high-intensity training and peak performance. While "compensation" is often equated solely with a paycheck, this study proposes a broader "comprehensive compensation" framework. This framework examines how various levers—ranging from base salary to social status and career autonomy—contribute to the "incentive effect," defined as an athlete's internal motivation and willingness to exert effort.

Methodology: The Structural Equation Model

To decode these relationships, the researchers employed Structural Equation Modeling (SEM). SEM is a powerful multivariate statistical tool ideal for analyzing "latent variables"—psychological constructs like "satisfaction" or "motivation" that cannot be measured directly but are inferred from observed survey data.

The study utilized a primary dataset of 352 valid responses from athletes in Guangdong, Liaoning, Hunan, Jilin, Gansu, and Yunnan provinces. This sample represents a diverse cross-section of China's economic regions. Participants, primarily aged 19–24, represented sports including swimming, athletics, basketball, and soccer.

Figure 1: The structural equation model used to analyze the relationship between compensation factors and the incentive effect.

The model categorized compensation into four distinct quadrants:

  1. Direct Economic ($ζ_1$): Basic salary, bonuses, and subsidies.
  2. Indirect Economic ($ζ_2$): Retirement placement and medical insurance.
  3. Direct Non-Economic ($ζ_3$): Social status, leadership attention, and the training environment.
  4. Indirect Non-Economic ($ζ_4$): Career achievement, training autonomy, and promotion opportunities.

Key Results and Analysis

The SEM analysis demonstrated a high-quality fit (GFI = 0.953, CFI = 0.968), validating the proposed theoretical structure. The path coefficients revealed the following impacts on the incentive effect ($η$):

  • Direct Economic Satisfaction ($ζ_1$): This was the strongest motivator, with a path coefficient of 0.371 ($p < 0.001$). Interestingly, bonuses and subsidies carried more weight than the base salary, suggesting that performance-linked rewards are more effective than fixed pay.
  • Direct Non-Economic Satisfaction ($ζ_3$): This factor was the second most powerful (Path coefficient 0.297, $p < 0.001$). It highlights the importance of "leadership attention" and social recognition in the athlete's psychological contract.
  • Indirect Non-Economic Satisfaction ($ζ_4$): This also showed a significant positive effect (Path coefficient 0.150, $p < 0.01$), particularly for elite athletes who value autonomy and national honor.
  • The Welfare Paradox ($ζ_2$): Surprisingly, indirect economic satisfaction showed no statistically significant impact ($p = 0.756$). Benefits like insurance and retirement plans failed to move the needle on daily motivation.

Discussion: Why Welfare Fails to Motivate

The rejection of the hypothesis regarding indirect economic compensation is a key finding. The authors suggest that for young athletes in their physical prime, future-dated benefits like retirement placement or medical insurance are too abstract. These "hygiene factors" may prevent dissatisfaction if absent, but they do not actively drive the intense, day-to-day effort required in professional sports.

In contrast, the high weight of direct non-economic factors underscores the "Status as a Stimulus" effect. Athletes have a profound need to feel valued by their organizations and society. When coaches and leaders provide direct attention and when the public grants high social status, athletes feel a greater sense of obligation and drive.

Conclusion and Recommendations

The study concludes that to optimize athlete performance, sports management must move beyond a one-size-fits-all salary model.

  1. Prioritize Variable Pay: Compensation design should focus on bonuses and subsidies that are directly tied to performance outcomes.
  2. Enhance Social Recognition: Organizations should invest in the "direct non-economic" sphere by improving the training environment and ensuring athletes receive public and organizational recognition.
  3. Grant Autonomy to Elites: For high-level athletes, providing training autonomy and clear career advancement paths (indirect non-economic rewards) is essential for long-term retention and motivation.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study explores the compensation incentive effect of athletes. Based on the related literature, we proposed theoretical hypotheses on the compensation incentive effect and established an assessment index system of the compensation incentive effect for athletes. A structural equation model was used to test the survey data of 352 athletes in six provinces to discover the truth of the compensation incentive effect. The results suggested that direct economic compensation satisfaction, direct non-economic compensation satisfaction, and indirect non-economic compensation satisfaction had significant positive effects on the compensation incentive effect of athletes, while indirect economic compensation satisfaction showed no significant effect. Moreover, the evaluation results of athletes' compensation incentive effect showed that direct economic compensation satisfaction contributed the most to the influence factor of the compensation incentive effect. Therefore, the evaluation of athletes' compensation incentive effect should focus on variables of direct economic compensation satisfaction, i.e., basic compensation satisfaction, bonus income satisfaction, and subsidy satisfaction. Finally, some strategies and recommendations were suggested to improve the compensation design for athletes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2022compensation,
  author = {Huan Zhao and Zhaoxia Liu and Susu Zhang and Feiyan Xiao and Meng Liu and Ruiyuan Li and Liqing Zhang and Chengcheng Xu},
  title = {{The compensation incentive effect of athletes: A structural equation model}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2022.1034855},
}
Figure